The CTA cancelled BIR assessment notices and set aside garnishment after defective substituted service of the PAN and FLD/FAN violated tax due process.
Taxpayers facing bank garnishment may still challenge collection when the BIR cannot prove that the Preliminary Assessment Notice and Final Assessment Notice were validly served. For companies under audit, this ruling reinforces a practical point: collection remedies such as distraint, levy, and garnishment must rest on a valid assessment, and a valid assessment requires strict compliance with due process.
Background of the Assessment Dispute
The taxpayer, a domestic corporation, was investigated for taxable year 2017 after receiving a Letter of Authority on April 16, 2019. The BIR later issued a Notice of Informal Conference identifying alleged deficiency income tax, value-added tax, and expanded withholding tax exposures totaling ₱31,574,967.98. The BIR then issued a Preliminary Assessment Notice dated December 14, 2020 for alleged deficiency income tax and VAT totaling ₱35,131,512.01, followed by a Formal Letter of Demand and Final Assessment Notices dated January 12, 2021 assessing ₱35,378,902.78, inclusive of interests and compromise penalties.
The taxpayer denied receiving the PAN and the FLD/FAN. The BIR proceeded with collection by issuing a Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy dated October 28, 2021 and an undated Warrant of Garnishment against the taxpayer’s HSBC bank account. The taxpayer received the Warrant of Garnishment on January 26, 2022 and filed its Petition for Review on February 21, 2022. The dispute reached the Court of Tax Appeals in Regus PLT Centre, Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (CTA Case No. 10778).
The Taxpayer’s Core Argument
The taxpayer argued that the assessment was void because it never received the PAN and the FLD/FAN. Without proper service of these notices, the taxpayer claimed it was deprived of the opportunity to respond to the BIR’s findings, contest the proposed assessment, and file a valid protest. It also challenged the Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy and the Warrant of Garnishment on the ground that collection cannot proceed from void assessment notices.
The taxpayer also pointed out that it had closed its registered Philamlife Tower office and that the BIR should have sent notices to its branch office in PBCom Tower. The BIR countered that the taxpayer failed to update its registered address through BIR Form 1905 and that the notices were served by substituted service at the registered address.
The Court First Confirmed Its Jurisdiction Over the Garnishment Dispute
The Commissioner argued that the Petition for Review was filed out of time because the taxpayer allegedly knew of the assessment before it physically received the Warrant of Garnishment. The Court rejected this argument.
The Court explained that its appellate jurisdiction is not confined to disputed assessments alone. It also covers other matters arising under the National Internal Revenue Code or laws administered by the BIR, including the validity of collection remedies such as warrants of distraint, levy, and garnishment. Because the taxpayer filed its Petition for Review within 30 days from receipt of the Warrant of Garnishment on January 26, 2022, the appeal filed on February 21, 2022 was timely.
Failure to Update a Registered Address Did Not Automatically Save the BIR’s Service
The Court did not fully accept the taxpayer’s argument that the BIR was required to serve the assessment notices at the PBCom Tower branch office. It noted that the cancellation of a registered head office or update of registration details requires proper filing with the BIR, including BIR Form 1905. The taxpayer’s own witness admitted that the company had not yet updated the BIR through Form 1905 regarding the closure of the Philamlife Tower office.
This part of the ruling is important for businesses. A taxpayer that moves offices, closes a registered address, or shifts operations to another branch should formally update its BIR registration. Informal communications with BIR personnel may not be enough. Failure to update registration details can expose the taxpayer to the risk that notices will continue to be sent to the old registered address.
Why the Assessment Notices Were Still Held Invalid
Even though the taxpayer failed to properly update its registered address, the Court still ruled in its favor because the BIR failed to prove valid substituted service of the assessment notices.
Under Section 228 of the Tax Code and Revenue Regulations No. 12-99, as amended by Revenue Regulations No. 18-2013, a taxpayer must be informed in writing of the law and facts on which an assessment is based. The taxpayer must also be given a meaningful opportunity to respond. Assessment notices may be served personally, by substituted service, or by mail, but each mode has specific requirements.
For substituted service, the BIR must show that personal service was not practicable and that the circumstances for substituted service were present. If no person is found at the taxpayer’s registered or known address, the revenue officers must bring a barangay official and two disinterested witnesses to personally observe and attest to the absence. The notice must then be given to the barangay official, and the required details must be reflected in the notice and written report.
For the PAN, the written report stated that substituted service was used because building administrative personnel did not allow entry due to COVID-19 restrictions. The Court found this insufficient. The evidence did not adequately prove that the PAN was actually served on and received by the barangay official identified in the documents. The BIR’s witnesses also failed to identify and authenticate the signatures of the barangay official and the witnesses appearing in the acknowledgment receipt.
For the FLD/FAN, the evidentiary gap was even more serious. The BIR presented only the written report on personal or substituted service. It failed to submit the acknowledgment receipt containing the required details under the applicable revenue regulations and RMO No. 40-2019. Because of these deficiencies, the Court held that the fact of substituted service, or actual receipt by the taxpayer, was never established.
The Result: Assessment Notices Cancelled and Collection Enjoined
The Court granted the Petition for Review. It withdrew and set aside the Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy dated October 28, 2021 and the undated Warrant of Garnishment issued against the taxpayer. It also cancelled and set aside the PAN dated December 14, 2020 and the FLD/FAN dated January 12, 2021 for taxable year 2017.
Because the assessment notices were void, the collection remedies had no legal foundation. The Commissioner was enjoined and prohibited from collecting or taking further action on the subject deficiency taxes for taxable year 2017.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and CFOs
This ruling carries two practical lessons. First, taxpayers should promptly update their BIR registration details whenever they change, close, or transfer offices. A taxpayer cannot simply assume that the BIR will use a different address because some officers may know of the move. A properly filed registration update remains the safer and more defensible course.
Second, the BIR must strictly prove service of assessment notices before it can rely on them for collection. A warrant of garnishment can freeze bank accounts and severely disrupt operations, but it must be supported by a valid assessment. If the PAN or FLD/FAN was not validly served, the taxpayer may still have grounds to challenge the assessment and the collection action before the Court of Tax Appeals.
For businesses under BIR audit, the case is a reminder to maintain complete records of all notices actually received, all office registration updates, all communications with revenue officers, and all collection documents served by the BIR. For taxpayers already facing garnishment or distraint, the immediate question is not only whether the tax computation is correct, but whether each required notice was validly issued and served in accordance with law.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists companies, business owners, corporate counsel, and finance teams in handling BIR assessments, disputed deficiency taxes, warrants of distraint and levy, bank garnishments, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can review the validity of assessment notices, evaluate due process defenses, prepare protests and petitions for review, and seek urgent relief against improper collection actions.
If your company has received a BIR assessment, Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy, or Warrant of Garnishment, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.