The CTA dismissed British American Tobacco’s VAT refund claim due to premature filing before the BIR’s 90-day period, highlighting strict compliance with statutory timelines.
Taxpayers seeking a refund of unutilized or excess input VAT must strictly follow statutory timelines and procedural requirements to secure judicial review. Recent developments underscore that premature filing before the expiration of the prescribed administrative period can lead to dismissal for lack of jurisdiction.
Background
British American Tobacco (Philippines), Limited, a foreign corporation with a branch in the Philippines, sought a refund of P474,654,897.35 representing unutilized input VAT from importations and domestic purchases as of December 31, 2017. The refund claim was submitted to the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) after the taxpayer filed for cancellation of VAT registration and obtained a Certificate of No Outstanding Tax Liability (July 30, 2018 β July 29, 2020). The administrative claim was filed on July 30, 2020, and the BIR issued a denial notice on October 27, 2020, received by the taxpayer on October 30, 2020 (CTA Case No. 10322)
CTA 2nd Division Decision BRITβ¦
.
CTA Proceedings
The taxpayer elevated the matter to the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) on August 3, 2020, seeking judicial review under Section 112(B) of the National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC) of 1997, as amended. The Court conducted pre-trial conferences, received documentary and testimonial evidence from both parties, and admitted expert reports. Despite full presentation of evidence by the taxpayer, the respondent argued that jurisdiction was lacking due to the premature filing before the expiration of the BIR’s 90-day period to act on the administrative claim
CTA 2nd Division Decision BRITβ¦
.
Legal Principles Applied
The CTA emphasized that jurisdiction is derived from law and cannot be assumed. Under RA 1125, as amended, the CTA exercises exclusive appellate jurisdiction over decisions and inactions of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. A judicial claim for refund or tax credit requires either a denial or a