RMC No. 64-2013 revoked PCCI’s income tax exemption and clarified that non-stock non-profit organizations may still be liable for VAT.

Non-stock, non-profit organizations cannot rely on a prior BIR tax exemption ruling when their purposes do not clearly fall within Section 30 of the Tax Code. RMC No. 64-2013 revoked the income tax exemption previously granted to Philippine Canine Club Incorporated under BIR Ruling No. NSNP-(S30C-028) 726-09, and it also emphasized that non-stock, non-profit organizations may still be liable for VAT when they sell goods or render services in the course of trade or business.

What Changed Under RMC No. 64-2013

RMC No. 64-2013 circularized the revocation of BIR Ruling No. NSNP-(S30C-028) 726-09 dated November 20, 2009, which had granted income tax exemption to Philippine Canine Club Incorporated, or PCCI, under Section 30(C) of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997.

The revoked ruling had treated PCCI as exempt from income tax. RMC No. 64-2013 reversed that position because PCCI’s corporate purposes did not fall under the narrow language of Section 30(C). The BIR identified PCCI as a non-stock, non-profit corporation registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission on March 21, 1963 under Certificate of Registration No. 22739, with Taxpayer Identification No. 917-096-000 and registered office at Room 206 Hillcrest Condominium, 1616 E. Rodriguez Sr. Avenue, Cubao, Quezon City.

The BIR reviewed PCCI’s purposes, including maintaining a registry of purebred dogs, publishing a stud book, adopting and enforcing rules for purebred dog registration and events, regulating persons and organizations involved in breeding and registering purebred dogs, preventing fraud, protecting members’ interests, publishing a kennel gazette, and advancing the study, breeding, exhibiting, running, and maintenance of purebred dogs.

The BIR concluded that these purposes do not qualify under Section 30(C). The organization was not a beneficiary society, order, or association operating for the exclusive benefit of members in the nature of a fraternal organization under the lodge system or a mutual aid association. It was also not a non-stock corporation organized by employees providing life, sickness, accident, or other benefits exclusively to members or their dependents.

Why the Earlier Exemption Could Not Continue

PCCI had previously been granted tax exemption on July 18, 1974 under Section 26(H) of Presidential Decree No. 1158, the Tax Code of 1977. That provision covered a club organized and operated exclusively for pleasure, recreation, and other non-profitable purposes, provided that no part of its net income inured to the benefit of any private stockholder or member.

The critical legal development is that this club exemption was intentionally omitted when Republic Act No. 8424, or the Tax Code of 1997, was enacted. RMC No. 64-2013 applied the principle that a person, object, or thing omitted from an enumeration must be held to have been omitted intentionally. Because the 1997 Tax Code did not carry over the old exemption for pleasure or recreational clubs, the BIR ruled that the prior basis for exemption could no longer support PCCI’s income tax exemption.

RMC No. 64-2013 also referred to Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 035-2012, which states that the income of a club organized and operated exclusively for pleasure, recreation, and other non-profitable purposes, from whatever source, including membership fees, assessment dues, rental income, and service fees, is subject to income tax.

Who Is Affected

The most affected taxpayers are non-stock, non-profit corporations that assume they are exempt from income tax merely because they do not issue shares, do not distribute profits, or operate for the benefit of members. Associations, clubs, societies, professional or hobby organizations, registries, membership groups, recreational clubs, industry groups, and similar entities should review whether their purposes exactly fall within one of the categories expressly listed in Section 30 of the Tax Code.

This ruling is especially important for organizations that collect membership fees, registration fees, certification fees, advertising fees, event fees, assessment dues, rental income, or service fees. PCCI’s activities were funded principally by registration and membership fees, with other funds sourced from dog shows, competitions, certification fees, advertising fees, and other incidental activities. These are the types of receipts that business owners, accountants, and tax managers should examine when checking whether a non-stock, non-profit organization has income tax and VAT exposure.

For CFOs and corporate accountants, the practical search terms are: RMC No. 64-2013 non-stock non-profit tax exemption, BIR revocation of tax exemption ruling, Section 30(C) Tax Code Philippines, VAT liability of non-profit organizations, and membership fees income tax Philippines.

Key Compliance Requirements and Deadlines

RMC No. 64-2013 is dated September 30, 2013. It revoked BIR Ruling No. NSNP-(S30C-028) 726-09 dated November 20, 2009. The circular does not prescribe a separate future compliance deadline, but its practical effect is immediate: affected organizations cannot continue relying on a revoked ruling as legal basis for claiming income tax exemption.

Non-stock, non-profit organizations should determine whether they fall within the exact statutory language of Section 30. For Section 30(C), the organization must be either a beneficiary society, order, or association operating for the exclusive benefit of members, such as a fraternal organization operating under the lodge system or a mutual aid association, or a non-stock corporation organized by employees providing life, sickness, accident, or other benefits exclusively to members or their dependents.

If an organization’s purposes are instead recreational, hobby-related, registry-related, professional, promotional, commercial, or service-oriented, it should not assume that Section 30(C) applies. The burden rests on the taxpayer claiming exemption. The exemption must be supported by clear and unequivocal statutory language, not by implication, equity, or the mere non-profit character of the entity.

VAT Liability of Non-Stock Non-Profit Organizations

RMC No. 64-2013 is also significant because it addressed PCCI’s VAT exposure. The BIR noted that an investigation by the Special Investigation Division showed that PCCI failed to remit VAT from taxable years 2004 to 2012. The BIR emphasized that BIR Ruling No. NSNP-(S30C-028) 726-09 had never granted PCCI exemption from VAT.

The circular quoted Section 105 of the Tax Code, which provides that any person who, in the course of trade or business, sells, barters, exchanges, or leases goods or properties, renders services, or imports goods, is subject to VAT under Sections 106 to 108 of the Tax Code. It further emphasized that the phrase in the course of trade or business includes the regular conduct or pursuit of a commercial or economic activity, including incidental transactions, by any person regardless of whether the person is a non-stock, non-profit private organization, irrespective of the disposition of net income and whether or not it sells exclusively to members or their guests.

The practical rule is clear: non-stock, non-profit status is not, by itself, a VAT exemption. If the organization regularly renders services or sells goods in a commercial or economic activity, its receipts may be subject to VAT unless a specific exemption applies.

Penalties and Risks for Non-Compliance

RMC No. 64-2013 does not list a special penalty schedule. However, the risks are substantial because the revocation removes the legal basis for the claimed income tax exemption and highlights possible VAT liabilities. An organization that continues treating taxable income as exempt may face deficiency income tax assessments. An organization that sells goods or services without properly accounting for VAT may face deficiency VAT assessments, plus the applicable additions to tax under the Tax Code.

The circular specifically identified unremitted VAT for taxable years 2004 to 2012 in relation to PCCI. This illustrates the audit risk for organizations that have long treated their operations as tax-exempt without separately confirming VAT exposure. For accountants and finance officers, the danger is not limited to current-year filings; historical treatment of membership fees, registration fees, service fees, advertising fees, and event-related receipts may be reviewed.

Practical Steps for Businesses and Non-Profit Organizations

First, review the organization’s latest Articles of Incorporation, By-Laws, actual activities, revenue streams, and prior BIR rulings or certificates of tax exemption. The legal analysis should not stop at whether the entity is non-stock or non-profit. The question is whether the entity fits squarely within the exact exemption category invoked.

Second, identify all revenue sources. Membership fees, assessment dues, registration charges, certification fees, advertising income, rental income, service fees, event income, and competition fees should be mapped and tested for income tax and VAT treatment.

Third, determine whether the organization is rendering services or selling goods in the course of trade or business. Under Section 105, even a non-stock, non-profit private organization may be treated as conducting taxable transactions if it regularly pursues commercial or economic activity, including incidental transactions.

Fourth, do not rely indefinitely on old rulings. A prior exemption ruling may be revoked if the legal basis changes, if the ruling was issued under an old law, or if the organization’s purposes or activities do not satisfy the current Tax Code. RMC No. 64-2013 is a warning that certificates and rulings should be periodically reviewed against current statutory language and BIR issuances.

Finally, obtain a tax legal review before representing to donors, members, auditors, counterparties, or the BIR that an organization is exempt from income tax or VAT. Tax exemption is strictly construed against the taxpayer, and the taxpayer bears the burden of proving exemption in words too plain to be mistaken.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

RMC No. 64-2013 is a reminder that non-stock, non-profit organizations, associations, clubs, and membership-based entities need careful tax structuring and periodic compliance review. A revoked BIR ruling can expose an organization to income tax and VAT issues, especially when it collects membership fees, service fees, certification fees, advertising fees, event fees, or other recurring receipts.

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, non-stock non-profit organizations, associations, and business groups in reviewing tax exemption status, VAT exposure, BIR registration and invoicing compliance, audit risks, and corrective strategies. For legal assistance with BIR rulings, tax exemption reviews, VAT compliance, and tax audit defense, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *