RMC No. 70-2010 disallows depreciation based on reappraised asset values and requires acquisition cost as the tax basis for property, plant and equipment.
Businesses claiming depreciation deductions on property, plant and equipment must review their tax depreciation schedules immediately if any deduction is based on appraised increases or revalued asset amounts. RMC No. 70-2010 revokes BIR Ruling Nos. DA-413-04 and DA-436-04 and confirms that depreciation for income tax purposes must be computed on acquisition cost, not on reappraised value. For corporations and other taxpayers with fixed assets on their books, this matters because depreciation based on appraisal increases may be disallowed in a BIR audit and may result in a deficiency assessment.
What Changed Under RMC No. 70-2010
RMC No. 70-2010 formally revokes and invalidates BIR Ruling Nos. DA-413-04 dated July 30, 2004 and DA-436-04 dated August 12, 2004. The circular states that some taxpayers had been using those rulings to justify the computation of depreciation based on the increased value of fixed assets rather than their acquisition cost. The BIR rejected that position and returned to the rule that depreciation must be anchored on the taxpayer’s actual investment in the asset.
The most important rule is straightforward: the depreciation of property, plant and equipment must be based on acquisition cost. No depreciation is allowable on the appraisal increase of fixed assets. If an asset is reappraised upward in the accounting records, that increase does not create a new tax basis for depreciation. The taxpayer may not use a higher revalued amount to claim a larger depreciation deduction for income tax purposes.
This is a tax-basis clarification, not merely an accounting presentation issue. A company may have accounting records showing property, plant and equipment at revalued amounts, but RMC No. 70-2010 makes clear that the income tax depreciation deduction must still be limited to the acquisition cost basis, subject to the applicable rules on depreciation and salvage value.
Legal Basis: Depreciation Is Recovery of Cost, Not Recovery of Revaluation Gain
RMC No. 70-2010 relies on the Supreme Court ruling in Basilan Estates, Inc. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, G.R. No. L-22492, September 5, 1967. The principle emphasized by the BIR is that income tax law does not authorize depreciation of an asset beyond its acquisition cost. A deduction beyond that cost is not allowed because tax deductions are privileges granted by law and cannot be created by implication.
The circular also cites Item IX(H)(2) of RAMO No. 1-00 dated March 17, 2000, which states that no depreciation is allowable on the appraisal increase of fixed assets. It further provides that any foreseeable salvage value must be deducted from the cost of the asset in determining the basis of depreciation. This means that the computation should begin with acquisition cost, reduce that basis by foreseeable salvage value where applicable, and then apply the appropriate depreciation method consistent with the Tax Code and regulations.
The BIR’s reasoning is that depreciation is intended to permit recovery of the investment made in the asset over time. It is not intended to permit recovery of an unrealized appraisal increase or a profit element. A revaluation increase may affect financial reporting, but it does not automatically increase the taxpayer’s allowable depreciation deduction for income tax purposes.
Who Is Affected
RMC No. 70-2010 affects corporations, partnerships, sole proprietors, and other taxpayers that own and depreciate property, plant and equipment. It is especially relevant to businesses with land improvements, buildings, machinery, equipment, transportation assets, leasehold improvements, and other fixed assets that may have been reappraised for accounting, financing, restructuring, or corporate reporting purposes.
Large corporations with material fixed asset balances are directly affected because an incorrect depreciation base can significantly reduce taxable income and create exposure during tax audit. SMEs are also affected if they have relied on book revaluations, appraisal reports, or prior BIR rulings to support higher depreciation deductions. Corporate accountants, CFOs, and tax managers should pay particular attention to depreciation of revalued property, plant and equipment, depreciation based on appraisal increase, BIR tax depreciation basis, and acquisition cost depreciation Philippines because these are the search terms and practical issues likely to arise during compliance reviews.
Taxpayers currently under audit are also affected. RMC No. 70-2010 specifically directs revenue officers conducting audit investigations involving depreciation of assets to take the circular into consideration. This means that depreciation schedules may be examined not only for useful life and method, but also for whether the tax basis used is acquisition cost or an impermissible reappraised amount.
Key Compliance Requirement and Effective Practical Impact
The key compliance requirement is to compute depreciation of property, plant and equipment based on acquisition cost, not reappraised value. RMC No. 70-2010 is dated August 9, 2010, and it revokes the two earlier rulings dated July 30, 2004 and August 12, 2004. Businesses should treat those revoked rulings as unavailable support for depreciation deductions based on increased appraisal values.
For tax compliance, the business should maintain a clear distinction between accounting carrying value and tax depreciation basis. If accounting records reflect a revaluation surplus or appraisal increase, the tax depreciation schedule should not simply follow the revalued book amount. The tax file should preserve acquisition documents, invoices, deeds of sale, importation records, construction cost records, capital expenditure ledgers, and other documents proving the original acquisition cost of the asset.
Where foreseeable salvage value applies, it should be deducted from the cost of the asset in determining the depreciation basis. The circular does not create a new rate, threshold, or special deadline, but it creates a clear audit position: depreciation on appraisal increase is not allowable and may be disallowed by the BIR.
Penalties and Audit Exposure for Non-Compliance
RMC No. 70-2010 does not specify a new surcharge, interest rate, or compromise penalty table. However, it expressly provides that any depreciation based on the appraised increase of property, plant and equipment shall be disallowed. Where applicable, the corresponding deficiency assessment shall be made.
In practical terms, if a taxpayer claimed depreciation using a reappraised amount, the BIR may add back the excess depreciation to taxable income. This can result in deficiency income tax. Depending on the circumstances and the applicable provisions of the Tax Code, the deficiency assessment may also carry the usual statutory consequences associated with tax deficiencies. The immediate business risk is not merely a technical adjustment but a potential tax assessment arising from overstated depreciation expense.
Practical Steps for Businesses, CFOs, and Accountants
First, review the fixed asset register and identify assets whose accounting values were increased by appraisal, revaluation, merger accounting, restructuring, or similar adjustments. The question is whether the tax depreciation schedule uses acquisition cost or a higher reappraised amount.
Second, compare book depreciation with tax depreciation. If the accounting system automatically computes depreciation using revalued book amounts, a separate tax depreciation schedule should be maintained. The tax schedule should show acquisition cost, salvage value where applicable, depreciable basis, useful life, depreciation method, accumulated depreciation, and remaining tax basis.
Third, preserve support for acquisition cost. Appraisal reports may be useful for business or accounting purposes, but they should not be treated as proof of a new tax basis for depreciation. Taxpayers should retain contracts, invoices, official receipts, import documents, construction records, and board approvals for capital expenditures.
Fourth, assess prior-year exposure if the business previously claimed depreciation based on appraisal increases. If a tax audit is ongoing, prepare a reasoned reconciliation and evaluate whether voluntary correction, audit defense, or settlement strategy is appropriate. If no audit is pending, management should still determine whether its current-year tax computation must be corrected going forward.
Fifth, update internal tax review procedures. Any revaluation of property, plant and equipment should trigger a tax review so that finance teams do not automatically increase the tax depreciation base. This is especially important for businesses preparing audited financial statements, loan covenants, asset refinancing, or corporate restructuring involving material fixed assets.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 70-2010 is a reminder that a company’s accounting treatment and tax treatment do not always move together. For businesses with significant property, plant and equipment, the wrong depreciation basis can create avoidable BIR audit exposure, deficiency income tax assessments, and disputes over fixed asset documentation.
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, SMEs, CFOs, accountants, and in-house counsel in reviewing depreciation schedules, preparing BIR audit defenses, reconciling accounting and tax records, and developing compliant fixed asset tax policies. For assistance with BIR compliance, tax audit exposure, depreciation deductions, and corporate tax planning in the Philippines, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.