COA may disallow unauthorized RATA, but public officers who received allowances in good faith under official approval may avoid refund liability.
Government directors and officers may lose the legal basis for an allowance, yet still avoid refunding it when they received the benefit in good faith under an official corporate approval. For public corporations, government subsidiaries, and officers serving in board roles, the ruling draws an important line: COA may correctly disallow an unauthorized allowance, but disallowance does not automatically mean personal repayment.
The Practical Issue: Can COA Force Officers to Return Allowances Already Paid?
Many public-sector compensation disputes begin with a familiar problem. An allowance is approved by a board, paid for years, and later questioned by audit. COA may then issue a notice of disallowance and require the recipients to refund the amounts, even when the recipients believed that the payments were properly authorized.
The controversy in Singson v. Commission on Audit involved members of the Board of Directors of the Philippine International Convention Center, Inc., or PICCI, a government corporation whose sole stockholder was the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas. Several PICCI directors were also BSP officials. Under the PICCI By-Laws, directors were entitled to a per diem of P1,000.00 for every board meeting actually attended. Separately, the BSP Monetary Board approved an additional monthly Representation and Transportation Allowance, or RATA, of P1,500.00 for the PICCI directors.
Background of the Disallowance
From 1996 to 1998, the directors received RATA totaling P1,565,000.00. COA later disallowed the payments, reasoning that the directors were already receiving allowances from BSP and that the additional RATA from PICCI violated restrictions on double compensation and the PICCI By-Laws. The case eventually reached the Supreme Court as a petition challenging COA Decision No. 2002-081 and COA Resolution No. 2003-115 (G.R. No. 159355, August 9, 2010).
The petitioners argued that PICCI was governed by the Corporation Code because it was incorporated with the Securities and Exchange Commission and had no original charter. They also argued that the BSP, as sole stockholder, had approved the allowance through its Monetary Board resolutions. COA, on the other hand, maintained that the PICCI By-Laws only allowed per diems for directors and did not authorize a separate RATA.
The Doctrine: Disallowance Does Not Always Require Refund
The Supreme Court affirmed COA’s authority to disallow the RATA, but modified the refund consequence. The Court held that the PICCI By-Laws restricted directors’ compensation to the P1,000.00 per diem for every meeting actually attended. Since the By-Laws used per diem as the form of director compensation and did not authorize another allowance, the directors had no independent right to the additional RATA as PICCI directors.
At the same time, the Court rejected the broad view that the payments necessarily violated the constitutional prohibition against double compensation. It explained that RATA is different from salary. Salary is compensation for services rendered, while RATA is an allowance intended to defray representation and transportation expenses that certain officials incur because of the nature of their offices.
The Court also relied on earlier jurisprudence interpreting National Compensation Circular No. 67. That circular was aimed at preventing the dual collection of RATA by a national official from more than one national agency. The Court clarified that the prohibition must be read in context and not by isolating the phrase that no one may collect RATA from more than one source. In this case, the Court concluded that the RATA granted to the PICCI directors did not fall within the specific evil addressed by the circular.
Why the Officers Did Not Have to Refund the Money
The most consequential part of the ruling is the treatment of good faith. Even though the Court sustained the disallowance, it held that the petitioners did not have to return the P1,565,000.00 they had received. The reason was that they relied on BSP Monetary Board resolutions that appeared to authorize the allowance. The Court found that they believed in good faith that they were entitled to the RATA for board meetings attended.
This is not a blanket immunity rule. The decision does not say that every disallowed benefit may be retained. The protection applies where the recipients acted in good faith, received the allowance under an official approval, and had no clear reason to know that the payment lacked legal basis. Bad faith, participation in an obviously illegal scheme, or receipt despite clear legal prohibition may lead to a different result.
What This Means for Government Corporations and Public Officers
For government-owned or controlled corporations, government subsidiaries, and public officers sitting in corporate boards, the case is a warning about compensation design. Board resolutions alone may not be enough if the corporation’s by-laws, charter, or governing statute restricts compensation to per diems or requires a specific approval process. Corporate approvals should be aligned with by-laws, the Corporation Code, DBM issuances, COA rules, and any applicable charter or special law.
For officers who receive allowances, the ruling offers a practical defense when COA later issues a notice of disallowance. The key question is not only whether the allowance was ultimately valid, but whether the recipients acted in good faith when they accepted it. Evidence of board approval, past practice, official legal advice, budgetary approval, and absence of fraud may become important in resisting personal refund liability.
Why This Matters to Taxpayers and Corporate Clients
Although the case is not an income tax assessment case, it matters for taxpayers because public funds, government corporation finances, and audit disallowances ultimately affect institutional accountability. For private companies dealing with government corporations, it also shows how strictly Philippine law treats corporate authority, internal by-laws, and the legal basis for payments. A payment may be approved internally and still be vulnerable if the approving body acts outside the limits of the governing documents.
The ruling is also relevant to executives, directors, and compliance teams because the same governance lesson applies outside government: compensation must be traceable to lawful authority. For corporations, the safest practice is to document the source of authority before payment, especially where directors, officers, consultants, or representatives receive allowances separate from ordinary salary or per diem.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, public-sector counterparties, officers, and stakeholders on audit disallowances, corporate governance disputes, public accountability issues, and compensation-related legal risks. If your company or officers are facing a COA disallowance, refund demand, board compensation issue, or government-contract compliance concern, our litigation and corporate lawyers can help assess the legal basis, available defenses, and practical strategy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our Makati-based legal team.