Share redemption premiums are not automatically dividends. The Court allowed Goodyear’s refund and held no 15% FWT applied without unrestricted retained earnings.

Companies that redeem shares from a foreign shareholder do not automatically owe dividend withholding tax merely because the redemption price exceeds par value. The controlling question is whether the payment is truly a dividend under Philippine tax law: a distribution out of earnings or profits. Where the corporation has no unrestricted retained earnings and the payment is made to reacquire shares, the excess amount may be treated as part of the share redemption transaction, not as taxable dividends subject to final withholding tax.

Why the Goodyear Ruling Matters

The ruling is important for Philippine corporations with foreign parent companies, affiliates, or investors. It clarifies that the Bureau of Internal Revenue cannot simply recharacterize a share redemption premium as accumulated dividends in arrears without showing that the payment came from earnings or profits that could legally support a dividend declaration. For businesses, this means corporate law concepts such as unrestricted retained earnings and the nature of a redemption transaction can directly affect withholding tax exposure.

The case also confirms an important taxpayer remedy: a taxpayer seeking a refund under Section 229 of the Tax Code does not have to wait indefinitely for the Commissioner of Internal Revenue to act on the administrative claim before going to the Court of Tax Appeals. If the two-year deadline is about to expire, the taxpayer may file the judicial claim after first filing the administrative claim, even if only a short period has passed.

Background: Preferred Shares Redeemed From a US Shareholder

Goodyear Philippines, Inc. was a domestic corporation registered with the Bureau of Internal Revenue as a large taxpayer. After increasing its authorized capital stock, all of its preferred shares were subscribed by Goodyear Tire and Rubber Company, a corporation organized under the laws of Ohio, United States of America and unregistered in the Philippines.

In 2008, Goodyear Philippines’ board authorized the redemption of 3,729,216 preferred shares held by the US company. The redemption price was P470,653,914.00, consisting of P372,921,600.00 in aggregate par value and P97,732,314.00 described in the records as accrued and unpaid dividends. Goodyear Philippines filed an application for relief from double taxation but, taking a conservative approach, withheld and remitted P14,659,847.10 as 15% final withholding tax on the difference between the redemption price and the aggregate par value.

Goodyear Philippines later filed an administrative claim for refund or tax credit certificate with the BIR, followed by a judicial claim before the Court of Tax Appeals. The Commissioner argued that the CTA case was premature because the administrative claim had been filed only thirteen days earlier, and that the P97,732,314.00 excess should be treated as dividends subject to 15% final withholding tax. The Supreme Court rejected both arguments in Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Goodyear Philippines, Inc. (G.R. No. 216130, August 3, 2016).

The Refund Claim Was Not Premature

The Court held that Section 229 of the Tax Code requires a taxpayer to file an administrative claim before maintaining a court action for recovery of an erroneously or illegally collected national internal revenue tax. But the law does not require the taxpayer to wait for the BIR’s final action before filing the judicial claim.

The reason is practical and jurisdictional. Section 229 also imposes a strict two-year period from the date of payment of the tax or penalty. If a taxpayer were required to wait for the BIR’s decision even when the two-year period was about to lapse, the taxpayer could lose the right to go to court altogether. The administrative claim functions as notice to the Commissioner that court action may follow unless the amount is refunded or credited.

In Goodyear’s case, the tax was paid on November 3, 2008. The administrative claim was filed on October 21, 2010, and the judicial claim was filed on November 3, 2010. Both filings fell within the two-year period. The Court therefore held that Goodyear timely sought judicial relief despite the short interval between the administrative and judicial claims.

Why the Share Redemption Premium Was Not a Dividend

The Commissioner’s main substantive argument was that the P97,732,314.00 component of the redemption price should not be treated as a mere premium or part of the subscription price, but as accumulated dividends in arrears. If accepted, that characterization would subject the amount to 15% final withholding tax on intercorporate dividends received by a nonresident foreign corporation under Section 28(B)(5)(b) of the Tax Code.

The Court disagreed. Because the recipient was a US resident corporation, the RP-US Tax Treaty also governed the transaction. Under the treaty, the term dividends is understood by reference to the tax law of the state where the distributing corporation resides. Since Goodyear Philippines was a Philippine corporation, the Court looked to Philippine tax law, particularly Section 73(A) of the Tax Code.

Section 73(A) defines dividends as a distribution made by a corporation to its shareholders out of earnings or profits. The Court found that Goodyear Philippines’ audited financial statements for 2003 to 2009 showed that it had no unrestricted retained earnings and in fact operated from a deficit. Without unrestricted retained earnings, its board had no power to issue dividends. The Court also cited the Corporation Code rule that dividends may be declared only out of unrestricted retained earnings.

This made the Commissioner’s characterization legally untenable. A payment cannot be treated as a taxable dividend when the corporation had no legally available earnings or profits from which dividends could be declared. The P97,732,314.00 payment was therefore not accumulated dividends in arrears for purposes of the 15% final withholding tax.

Redemption Is Not the Same as an Ordinary Dividend

The Court also emphasized the factual distinction between an ordinary dividend and a redemption or liquidation-type payment. An ordinary dividend is generally a recurring return on stock. By contrast, redemption is a repurchase or reacquisition by a corporation of its own shares. In a redemption, the shareholder gives up shares and the corporation pays for those shares.

That distinction mattered. The payment to the US shareholder did not represent a periodic distribution of corporate earnings. It was paid in exchange for the redemption of 3,729,216 preferred shares. The shareholder’s interest was reduced through the transaction. The Court therefore treated the payment as part of the share redemption, not as an ordinary dividend.

Practical Impact for Philippine Corporations and Foreign Investors

For companies planning redemptions, buybacks, recapitalizations, or intra-group equity restructuring, the Goodyear ruling is a reminder that tax characterization must be supported by the legal and financial reality of the transaction. Labels in board documents or accounting descriptions are not necessarily controlling. The key questions include whether the corporation has unrestricted retained earnings, whether the payment is a recurring return on shares, whether the shareholder is surrendering an equity interest, and whether an applicable tax treaty changes the analysis.

For taxpayers seeking refunds, the ruling is equally practical. A taxpayer who has paid a disputed withholding tax should closely track the two-year prescriptive period under Section 229. Filing an administrative claim is necessary, but waiting too long for BIR action can be fatal. When the deadline is approaching, filing a timely CTA petition after the administrative claim may be the only way to preserve the refund remedy.

For the BIR, the case limits recharacterization arguments where the statutory elements of dividends are absent. The government may scrutinize whether a redemption is being used as a tax avoidance device, but it must still anchor the assessment on the Tax Code, the Corporation Code, and any applicable treaty. In Goodyear, those authorities did not support treating the redemption premium as taxable dividends.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, shareholders, and finance teams in tax disputes, refund claims, withholding tax exposure, and transaction structuring involving equity redemptions, foreign shareholders, and treaty-based tax positions. If your company is facing a BIR assessment, refund denial, or uncertainty over the tax treatment of a share redemption or cross-border payment, our lawyers can help evaluate the legal basis, preserve deadlines, and prepare the appropriate administrative or judicial remedy.

For tax litigation, corporate restructuring, and BIR controversy assistance, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *