Supreme Court voided a faction’s reduction of fully paid shares, stressing treasury-share rules, retained earnings, and trust fund doctrine.

A majority stockholder’s shares cannot be reduced by boardroom maneuver, factional vote, or informal agreement unless the corporation complies with the strict rules on treasury shares, retained earnings, capital reduction, and consideration. For business owners and investors, the ruling is a warning that corporate control cannot be rewritten by treating fully paid shares as disposable simply because a dispute arises among founders.

Why This Case Matters to Business Owners and Investors

Founder disputes often begin with an informal understanding: one person will provide financing, another will provide technical expertise, and others will secure permits or handle operations. When the business later becomes valuable, stalled, or politically divided, parties may try to revisit the original equity split. Salido v. Aramaywan Metals Development Corporation shows that equity ownership in a corporation is not something a faction can later reduce by resolution alone.

The dispute involved Aramaywan Metals Development Corporation, a mining corporation formed by two groups. Cerlito San Juan was supposed to advance the paid-up subscription for Aramaywan and, under the parties’ agreement, would hold 55% of its shares. Agapito Salido and his faction later claimed that San Juan did not fully deliver the expected funds and caused the approval of board resolutions reducing San Juan’s shares from 55% to 15%, cancelling shares held by his wife and daughter, and treating the reduced shares as treasury shares. The Supreme Court reviewed the controversy in Salido v. Aramaywan Metals Development Corporation (G.R. No. 233857, March 18, 2021).

The Core Doctrine: Paid Shares Cannot Be Taken Back Without Lawful Corporate Machinery

The Supreme Court affirmed that San Juan’s shares were not validly reduced. The Court treated the attempted reduction not as a simple internal adjustment, but as an attempted reacquisition of corporate shares. Under the Corporation Code, treasury shares are issued and fully paid shares that are later reacquired by the corporation through purchase, redemption, donation, or another lawful means. But a corporation cannot acquire its own shares at will. It must have unrestricted retained earnings in its books to cover the shares to be purchased or acquired.

That requirement matters because corporate capital is not merely a private fund among shareholders. It is also a protection for creditors. The trust fund doctrine treats subscribed capital as a fund available for the payment of corporate debts. Until liquidation, subscribed capital cannot simply be returned, released, condoned, or used to buy back shares in a way that prejudices creditors or bypasses statutory safeguards.

Aramaywan had just recently been incorporated and had not yet begun mining operations. The record did not show that it had unrestricted retained earnings. Without such retained earnings, it could not validly reacquire San Juan’s shares and classify them as treasury shares. The supposed conversion was therefore invalid.

A Board Resolution Cannot Cure the Lack of Retained Earnings or Consideration

The Court also rejected the theory that San Juan’s shares could be reduced because he supposedly consented to the reduction. Even assuming that San Juan agreed, the supposed agreement still lacked a valid legal basis. The Court found that San Juan’s subscription to Aramaywan had been fully paid. The funds were deposited in San Juan’s name as treasurer-in-trust for Aramaywan, but the beneficial ownership belonged to the corporation. The bank certificate stated that the deposit was clear and available for withdrawal on behalf of the company upon proof of incorporation.

Because San Juan had already fulfilled his obligation to advance the paid-up subscription for Aramaywan, the corporation could not justify taking back part of his shares by saying it was cancelling an unpaid obligation. The Articles of Incorporation also reflected that the corporation’s subscribed capital had been fully paid. The issuance of the certificate of incorporation reinforced the conclusion that the capital subscription reflected in the incorporation documents was accepted as paid.

The Court further reasoned that even if there had been unpaid subscriptions, the Corporation Code provides a specific procedure: the board must make a call for payment, the unpaid stock may become delinquent, and a delinquency sale may follow. A corporation cannot merely release a stockholder from unpaid subscription obligations or reduce subscribed capital by internal agreement. Doing so would violate the trust fund doctrine and undermine creditor protection.

What Happens When a Founder Fails to Perform a Separate Obligation?

The Salido faction also argued that San Juan failed to proceed with the incorporation of Narra Mining Corporation, another entity contemplated by the parties. The Supreme Court did not treat that alleged failure as a valid reason to reduce San Juan’s Aramaywan shares. San Juan’s obligation under the agreement, as read by the Court, was to assure the payment of the subscription for Narra Mining. The record did not establish a clear obligation to incorporate Narra Mining by a specific date, nor a breach that could serve as consideration for taking away Aramaywan shares.

This distinction is important for founders. A party may breach a separate contractual undertaking, but that does not automatically authorize the corporation or other shareholders to confiscate or reduce that party’s shares. The remedy must fit the obligation breached. Equity ownership cannot be casually used as a penalty unless the law, the articles, the bylaws, or a valid agreement clearly provides a lawful mechanism for doing so.

Board Quorum Was Not the Same as Stockholder Control

The Court also addressed the validity of several board resolutions. It agreed that certain ordinary corporate acts could be validly approved by the board when a quorum existed. Aramaywan had nine directors, so the presence of five directors was sufficient for a board quorum. A decision approved by the required majority of directors present could validly bind the corporation for ordinary business matters.

However, the transfer of the corporation’s principal office was different. Changing the principal office required an amendment of the Articles of Incorporation. That required not only board approval but also the written assent of stockholders representing at least two-thirds of the outstanding capital stock and approval by the Securities and Exchange Commission. Since San Juan remained the majority stockholder because the reduction of his shares was invalid, his written assent was indispensable for that amendment.

Practical Impact: What This Means for Corporate Disputes

For majority stockholders, the decision confirms that corporate shares are protected property rights. They cannot be reduced merely because a rival faction believes the original equity arrangement became unfair. If the shares are fully paid, the corporation must respect them unless a lawful transfer, redemption, purchase, or other valid mechanism exists.

For minority factions, the case is equally instructive. If a founder fails to fund the company, refuses to perform obligations, or breaches a shareholders’ agreement, the remedy is not self-help through questionable board resolutions. The proper response may involve enforcing the agreement, demanding payment under the Corporation Code, pursuing damages, holding a valid delinquency sale if subscriptions are unpaid, or seeking judicial relief. Shortcuts can invalidate the entire corporate act.

For creditors, the ruling reinforces the trust fund doctrine. Corporate capital cannot be withdrawn, released, or disguised as treasury share conversion without observing statutory safeguards. This protects those who deal with corporations on the assumption that subscribed capital remains available to answer for corporate obligations.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Intra-corporate disputes often move quickly from boardroom disagreements to SEC filings, conflicting General Information Sheets, contested elections, and court litigation. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists shareholders, directors, founders, and corporations in evaluating corporate acts, enforcing shareholder rights, challenging invalid resolutions, and structuring lawful remedies for ownership and control disputes.

If you are facing a dispute over corporate shares, board control, treasury shares, unpaid subscriptions, or amendments to corporate documents, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our corporate litigation team. Early legal review can prevent a temporary boardroom advantage from becoming an invalid corporate act.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *