A dean was treated as an employee, not a corporate officer, but her reassignment after college closure was valid management prerogative.

Employers cannot avoid labor jurisdiction simply by labeling an important workplace position as a corporate office. A worker remains an employee, and may bring a termination dispute before the Labor Arbiter, unless the position is expressly made a corporate office by law or by the corporation’s by-laws. For schools, corporations, and senior employees, the practical lesson is clear: board approval, administrative rank, or a title of trust and confidence does not automatically convert an employee into a corporate officer.

Why This Ruling Matters to Employers and Senior Personnel

Many employment disputes involve people who hold senior, confidential, or management-level positions. Employers sometimes argue that these personnel are not ordinary employees but corporate officers, thereby placing their disputes outside the jurisdiction of labor tribunals. That distinction matters because illegal dismissal and constructive dismissal complaints are generally heard by Labor Arbiters and the NLRC, while intra-corporate disputes involving corporate officers may fall under a different jurisdictional framework.

The ruling in Barba v. Liceo de Cagayan University is important because it draws a practical boundary. A person is not a corporate officer merely because the board approved the appointment, because the position involves trust and confidence, or because the employee performs high-level administrative functions. The position must be one of the corporate offices identified by the Corporation Code or expressly provided in the by-laws.

Background: A Dean Transferred After Her College Closed

Dr. Ma. Mercedes L. Barba served as Dean of the College of Physical Therapy of Liceo de Cagayan University. She had earlier been granted a scholarship for residency training in Rehabilitation Medicine, with an undertaking to serve the school after her training in whatever position the school desired related to her studies. Her appointment as Dean and Doctor-in-Charge of a rehabilitation clinic was for a fixed three-year period, subject to revocation for valid cause.

The College of Physical Therapy later suffered a steep decline in enrollment. Because of this, the university froze the operations of the college and informed Dr. Barba that her services as Dean would end with the close of the school year. She was then directed to report to the Acting Dean of the College of Nursing for a teaching load. Dr. Barba viewed the transfer as a demotion and claimed constructive dismissal. The case reached the Supreme Court in Barba v. Liceo de Cagayan University (G.R. No. 193857), decided on November 28, 2012.

The Corporate Officer Issue: Title Alone Is Not Enough

The decisive jurisdictional question was whether Dr. Barba was an employee or a corporate officer. If she was a corporate officer, the Labor Arbiter and the NLRC would have no jurisdiction over her constructive dismissal complaint. If she was an employee, the labor tribunals could properly hear the case.

The Court held that Dr. Barba was an employee, not a corporate officer. It emphasized that corporate officers are those given that character either by the Corporation Code or by the corporation’s by-laws. Under the Corporation Code, corporate officers include the president, secretary, treasurer, and such other officers as may be provided in the by-laws. The Court applied the rule that a position must be expressly mentioned in the by-laws to be considered a corporate office.

Liceo’s by-laws named certain corporate officers and also referred to a College Director and heads of departments. But the Court found that a College Dean was not among the corporate officers expressly mentioned. Dr. Barba’s appointment as Dean, even if approved by the board, did not make her a corporate officer. The board may create appointive positions, but the persons occupying those positions do not automatically become corporate officers unless the by-laws properly confer that character upon them.

Board Approval Does Not Automatically Create a Corporate Office

The Court rejected the argument that the board’s approval of Dr. Barba’s appointment transformed her into a corporate officer. Her appointment letter did not designate her as College Director. Nor did the by-laws show that a Dean and a College Director were the same position. The Court noted that the university had several deans, while the by-laws contemplated only one College Director. This distinction undermined the claim that every dean was effectively the College Director mentioned in the by-laws.

The Court also considered the manner of appointment. A College Dean was appointed by the university president upon recommendation of academic officials and approval of the board. This was different from the direct appointment to a corporate office contemplated by the by-laws. The Court therefore treated the deanship as an administrative employment position, not a corporate office.

The Four-Fold Test Confirmed an Employment Relationship

Applying the four-fold test, the Court found an employer-employee relationship. The university selected and engaged Dr. Barba, paid her salary and allowances, exercised authority over her work, and had the power to terminate or assign her. These indicators showed that she was an employee within the meaning of labor law.

Because she was an employee, her complaint for illegal or constructive dismissal was properly within the jurisdiction of the Labor Arbiter and the NLRC. The Court also noted that the university had actively participated before the Labor Arbiter and the NLRC without initially objecting to jurisdiction. It was only later, before the Court of Appeals, that the university raised the jurisdictional issue. The Court treated this belated challenge with disfavor, reiterating that active participation in proceedings may estop a party from later attacking jurisdiction after receiving an unfavorable result.

No Constructive Dismissal Despite Labor Jurisdiction

Although the Court sided with Dr. Barba on jurisdiction, it did not find that she had been constructively dismissed. This is the ruling’s important second layer: being an employee entitled to labor remedies does not mean every reassignment is illegal.

The Court held that the termination of her deanship was valid because the appointment was for a fixed term and the College of Physical Therapy had ceased operations due to a drastic decline in enrollment. The university was not required to maintain a deanship position for a college that no longer operated. Her loss of dean-related compensation, privileges, and benefits was a consequence of the valid end of that fixed-term administrative appointment.

The Court further held that assigning her a teaching load in another related college was not unreasonable, inconvenient, or prejudicial. The reassignment was made to accommodate her after the closure of the College of Physical Therapy and to allow her to complete the remaining service obligation under her scholarship contract. Thus, the transfer was a valid exercise of management prerogative, not constructive dismissal.

Practical Lessons for Companies, Schools, and Employees

For employers, the ruling is a warning against casual use of the term corporate officer. If a company intends a position to be a corporate office, the position must be clearly and expressly stated in the by-laws, and the appointment process should conform to corporate law. Merely obtaining board approval for a senior appointment will not necessarily remove the employee from labor law protection.

For HR managers and corporate secretaries, the case underscores the need to align job titles, by-laws, board resolutions, appointment letters, and employment documents. Ambiguity may lead to jurisdictional disputes, especially when senior personnel are removed, transferred, or reassigned.

For employees in high-ranking roles, the ruling confirms that a title such as dean, manager, director, or department head does not automatically strip labor rights. The real inquiry is legal and factual: whether the office is expressly created as a corporate office and whether the relationship satisfies the tests of employment.

For educational institutions, the ruling also recognizes operational realities. Fixed-term appointments to administrative posts, such as deanships and similar academic offices, may be valid where tied to institutional practice and necessity. When a program closes for legitimate reasons, the school may reassign affected personnel, provided the transfer is reasonable, related to the employee’s qualifications or obligations, and not a disguised punishment or demotion.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Disputes involving senior employees, corporate officers, school administrators, managers, and directors often turn on both labor law and corporate documentation. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists employers and employees in evaluating jurisdiction, drafting by-laws and appointment documents, handling NLRC cases, and assessing whether a reassignment, removal, or non-renewal may constitute constructive dismissal.

For advice on employment disputes, corporate officer classifications, management prerogative, or labor litigation strategy, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with Ablola, Saribong & Gueco.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *