When a Firing Is Too Harsh: Minor Workplace Mistakes Cannot Automatically Cost an Employee Their Job

Dismissal must be proportionate to the offense; minor lapses may not justify termination, while corporate officer disputes belong outside the NLRC. Employers may discipline employees for mistakes, absence, delay, or failure to follow instructions, but dismissal remains a last-resort penalty: the misconduct must be serious, willful, work-related, and proportionate to the punishment imposed. Why This […]

Corporate Officers Cannot Be Made Personally Liable by Execution Alone

Corporate officers cannot be made personally liable for labor judgments by execution alone without summons, due process, and proof of bad faith. Business owners and corporate officers cannot be made personally liable for a corporation’s labor judgment simply because the company cannot pay. A final award against a corporation does not automatically become a personal […]

When a Contractor Is Just a Corporate Mask: Employees May Sue the Principal Employer for Illegal Dismissal

A principal company may be treated as the real employer when a contractor is merely a labor-only conduit, but officers need proof of bad faith for personal liability. Employees assigned through a contractor may still claim illegal dismissal directly against the principal company when the contractor is undercapitalized, unregistered, dependent on the principal, and used […]

When a Company Officer Can Sue for Illegal Dismissal Before the Labor Arbiter

A corporate title or stock ownership does not automatically make dismissal disputes intra-corporate; regular employee-officers may sue before the Labor Arbiter. Company officers are not automatically pushed into corporate litigation when they lose their jobs. If the position is not a true corporate office created by the by-laws and filled by board or stockholder election, […]

When a Corporate Title Does Not Defeat Labor Rights: Why Deans, Managers, and Appointive Officials May Still Be Employees

A dean was treated as an employee, not a corporate officer, but her reassignment after college closure was valid management prerogative. Employers cannot avoid labor jurisdiction simply by labeling an important workplace position as a corporate office. A worker remains an employee, and may bring a termination dispute before the Labor Arbiter, unless the position […]

A General Manager Is Not a Corporate Officer Unless the By-Laws Say So

A general manager not listed in corporate by-laws remains an employee; closure was valid, but lack of notice required separation pay and damages. Companies cannot move an executive’s dismissal out of the labor system simply by calling that person a corporate officer. If the position is not expressly listed in the by-laws as a corporate […]

When a Manager Is Not a Corporate Officer: Why Employers Cannot Avoid Illegal Dismissal Claims by Using a Board Resolution

A stockholder-manager is not automatically a corporate officer. Without proof of board appointment, an illegal dismissal claim remains with the Labor Arbiter. A company cannot convert an employee’s illegal dismissal case into an intra-corporate dispute merely by calling the employee a manager, pointing to his stock ownership, or terminating him through a board resolution. If […]

Corporate Officers Cannot Turn Board Non-Reelection Into an Illegal Dismissal Case

Corporate officers elected under by-laws must contest removal in the RTC as an intra-corporate dispute, not before the Labor Arbiter. Corporate officers who lose their board-elected positions cannot automatically sue for illegal dismissal before the Labor Arbiter. When the position exists under the corporation’s by-laws and the officer was elected by the board, the dispute […]

Corporate Officers Cannot Turn Boardroom Dismissals Into NLRC Cases

Corporate officers who are also directors or stockholders must bring dismissal and compensation disputes before regular courts, not the NLRC. Corporate officers who are also directors or stockholders cannot automatically bring dismissal, reinstatement, backwage, commission, or compensation claims before the NLRC. When the dispute concerns the removal or rights of an elected corporate officer, the […]