COA correctly disallowed CNU employee benefits, but the Court excused officials and recipients from refund due to good faith, services rendered, and undue prejudice.
Government officials who approved benefits later disallowed by the Commission on Audit are not automatically required to refund them when they acted in good faith, and employees who received modest or service-based benefits may also be excused from returning the money when fairness, undue prejudice, or the nature of the payment justifies relief.
The Doctrine: Illegal Benefit, No Automatic Refund
The ruling in Velasquez v. Commission on Audit is important because it separates two questions that are often treated as one. First, was the government benefit validly granted? Second, if it was not validly granted, must the approving officials and employee-recipients return the money? The Court answered those questions differently. It sustained the disallowance of the quarterly rice subsidy and the Kalampusan Award granted by Cebu Normal University, but it relieved both the approving members of the Board of Regents and the recipients from refund liability.
For ordinary government employees and public officers, that distinction matters. A COA notice of disallowance may establish that a payment had no sufficient legal basis. But it does not always follow that every peso must be clawed back from the persons who approved or received the amount. Good faith, the state of the law at the time of approval, the services actually rendered, the character of the benefit, and the prejudice caused by a delayed refund demand may all affect liability.
Background: Rice Subsidy and Performance Incentives at Cebu Normal University
The case involved former members of the Board of Regents of Cebu Normal University who approved university expenditures in 2003 and 2004. These included a quarterly rice subsidy and the Kalampusan Award, a P20,000.00 incentive for each employee in recognition of accomplishments connected with the exemplary performance of university graduates in licensure examinations. COA later issued notices of disallowance covering P1,277,240.00 for the rice subsidy and P3,708,000.00 for the Kalampusan Award, for a total of P4,985,240.00.
COA held that the grants lacked legal basis. It relied on rules requiring statutory authority for payments from public funds and on the limitation that income of state universities and colleges may be used only for instruction, research, extension, or similar programs and projects. The former regents argued that when they approved the benefits, the controlling interpretation of the Higher Education Modernization Act had not yet been settled by jurisprudence. The dispute reached the Court in Velasquez v. Commission on Audit (G.R. No. 243503, September 15, 2020).
Why COA Was Correct to Disallow the Benefits
The Court agreed with COA that the benefits were outside the authority of the Board of Regents. Under Section 4(d) of Republic Act No. 8292, income generated by a state university or college, including tuition and other school charges, forms part of special trust funds. Those funds may be disbursed by the governing board for instruction, research, extension, or other programs or projects of the university or college.
The key interpretive issue was the phrase “other programs or projects.” In Benguet State University, the Court had already read that phrase through the doctrine of ejusdem generis. Because the listed purposes were instruction, research, and extension, the general phrase “other programs or projects” had to refer to programs or projects of a similar academic nature. It did not give governing boards a free hand to spend university income on any purpose they considered beneficial to employees.
The Court also rejected the argument that Benguet State University should apply only prospectively. A judicial interpretation of a statute ordinarily becomes part of the law as of the date the law took effect, unless the Court is abandoning an old doctrine or declaring a law unconstitutional in a way that justifies prospective application. Since Benguet State University merely interpreted Section 4(d) and did not overturn an earlier doctrine, that interpretation applied retroactively. On that basis, the rice subsidy and Kalampusan Award were validly disallowed.
Why the Former Regents Were Not Made to Refund
The more practical part of the ruling concerns personal liability. COA had treated the approving officials as jointly and severally liable for the disallowed amounts. The Court disagreed. It held that the former regents acted in good faith when they approved the benefits in 2003 and 2004, before Benguet State University clarified in 2007 the limits of a state university board’s authority to use institutional income.
The Court applied the framework in Madera v. Commission on Audit. Under that doctrine, approving and certifying officers who acted in good faith, in the regular performance of official functions, and with the diligence of a good father of a family are not civilly liable to return the disallowed amount. Solidary liability attaches only when approving officers are clearly shown to have acted with bad faith, malice, or gross negligence.
That rule is especially important for board members, officers, and managers of government entities. COA disallowance does not automatically mean personal bad faith. The inquiry is contextual. Did the approving officers rely on a plausible interpretation of law? Was there no settled jurisprudence at the time? Was the practice traditional within the agency? Was there a legal opinion, certificate of availability of funds, or other indication that the officials exercised diligence? In Velasquez, the uncertainty before Benguet State University supported good faith.
Why the Employees Also Kept the Money
The Court also excused the employee-recipients from refunding the benefits. Under Madera, recipients are generally liable to return amounts they received when the notice of disallowance is upheld, because no one should be unjustly enriched by an invalid payment. But that rule is not absolute. Return may be excused when the payment was genuinely given in consideration of services rendered, or when social justice, humanitarian reasons, undue prejudice, or other bona fide exceptions justify relief.
The rice subsidy was treated as a reasonable amount of financial assistance. The Kalampusan Award, meanwhile, was connected to services rendered and employee performance. The Court also recognized the unfairness of requiring return 16 years after the employees had received the amounts. The result was a practical and equitable compromise: the disallowance stood, but the people involved did not have to repay the money.
Practical Impact for Public Officers, SUCs, and Government Employees
For state universities and colleges, Velasquez is a warning against using institutional income for employee benefits that are not tied to instruction, research, extension, or similar academic programs. Even if a benefit is popular, helpful, or morale-boosting, it may still be disallowed if the governing board lacks clear statutory authority.
For members of boards, approving officers, and certifying officials, the case underscores the importance of documenting diligence before approving benefits. Legal opinions, finance certifications, board memoranda, statutory analysis, and clear records of deliberation can become decisive if COA later questions the payment. Good faith is not just a state of mind; it is often proven through contemporaneous records showing that officials took the law seriously before public funds were released.
For government employees, the ruling gives some protection against harsh refund demands, especially where they passively received benefits, rendered services, or relied on long-standing agency practice. However, employees should not assume that every disallowed benefit may be kept. The Court’s exceptions are applied case by case. Larger payments, clearly unauthorized allowances, or benefits received despite obvious legal defects may still be ordered returned.
The Bottom Line
Velasquez confirms a balanced rule in COA disallowance cases: public funds must be spent only under legal authority, but refund liability must still be fair, evidence-based, and sensitive to good faith. A benefit may be illegal without making every approving officer dishonest or every recipient unjustly enriched. The practical lesson is simple: legality determines disallowance, but good faith and equity may determine refund liability.
Need Help With a COA Disallowance, Government Benefits Issue, or Public Sector Liability Case?
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists public officers, government employees, institutions, contractors, and private parties dealing with COA notices of disallowance, refund demands, administrative liability, public fund use, and related litigation. If your agency, board, or office is facing questions over allowances, incentives, honoraria, or employee benefits, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult a Makati-based litigation and public accountability team.