Flying Pay Is Not a Travel Allowance: CAAP Employees Who Fly as Passengers Must Refund Disallowed Benefits

CAAP personnel who merely flew as passengers were ordered to refund flying risk pay, while good-faith approving officers escaped solidary liability. Government personnel cannot claim flying risk pay merely because their official duties require them to ride airplanes. The allowance belongs only to aviation personnel whose actual functions involve regular and frequent aerial operations, not […]

Government Employees Must Return Unauthorized Health Insurance Benefits After COA Disallowance

Government health insurance benefits paid without legal authority may be disallowed by COA, requiring approving officers and employee-recipients to refund them. Government employees who receive health insurance benefits paid from public funds may be ordered to return them when the benefit was not authorized by law, even if the employees merely received the benefit passively […]

When GOCC Directors Approve Their Own Benefits, COA Can Make Them Pay It Back

GOCC directors and officers may be required to return unauthorized gratuity benefits when board approval lacks legal basis and violates public compensation controls. Government-owned or controlled corporations cannot treat director gratuity, retirement-style benefits, or special exit payments as ordinary board discretion when public funds, compensation rules, and corporate losses are involved. For directors, senior officers, […]

GOCC Subsidiaries Cannot Pay Board Benefits Without Stockholder Approval and Presidential Authority

GOCC subsidiary board members who approve unauthorized benefits for themselves may face COA disallowance, refund liability, and solidary exposure. Government-owned corporations and their subsidiaries cannot treat director allowances as ordinary internal business expenses simply because the subsidiary was incorporated under the Corporation Code. When public officers sit on the boards of GOCC subsidiaries and approve […]

GOCCs Cannot Treat Employee Benefits as Ordinary Corporate Perks Without Presidential Approval

GOCCs without original charters still need presidential approval for employee fringe benefits; unauthorized payments may be disallowed by COA. Government-owned or controlled corporations, even when organized under the Corporation Code and governed by the Labor Code, cannot unilaterally grant employee medical benefits, allowances, or fringe benefits if those payments require presidential approval under compensation standardization […]

When Government Buyers Pay the Sellerโ€™s Taxes, COA Can Disallow the Deal

COA may disallow LGU payment of a sellerโ€™s taxes and legal fees when the deed is silent, but officials may avoid refund liability absent bad faith. Government buyers cannot casually agree to shoulder a sellerโ€™s transfer taxes, registration expenses, or private legal fees unless the obligation is clearly written into the sale contract and allowed […]

When Government Benefits Are Disallowed, Employees May Still Avoid Refunds

The Supreme Court upheld COAโ€™s COLA disallowance but excused officers and retired payees from refund due to good faith and undue prejudice. Government employees who receive disallowed benefits are not automatically protected by good faith, but the Supreme Court may still excuse repayment when refund would cause undue prejudice, especially where the payments were made […]

When COA Cannot Audit PAGCOR Spending: The Supreme Court Draws a Line Between Government Share and Corporate Operating Funds

The Supreme Court limited COA audit power over PAGCOR funds, voiding a disallowance for expenses sourced from operating funds outside charter coverage. PAGCOR officials cannot be made to refund a disallowed corporate expense when the Commission on Audit acts outside the limited audit authority imposed by PAGCORโ€™s own charter. For businesses and officers dealing with […]

Government Employees Cannot Keep Unauthorized Allowances Merely Because They Were Long Paid

COA may disallow unauthorized GOCC benefits, while approving and certifying officers can be liable only for the net amount when gross negligence is shown. Public officers who approve or certify unauthorized employee benefits cannot rely on old agency practice, outdated board resolutions, or advisory letters when clear law and settled jurisprudence already prohibit the payment. […]