Real property tax assessments may be challenged without prior payment when legality is disputed, and void assessments may support refund relief.
A taxpayer disputing a real property tax assessment may challenge the legality or validity of that assessment before the tax tribunals without first paying the tax under protest, and if the assessment is void, the tribunal may also order the refund of amounts already collected. For property owners, local treasurers, schools, government corporations, and public institutions, the ruling draws an important line: payment first applies to ordinary assessment disputes, but not where the very power to tax the property is being attacked.
Why the Case Mattered
The dispute arose from real property taxes assessed by Basilan City against a large land grant held and administered by the University of the Philippines. The property consisted of thousands of hectares of public land granted to the University under Act No. 3608 for purposes connected with its educational mission. The law placed the land under the administration and control of the Board of Regents and directed that the income from the land be used to support the University’s activities.
From 1940 to 1955, the land had not been listed for real property tax assessment. In 1955, the then City Treasurer and Assessor of Basilan placed the land on the assessment rolls and issued demands for real property taxes and penalties. The University initially paid certain amounts under protest, but later stopped payment and asked for the cancellation of the assessments and the refund of amounts already paid. The dispute eventually reached the Court of Tax Appeals and then the Supreme Court in Treasurer-Assessor, Board of Tax Appeals of Basilan City and City of Basilan v. University of the Philippines (G.R. No. L-20550, April 30, 1971).
The Payment-Under-Protest Rule Does Not Bar Jurisdiction When the Assessment Itself Is Attacked
Basilan City argued that the University could not go to the Court of Tax Appeals because it had not first paid all the assessed real property taxes under protest. The city relied on Section 54 of the Assessment Law, which generally required payment under protest before a taxpayer could sue to recover an allegedly illegal or excessive tax. On that theory, non-payment would defeat the appeal.
The Supreme Court rejected that argument. It explained that the jurisdiction of the Court of Tax Appeals over decisions of provincial or city boards of assessment appeals came from Republic Act No. 1125. That law did not impose a prior-payment requirement before the Court of Tax Appeals could review a decision involving the assessment and taxation of real property. The Court distinguished between a simple dispute over the amount of tax due and a direct challenge to the legality or validity of the assessment itself.
The key doctrine is that when a taxpayer alleges that the assessment is illegal, void, excessive, or unreasonable, the taxpayer may bring the matter through the assessment appeal process without first paying the disputed real property tax. Otherwise, a local government could force payment even when the assessment may have been made without legal authority. That would undermine the purpose of appellate review.
The Court of Tax Appeals May Order Refunds as an Incident of Its Jurisdiction
Basilan City also argued that, even if the Court of Tax Appeals could review the assessment, it had no power to order the refund of taxes already collected. The Supreme Court again disagreed. Once the Court of Tax Appeals validly acquired jurisdiction over the legality of the assessment, it also had the necessary incidental authority to grant complete relief. If an assessment is void, the tribunal reviewing it is not limited to saying so in the abstract. It may order the return of money collected under that void assessment.
This part of the ruling matters because it avoids unnecessary litigation. Without this doctrine, a taxpayer who successfully proves that an assessment is void would still have to file a separate court action merely to recover amounts already paid. The Supreme Court treated refund relief as incidental and necessary to the tax court’s appellate jurisdiction, not as an unrelated remedy outside its power.
Why the University Land Was Exempt From Real Property Tax
The Court also addressed the substantive tax issue: whether the University land grant was taxable by Basilan City. The city argued that the exemption under the Revised Administrative Code covered property owned by the Republic, but not land administered by the University. The Supreme Court found this argument untenable.
The land grant was treated as government property. The Court emphasized that the law creating and transferring the land to the University did not show an intent to divest the State of ownership in the ordinary private sense. The land was granted to support a public educational institution, administered by the Board of Regents, and used to generate income for the University’s public functions. The grant also contained restrictions showing that the property remained tied to public purposes, including limitations on disposition and reversion to the public domain if the land ceased to serve the statutory purpose.
Because the property was owned by the Republic and devoted to public purposes, it fell within the statutory exemption for property owned by the Republic of the Philippines. The fact that the University administered the property and could benefit from its income did not transform the land into taxable private property. Public ownership and public purpose controlled the tax treatment.
Practical Impact for Taxpayers and Local Governments
For taxpayers, the ruling is especially important in real property tax cases where the dispute is not merely about valuation, classification, or computation, but about whether the local government had authority to tax the property at all. A landowner, institution, or government entity asserting that an assessment is void should understand that the payment-under-protest rule is not always an absolute barrier to review.
For local governments, the case is a caution against treating all assessment appeals as ordinary collection matters. Where the taxpayer raises a serious jurisdictional or legal objection to the assessment, the reviewing bodies must address the legality of the assessment itself. The power to assess real property taxes is broad, but it remains limited by statutory exemptions, public ownership rules, and the jurisdiction of tax appellate bodies.
The decision also remains useful in disputes involving public institutions, government property, state universities, charitable or educational properties, and entities claiming exemption from local real property tax. It shows that courts will look not only at who administers or benefits from property, but also at ownership, statutory purpose, restrictions on disposition, and whether the property remains devoted to a public function.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Real property tax assessments can create immediate cash pressure, especially when local governments demand payment before resolving the taxpayer’s objections. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists property owners, businesses, schools, government-related entities, and institutions in evaluating local tax assessments, preparing protests and appeals, and litigating disputes involving exemptions, void assessments, refunds, and local government taxing authority.
If your property has been assessed for real property tax despite a possible exemption, ownership issue, or legal defect in the assessment, our litigation and tax team can help assess the available remedies and develop a strategy before payment, collection, or enforcement escalates. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with Ablola, Saribong & Gueco regarding real property tax disputes, assessment appeals, and local tax litigation in the Philippines.