Private complainants may challenge the criminal aspect with prosecutor conformity, but acquittals after demurrer stand absent grave abuse or denial of due process.

A private complainant who loses a criminal case after a demurrer to evidence cannot simply relitigate the acquittal by arguing that the trial court weighed the evidence incorrectly. The practical rule is sharper: the offended party may help question the criminal aspect only with the proper public prosecutor’s conformity at the correct court level, but the acquittal will still stand unless the prosecution proves grave abuse of discretion so serious that the trial was effectively void.

Why This Ruling Matters to Complainants and Accused Persons

For businesses, clinics, employers, and individuals who file criminal complaints, this ruling is a reminder that a criminal case is not personally owned by the complainant. Once the State prosecutes the case and the accused is acquitted, the complainant’s dissatisfaction with the result is not enough. The complainant may still protect civil claims where available, but overturning an acquittal is a much narrower matter because the Constitution protects the accused from being placed in jeopardy twice for the same offense.

For accused persons, the decision reinforces a powerful shield. A demurrer to evidence granted after the prosecution has rested is not a mere procedural pause. It is an adjudication that the prosecution’s evidence is insufficient. In criminal cases, that generally means acquittal, finality, and immediate protection against further attempts to convict.

Background: A Clinic, Alleged RT-PCR Test Falsification, and an Acquittal

The dispute arose from a criminal complaint for falsification of private documents filed by Marilao Medical and Diagnostic, Inc. against Dr. Jovith Royales, owner of Best Care, a clinic allegedly not authorized to issue RT-PCR tests. Marilao Medical claimed that Best Care falsely used Marilao Medical’s name in processing and issuing RT-PCR test results. The case reached the Supreme Court as Marilao Medical and Diagnostic, Inc. v. Royales (G.R. No. 265152).

After the prosecution presented its evidence, Dr. Royales filed a demurrer to evidence. The Metropolitan Trial Court granted the demurrer and acquitted him. The trial court found that the alleged falsified documents were not properly identified by their signatories, that the witness who identified them had no personal knowledge of the actual falsification, and that the evidence failed to connect Dr. Royales himself to the alleged falsification scheme.

Marilao Medical then filed a petition for certiorari before the Regional Trial Court. It argued that the trial court committed grave abuse of discretion and that circumstantial evidence, including Best Care’s alleged use of and benefit from the documents, should have been enough to establish a prima facie case. The petition carried the conformity of the Office of the City Prosecutor. The RTC nevertheless dismissed the petition, holding that Marilao Medical lacked standing to question the criminal aspect of the case.

The Supreme Court’s Procedural Ruling: Prosecutor Conformity Matters at the RTC Level

The Supreme Court partially agreed with Marilao Medical on one procedural point. A private complainant generally may question an acquittal only as to the civil aspect of the case. If the challenge attacks the criminal aspect, the action must be under the control and authority of the State.

But the Court clarified an important distinction. When the case is before the Regional Trial Court, the State is represented by the provincial or city prosecutor. When the case is before the Court of Appeals or the Supreme Court, the State is represented by the Office of the Solicitor General. Because Marilao Medical’s Rule 65 petition was filed before the RTC and bore the express conformity of the Office of the City Prosecutor, the RTC should not have dismissed it outright for lack of authority.

This is the decision’s first practical doctrine: a private complainant may initiate a Rule 65 petition attacking the criminal aspect before the RTC if the proper public prosecutor expressly concurs. The petition need not be filed in the name of the prosecutor alone, but the State’s concurrence must be clear.

The Substantive Ruling: Prosecutor Conformity Does Not Defeat Double Jeopardy

Although the Supreme Court found that the RTC should have given due course to the petition, it still denied relief on the merits. The Court held that Marilao Medical failed to show grave abuse of discretion by the MeTC.

The Court emphasized that an acquittal is final, unappealable, and immediately executory. The State is not allowed to make repeated attempts to convict an accused after losing the case. A Rule 65 petition may be available only in the most exceptional cases, such as when the trial court acted in a capricious, whimsical, arbitrary, or despotic manner, or when the prosecution was denied due process. In criminal cases, the petitioner must show more than a possible mistake in the judge’s evaluation of evidence. It must show that the proceeding was tainted by jurisdictional error, such as a sham trial or a denial of the prosecution’s opportunity to present its case.

The MeTC’s grant of the demurrer did not meet that high standard. The trial court explained why it found the prosecution evidence insufficient. It noted the absence of proof that Dr. Royales ordered the falsification, the absence of proof linking any alleged order to the specific documents charged in the informations, and the failure to establish actual possession or authorship merely from his status as owner of Best Care.

No Automatic Presumption Against Company Owners

One of the most important takeaways for business owners and corporate officers is the Court’s treatment of the presumption of authorship in falsification cases. Marilao Medical argued that because Dr. Royales owned Best Care and allegedly benefited from the questioned documents, authorship should be presumed against him.

The Court rejected that leap. Possession and authorship of a falsified document cannot be presumed merely because a person is an officer or owner of the company that used or produced the document. There must be evidence of actual possession or a concrete link between the accused and the falsified document. Likewise, any benefit received from a company’s use of documents may be merely incidental and is not, by itself, enough to establish criminal liability.

This matters beyond healthcare and laboratory disputes. In corporate fraud, falsification, procurement, billing, and regulatory cases, prosecutors and complainants must connect the accused person to the specific criminal act. A title such as owner, president, director, or manager may be relevant, but it is not a substitute for proof.

The Concurring Opinion: The Finality of Acquittal Should Be Even More Strictly Applied

Justice Caguioa concurred but wrote separately to stress the double jeopardy concern. In his view, a grant of demurrer to evidence is a resolution on the merits equivalent to acquittal. Once that happens after the prosecution has presented its case, review of the acquittal risks violating the accused’s constitutional protection against double jeopardy unless the prosecution was denied due process.

The concurrence underscores the narrowness of the Rule 65 exception. It is not enough to say that the judge misunderstood the facts, misread the evidence, or reached the wrong conclusion. Unless the prosecution was denied its day in court, the acquittal must generally remain untouched.

Practical Impact: What Complainants Should Do Before Filing Criminal Cases

For complainants, the lesson is preventive rather than corrective. The strongest work must be done before and during trial, not after acquittal. If a case depends on allegedly falsified documents, the prosecution must be ready to authenticate the documents, identify the signatories where necessary, establish why the documents are false, and connect the accused to the specific acts charged.

Business complainants should also distinguish between suspicion of an anomaly and proof of personal criminal participation. The Court acknowledged that a falsification scheme may have existed, but that was not enough. Criminal liability still required proof tying the accused to the charged falsification.

For accused persons and defense counsel, the ruling confirms the strategic importance of a demurrer to evidence. If the prosecution fails to establish all material elements of the offense, a demurrer may end the criminal case entirely. Once granted on insufficiency of evidence, the resulting acquittal becomes extremely difficult to disturb.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises complainants, accused persons, corporate officers, clinics, employers, and business owners involved in criminal complaints, falsification cases, fraud investigations, and related civil claims. The Royales ruling shows that criminal litigation is often won or lost on evidence architecture: who can authenticate the document, who has personal knowledge, and how the accused is linked to the specific act charged.

If you are preparing to file a criminal complaint, defending against one, or assessing whether an acquittal can still be challenged without violating double jeopardy, our litigation team can help evaluate the evidence, procedural options, and civil recovery strategy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco on criminal litigation, corporate disputes, and evidence-driven case strategy.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *