DOJ Prosecutors May Use a Higher Screening Standard Before Filing Criminal Cases

The Supreme Court upheld the DOJ’s 2024 preliminary investigation rules, allowing prosecutors to require prima facie evidence with reasonable certainty of conviction. People facing criminal complaints before prosecutors may now invoke a more demanding screening standard at the preliminary investigation stage: the DOJ’s 2024 rules requiring prima facie evidence with reasonable certainty of conviction remain […]

Private Complainants Can Challenge Acquittals Only Through the State — and Even Then, Double Jeopardy Sets a High Wall

Private complainants may challenge the criminal aspect with prosecutor conformity, but acquittals after demurrer stand absent grave abuse or denial of due process. A private complainant who loses a criminal case after a demurrer to evidence cannot simply relitigate the acquittal by arguing that the trial court weighed the evidence incorrectly. The practical rule is […]

Payment Extensions Do Not Automatically Erase Trust Receipt Criminal Liability

A payment extension did not novate trust receipt obligations; officers may still face estafa for failing to remit sale proceeds or return goods. Corporate officers who sign trust receipts cannot assume that a later payment schedule, restructuring, or partial settlement will automatically convert the transaction into an ordinary loan and eliminate exposure to estafa. When […]

When Tax Structuring Becomes Evidence: Why Probable Cause Is Hard to Stop Before Trial

The Supreme Court upheld probable cause in a graft case, warning that tax-driven asset registration and ownership defenses are trial issues. Business owners, corporate officers, and politically exposed persons cannot defeat a graft prosecution at the preliminary investigation stage merely by presenting documents that dispute ownership, agency, or tax-driven structuring. Where the Ombudsman has evidence […]

Corporate Officers Can Face Criminal Liability for Blocking a Member’s Right to Inspect Records

Corporate officers may face liability for refusing a member’s written demand to inspect records, even if the corporation’s registration was revoked. Corporate transparency is not optional: a member who makes a written demand to inspect association records may trigger personal criminal exposure for officers who refuse access without a lawful basis. For officers of corporations, […]

When Withholding Corporate Books Becomes a Criminal Case

Refusal to inspect a stock and transfer book may be criminal, but only if the accused acted for the corporation in denying statutory inspection rights. Stockholders and directors have a legally enforceable right to inspect a corporation’s records, minutes, and stock and transfer book, but a criminal prosecution for denial of that right will prosper […]

LPG Refillers Can Face Criminal Charges for Using Branded Cylinders Without Written Authority

Unauthorized refilling of branded LPG cylinders may support BP 33 charges, but only officers managing the business or responsible employees may face liability. LPG refillers cannot treat a customer’s possession of a branded cylinder as permission to refill it. When a cylinder bears another company’s brand, embossing, or identifying mark, refilling it without written authority […]

When a Civil Case Will Not Stop a Criminal Case for Falsification

A civil loan dispute did not suspend falsification charges because it would not necessarily determine the accused officer’s guilt or innocence. A pending civil dispute will not automatically suspend a criminal prosecution for falsification. A person accused of making documents appear to show a loan, transaction, or participation that allegedly did not exist must face […]

When a Criminal Case Cannot Be Stopped Mid-Trial: The Joseph Doctrine on Demurrers, Certiorari, and Separate Trials

A denied mid-trial motion to acquit usually cannot stop a criminal case by certiorari, but separate trials may be ordered to prevent prejudice among accused. Accused persons, including taxpayers and corporate officers facing criminal prosecution, cannot usually stop a criminal case through certiorari simply because they believe the prosecution’s evidence is weak. The remedy is […]

When a Criminal Case Can Be Revived Without a New Information

A provisional criminal dismissal with the accused’s consent may be revived without a new information if the order clearly lacks finality. A criminal case provisionally dismissed with the accused’s express consent may still be revived without filing a new information, so long as the dismissal order itself makes clear that it is not final and […]