Supreme Court acquits one estafa accused, affirms another’s conviction, but bars recovery of money paid for an illegal party-list seat deal.
Money paid for an unlawful promise to secure public office may not be recoverable in court, even when the transaction also involved deceit. In Morales, the Supreme Court acquitted one accused for lack of proof of conspiracy and personal deceit, affirmed the estafa conviction of the principal actor, but deleted the civil award because the complainant and the main wrongdoer were both engaged in an illegal arrangement to obtain a congressional seat through the party-list system.
Why This Case Matters to Clients
The most consequential point is not simply that an estafa conviction was partly reversed. The ruling is a warning about illegal transactions dressed up as contracts, joint ventures, political contributions, or reimbursement arrangements. A written agreement, receipts, emails, and a money-back clause will not necessarily save a party who knowingly pays for an unlawful objective. Courts may still enforce the criminal law against the fraudster, but refuse to help the payor recover the money if both sides stood on equal fault.
For business owners, political donors, consultants, and individuals who deal with fixers or influence-peddlers, the practical lesson is direct: when the object of the bargain is illegal or contrary to public policy, the courts may leave the parties where they are. A person may have been deceived, but if the very transaction was to buy access, influence, or public office, recovery becomes legally precarious.
Background: The Party-List Seat Arrangement
The case arose from an estafa charge involving an alleged promise that Catherine Factor-Koura would secure a congressional seat through the party-list system in exchange for large payments. The prosecution alleged that the accused represented that she would be assured a party-list seat and that her money would be returned if the party-list did not win. The case reached the Supreme Court after the trial court and the Court of Appeals convicted Mark Joel Morales and Armando Almo Co for estafa, while another accused was acquitted. The Supreme Court decision was issued on August 20, 2025 (G.R. No. 267896).
The payments were substantial. The complainant allegedly paid P15 million under a memorandum of agreement and later additional amounts, bringing the total to P17 million. The agreement was framed as funding for party-list projects and platforms, but the factual theory of the prosecution was that the money was tied to securing a congressional nomination and seat. When the expected political result did not materialize, the complainant sought recovery and criminal accountability.
The Supreme Court’s Ruling: Acquittal for One Accused, Conviction for Another
The Supreme Court granted the petition of Morales and acquitted him of estafa. The Court held that the prosecution failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that Morales conspired with Armando Co or that Morales himself made fraudulent representations that induced the complainant to part with her money.
The Court emphasized that conspiracy is never presumed. Mere association, presence in meetings, participation in political or organizational activities, or being named in documents is not enough. To convict an accused on the basis of conspiracy, the prosecution must prove a common criminal design and intentional participation in the execution of that design. In Morales’ case, the Court found that the evidence pointed to Co as the person who made the key representations, received the payments, and dealt with the complainant on the supposed money-back guarantee.
The Supreme Court also held that the elements of estafa by deceit were not proven as to Morales. His alleged acts, including his affiliation with the organization, his role as a supposed nominee, and his presence in events connected with the party-list effort, did not establish that he made the false pretenses that caused the complainant to pay. Without proof of fraudulent inducement attributable to him, his conviction could not stand.
Why Armando Co’s Criminal Liability Remained
The Court made clear that the acquittal of one accused does not automatically absolve another. Criminal liability is personal. If the evidence independently proves that one accused committed the crime, that conviction may remain even if a co-accused is acquitted.
As to Co, the Court found that the evidence showed his direct and independent participation. He was identified as the person who made representations about the complainant’s supposed nomination, received the checks and payments, handled the disputed arrangement, and repeatedly gave assurances. The Court therefore affirmed his conviction for estafa under Article 315, paragraph 2(a) of the Revised Penal Code.
The In Pari Delicto Doctrine: Why the P17 Million Civil Award Was Deleted
The most striking part of the ruling is the deletion of the P17 million civil liability. Ordinarily, an estafa conviction carries civil consequences because the offender is required to return what was fraudulently obtained. But the Supreme Court held that this case involved an illegal transaction: payment of money in exchange for a congressional seat through the party-list system.
The Court applied the doctrine of in pari delicto. When parties are in equal fault in an illegal transaction, courts generally will not grant affirmative relief to either side. The doctrine rests on the principle that no action arises from a wrongful cause. Contracts designed to traffic in public office or manipulate electoral processes are void for being contrary to public policy. They undermine democratic institutions and public trust.
Thus, while Co’s criminal conviction remained, the complainant could not recover the P17 million through the civil award because she was found to have participated in the unlawful transaction. The law punished the criminal deceit, but it did not assist the complainant in recovering money paid for an illegal political objective.
Practical Impact: What This Means for Clients
For prospective complainants, this ruling shows the importance of separating fraud from illegality. A person who was tricked into paying money may have a criminal complaint, but if the payment itself was made for an unlawful purpose, civil recovery may be barred. The court may recognize that a crime occurred while still refusing to return the money because the complainant was not an innocent party to the bargain.
For accused persons, the ruling reinforces the constitutional requirement of proof beyond reasonable doubt. Association with a wrongdoer is not enough. Being present in meetings, signing documents, being part of an organization, or sharing a broad objective does not automatically prove conspiracy. Prosecutors must connect each accused to the fraudulent representation, the inducement, and the resulting damage.
For companies and individuals dealing with consultants, political intermediaries, or persons claiming government connections, the case is a serious compliance warning. Avoid arrangements that promise licenses, appointments, nominations, permits, government approvals, or public office in exchange for money. Even if the transaction is documented and includes a refund clause, the illegal purpose may defeat civil recovery and expose participants to criminal, regulatory, or reputational consequences.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Fraud cases often involve overlapping issues of criminal liability, civil recovery, public policy, documentary evidence, and the personal participation of each accused. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises clients in Makati and across the Philippines on estafa complaints, defense strategy, civil recovery, contract risk, corporate fraud, and litigation involving disputed payments and alleged misrepresentations.
If you are considering filing an estafa complaint, defending against one, or assessing whether a disputed transaction can still be recovered in court, our litigation team can help evaluate the evidence, identify the strongest theory of liability or defense, and determine whether public policy doctrines such as in pari delicto may affect your case. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco about criminal, civil, and commercial litigation strategy.