Judicial mistakes are corrected by appeal, not discipline, unless clear evidence proves fraud, bad faith, bias, or corrupt motive by the judge.

A party who believes a judgment contains a serious error must usually challenge that error through appeal or other proper court remedies, not by filing an administrative case against the judge. The Damayo ruling draws a firm line between judicial error and judicial misconduct: a mistaken word in a decision may justify correction on review, but it does not become fraud, bias, or corruption without clear and convincing proof of bad faith.

The Practical Rule: Not Every Wrong Judgment Is Judicial Misconduct

The central doctrine may be called the judicial good-faith error rule. Judges may be disciplined for acts showing fraud, dishonesty, corruption, bad faith, malice, bias, or deliberate intent to do injustice. But when the complaint is merely that the judge made an erroneous ruling, the remedy is judicial review, not an administrative complaint.

This distinction matters to litigants because administrative complaints against judges are not substitutes for lost appeals. A party who misses a procedural remedy, chooses the wrong mode of appeal, or fails to timely pursue available review cannot normally convert that litigation loss into a disciplinary case by re-labeling the ruling as fraudulent.

Background: A Criminal Conviction, a Missing Word, and a Failed Appeal

Catherine Damayo was charged with estafa before the Regional Trial Court of Mandaue City. The case was then presided over by Judge Marilyn Lagura-Yap, who later became an Associate Justice of the Court of Appeals-Visayas. After trial, the court convicted Damayo and imposed an indeterminate prison sentence, civil liability for the amount involved, and interest.

The controversy arose because the first page of the trial court judgment stated that Damayo had pleaded


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *