A judge was fined for chamber arraignment, delayed proceedings, and apparent bias, reaffirming that criminal arraignment must be done in open court.

Criminal defendants, complainants, and litigants may insist that arraignment be done in open court, not informally or privately, because the arraignment is the moment when the criminal case formally joins issue and allows the proceedings to move forward. When a judge tolerates years of unexplained delay or appears to conduct arraignment inside chambers, the problem is not a mere technical lapse. It becomes a question of judicial competence, impartiality, and public confidence in the courts.

Why This Ruling Matters to People Facing Criminal Cases

For an ordinary person accused in a criminal case, arraignment is not just a hearing date on the calendar. It is the stage where the charge is read to the accused in a language or dialect known to him, and where the accused is asked whether he pleads guilty or not guilty. Without a valid arraignment, the case cannot properly proceed to trial.

This ruling is especially important for persons asking practical questions such as: can a judge arraign an accused in chambers, what happens if arraignment is repeatedly postponed, can a judge be disciplined for ignoring criminal procedure, and how do I complain about bias or partiality by a judge? The answer from Bandoy v. Judge Jacinto is direct: Rule 116 is not optional, and judges who disregard basic criminal procedure may be administratively sanctioned.

Background: A Criminal Case, Delayed Arraignment, and Alleged Leniency

The administrative complaint arose from two related criminal proceedings in Occidental Mindoro. Gaspar Bandoy was one of the accused in a serious illegal detention case filed by Romulo De Jesus, Jr. Bandoy claimed that the case was retaliatory because he had earlier been instrumental in the filing of a criminal complaint against De Jesus for ballot switching in connection with the 2007 local elections.

In the ballot-switching case, Bandoy alleged that De Jesus repeatedly failed to appear for arraignment. The arraignment was originally scheduled for April 23, 2008, but was reset several times until De Jesus eventually entered a plea of not guilty on July 6, 2011. Bandoy alleged that this arraignment took place inside the judge’s chambers, not in open court. The administrative matter was resolved by the Supreme Court in Bandoy v. Judge Jacinto (A.M. No. RTJ-14-2399, November 19, 2014).

Bandoy also accused Judge Jose S. Jacinto, Jr. of bias and partiality, claiming that the judge showed unreasonable leniency toward De Jesus while Bandoy and his co-accused remained exposed to the consequences of a non-bailable serious illegal detention charge. Some of Bandoy’s allegations, including claims involving an alleged arrest order and accommodations for a court audit team, were not credited by the Office of the Court Administrator because of insufficient proof. But the allegation concerning the repeated resettings and the supposed chamber arraignment became central.

The Court’s Core Doctrine: Arraignment Must Be Public, Formal, and Rule-Compliant

The Supreme Court emphasized that competence and diligence are prerequisites to judicial office. A judge is presumed to know the law, and the duty to maintain professional competence is not ceremonial. It is essential to the legitimacy of the court.

Rule 116, Section 1(a) of the Revised Rules of Criminal Procedure requires that arraignment be made in open court. The accused must be furnished a copy of the complaint or information, the charge must be read in a language or dialect known to the accused, and the accused must be asked whether he pleads guilty or not guilty. These steps are not empty rituals. They are integral safeguards at a crucial stage of criminal litigation.

The Court found Judge Jacinto administratively guilty of gross ignorance of Rule 116. The ruling treated anything less than the required open-court procedure as a serious breach of judicial duty. The judge’s failure to squarely answer the allegation that the arraignment was conducted inside chambers also mattered. The Court accepted the Office of the Court Administrator’s observation that silence in the face of a serious accusation affecting one’s judicial office may create public doubt.

Why Silence and Leniency Created an Appearance of Bias

The Court did not merely punish a technical error. It looked at the larger picture: repeated postponements of arraignment from 2007 to 2011, the absence of appropriate action to compel the accused’s appearance, and the appearance of leniency toward one party. The Court said it could not understand why the arraignment had been postponed for years without appropriate action from the court.

That point is important for litigants. Judicial bias is not proven only by direct evidence of favoritism. A court’s conduct may also create an appearance of partiality when a judge fails to enforce ordinary procedural rules against one side while the other side suffers the consequences of delay. The Court reiterated that judges must not only be honest and impartial; they must also appear honest and impartial.

For business owners, employers, property owners, and individuals involved in litigation, this principle has practical force. A party does not need to accept unexplained procedural irregularity as normal. When a judge’s handling of a case gives a reasonable appearance of unequal treatment, that may be raised through the proper judicial or administrative remedies, depending on the nature of the conduct and available evidence.

Gross Ignorance of the Law Is a Serious Charge

The Court classified gross ignorance of the law or procedure as a serious administrative charge under Rule 140 of the Rules of Court. Gross ignorance exists when a judge commits a gross or patent error, or when the judge ignores settled law and procedure in a manner that demonstrates bad faith, fraud, dishonesty, corruption, or inexcusable incompetence. Good faith does not automatically excuse a judge who shows an utter lack of familiarity with basic rules.

Here, Rule 116 was not obscure. It was a basic criminal procedure rule governing arraignment. The Court stressed that judges owe the public and the legal profession more than a casual acquaintance with statutes and procedural rules. When a judge mishandles basic procedure, public confidence in the courts is eroded.

The Penalty Imposed

The Supreme Court found Judge Jacinto guilty of gross ignorance of the law and procedure, and of bias and partiality. He was fined P40,000.00 and sternly warned that repetition of the same or similar act would be dealt with more severely.

The Court noted that there were other pending administrative cases against the judge, but those could not be fully considered in determining the penalty because they were still under review and evaluation. The sanction in this case was therefore based on the proven administrative violations before the Court.

Practical Impact: What Litigants Should Take Away

The most practical lesson is that courtroom procedure matters because it protects both liberty and public trust. In criminal cases, arraignment must happen in open court. Repeated postponements should not be casually tolerated when the court has legal tools to compel attendance. A judge’s failure to enforce basic procedure can create a perception that one side is being favored.

For accused persons, the arraignment process is a safeguard, not a formality. For complainants and private parties, it confirms that delay and unexplained leniency may be questioned. For lawyers, it is a reminder to build a clear record: hearing dates, orders of postponement, absences, motions, and objections matter when later proving procedural irregularity or judicial bias.

The ruling also shows the limits of administrative complaints. Allegations of bias must be supported by proof. Claims that are speculative or unsupported may be disregarded. But where the record shows a basic procedural violation, and the judge fails to respond meaningfully to a serious charge, administrative accountability may follow.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients in criminal litigation, civil litigation, labor cases, property disputes, and administrative proceedings where court delay, procedural irregularity, or apparent partiality affects the outcome of a case. For parties facing criminal arraignment issues, questionable court orders, delayed proceedings, or concerns about judicial conduct, our litigation team can evaluate the record, identify available remedies, and prepare the appropriate motions, pleadings, or administrative complaints.

For case assessment and litigation strategy, visit MakatiLawFirm.com and consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco, a full-service law firm based in Makati City.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *