Congress Can Restructure GOCC Offices Without Violating Security of Tenure

Congress may validly shorten GOCC officialsโ€™ terms and centralize compensation reform when done in good faith for fiscal discipline and public accountability. Congress may shorten the terms, restructure the offices, and rationalize the compensation of government-owned or controlled corporation officials when the changes are made in good faith, supported by a clear public policy, and […]

When Court Evidence Disappears: Lost Drug Exhibits Can Cost Court Personnel Their Careers

Court personnel may be dismissed when lost drug evidence compromises pending criminal cases, with clerks liable for gross neglect of duty. Court personnel who mishandle evidence can be dismissed from government service when their negligence compromises pending criminal cases, especially where the missing exhibits are the very drugs needed to prove the offense. For litigants, […]

Good Faith Can Save Officials and Employees From Refunding Disallowed Government Benefits

COA correctly disallowed CNU employee benefits, but the Court excused officials and recipients from refund due to good faith, services rendered, and undue prejudice. Government officials who approved benefits later disallowed by the Commission on Audit are not automatically required to refund them when they acted in good faith, and employees who received modest or […]

Association Standing Rule: Why Multiple Court Challenges Can Fail

Associations must prove member authority and direct injury; repeated regulatory challenges risk dismissal for standing, mootness, and forum shopping rules. The association standing rule means that a trade group cannot simply invoke the interests of an industry and expect the courts to decide a major regulatory challenge. An association that sues for its members must […]

When SEC Fees Become Oppressive: Businesses Can Challenge Excessive Regulatory Charges

Supreme Court voided an excessive SEC corporate term extension fee, holding that regulatory charges must be reasonable, proportionate, and not oppressive. Regulatory agencies may collect filing and license fees, but those fees cannot be so large, arbitrary, or disproportionate that they effectively punish a business for seeking approval of an ordinary corporate act. For corporations, […]

RMO No. 13-2020: Revised BIRโ€™s BEST Employee Recognition Rules, Rewards, and Approval Deadline

RMO No. 13-2020 amends BIRโ€™s BEST rules, setting July 1 indorsement and โ‚ฑ5,000/โ‚ฑ10,000 awards, with no new taxpayer filing duty. BIR offices conducting the annual BIRโ€™s Best Employee for Service Excellence and Public Trust must apply the amended recognition rules immediately: finalists receive โ‚ฑ5,000.00 each, overall winners receive โ‚ฑ10,000.00 each, and the Executive PRAISE Committee […]

RMO No. 4-2020: New BIR Regional Legal Division Workflow for Formal Charges and Administrative Decisions

RMO No. 4-2020 standardizes how BIR Legal Divisions handle formal charges and regional decisions in personnel administrative cases. BIR regional administrative cases must now follow a uniform Legal Division workflow before formal charges and regional decisions are served, implemented, and furnished to the required offices. RMO No. 4-2020 matters to businesses, tax practitioners, and in-house […]

Gun Licenses Are a Privilege, But Your Home Still Needs a Warrant

Gun ownership is only a statutory privilege, but firearm licensing cannot justify warrantless PNP inspections of private homes. Firearm owners in the Philippines cannot claim a constitutional right to own or carry guns, but the government also cannot turn gun licensing into an open-ended license to enter and inspect a private home. The controlling doctrine […]

When Government Bonuses Must Be Returned: COA Disallowance, Special Trust Funds, and the Limits of Good Faith

Government employees may be required to refund unauthorized incentives after COA disallowance, even without fraud, when public funds lacked legal basis. Government employees who receive unauthorized bonuses or incentives may be ordered to return them even if they acted without fraud and believed the payment was valid. For state universities and other public institutions, the […]

GOCC Board Allowances Are Not Automatically Double Compensation

GOCC board per diems and RATA are not automatically double compensation, but bonuses remain risky absent clear legal authority. Government officials who sit on the board of a government-owned or controlled corporation are not automatically required to return every allowance, per diem, or RATA they receive. The controlling question is more precise: whether the payment […]