Government employees may be required to refund unauthorized incentives after COA disallowance, even without fraud, when public funds lacked legal basis.
Government employees who receive unauthorized bonuses or incentives may be ordered to return them even if they acted without fraud and believed the payment was valid. For state universities and other public institutions, the ruling is a warning that special trust funds cannot be treated as a general source of employee benefits unless the payment has a clear legal basis and is tied to the purposes allowed by law.
Why This Case Matters to Public Employees and Government Agencies
The dispute arose from an Accomplishment Incentive Award granted by Bulacan State University to its officials, faculty members, and non-academic personnel. The university’s Board of Regents approved the incentive in recognition of efforts allegedly contributing to excellence in education, sports, and culture. The amount involved was substantial: P37,876,296.57 in disbursements charged against the university’s Special Trust Fund.
On post-audit, the Commission on Audit disallowed the payment. COA found the incentive irregular and without legal basis, citing the constitutional rule against additional compensation, the Salary Standardization Law, and audit rules on unauthorized allowances and benefits. The employees and officials challenged the disallowance, arguing that the university’s governing board had authority under the Higher Education Modernization Act to use special trust funds for instruction, research, extension, and other programs or projects of the university.
In Chozas and De Jesus v. Commission on Audit (G.R. Nos. 226319 and 235031), the Supreme Court affirmed COA’s disallowance and required all officers and employees who received the Accomplishment Incentive Award to return the amounts they received.
The Doctrine: Special Trust Funds Are Purpose-Limited Public Funds
The core doctrine is simple but consequential: a state university’s Special Trust Fund is not a discretionary bonus pool. Although Republic Act No. 8292 allows state universities and colleges to retain income from tuition, school charges, auxiliary services, and land grants, the use of those funds remains limited by law. The funds may be disbursed for instruction, research, extension, or other programs and projects of the university or college.
The Court rejected the argument that a broad institutional goal, such as promoting excellence, was enough to justify a general incentive award. The phrase