Taxpayers May Wait for the BIRโ€™s Final Decision Before Going to the CTA

Taxpayers who protest BIR assessments may wait for the final BIR decision after 180 days, then appeal to the CTA within 30 days from receipt. A taxpayer who timely protests a tax assessment is not forced to rush to the Court of Tax Appeals the moment the BIR fails to act within 180 days. The […]

When COA Disallows Government Allowances, Good Faith Can Still Save Recipients From Refund

COA may disallow unauthorized RATA, but public officers who received allowances in good faith under official approval may avoid refund liability. Government directors and officers may lose the legal basis for an allowance, yet still avoid refunding it when they received the benefit in good faith under an official corporate approval. For public corporations, government […]

Court Clerks Can Be Disciplined for Poor Attendance Supervision Even Without Personal Absence

Court clerks must monitor assigned staff and attendance, but poor supervision without grave neglect may warrant admonition, while first-offense tardiness merits reprimand. Court officials cannot escape accountability by saying that subordinate employees failed to report for duty on their own; a clerk of court who assigns personnel to Saturday work must still monitor attendance and […]

Local Governments Can Franchise Tricycles, But They Cannot Take Over LTO Registration and Driver Licensing

Cities may franchise tricycles, but they cannot replace LTO vehicle registration or driver licensing through local tax or regulatory ordinances. A city may regulate and franchise tricycles for local transport, but it cannot require tricycle owners and drivers to obtain local vehicle registration and driver licenses in place of those issued by the Land Transportation […]

Autonomous Regional Bodies Must Still Follow Due Process Before Removing Their Own Officials

Autonomous regional bodies may manage internal affairs, but removal or expulsion still requires due process and remains subject to judicial review. Even autonomous regional assemblies cannot remove an elected presiding officer by political shortcut: when an official is stripped of office through accusations of misconduct, the body must still observe due process, allow the official […]

When a National Permit Cannot Take Away a Municipal Revenue Service

A municipal ferry service cannot be displaced by a transport certificate issued without direct notice, especially where local revenue powers are affected. Municipal governments with statutory authority over local ferry services cannot be stripped of that revenue-generating function by an administrative transport certificate issued without direct notice and hearing. The ruling matters for local tax […]

Official Errands Can Be Compensable Even Outside Work Hours

Work-related errands may be compensable even outside office hours or premises when the injury is connected to official duties and evidence is unrebutted. Employees injured while performing a work-related errand may still be entitled to employeesโ€™ compensation even if the accident happens outside regular office hours, away from the workplace, or on a day when […]

After Proclamation, Election Fights Move to Election Protest โ€” Not Certiorari

After proclamation, election disputes generally shift to election protest or quo warranto, making pre-proclamation certiorari challenges moot. A candidate already proclaimed after an election generally cannot keep a pre-proclamation fight alive by recasting it as a certiorari or prohibition case. Once the voters have cast their ballots, the winners have been proclaimed, and the losing […]