When a Child Victim’s Testimony Is Enough to Convict, But the Penalty Must Stay Within the Charge

A child victim’s credible testimony may sustain a rape conviction, but uncharged aggravating circumstances cannot increase the penalty on appeal. A rape conviction may rest on the clear, candid, and consistent testimony of a young victim, even without dramatic physical resistance or immediate reporting; but an accused cannot receive a harsher penalty based on aggravating […]

When Mental Deficiency Makes Consent Legally Impossible in Rape Cases

The Court affirmed a rape conviction, holding that mental deficiency may make consent legally impossible despite the victim’s ability to testify. A person who is mentally incapable of giving intelligent consent may be legally treated as incapable of consent, even if she answers some questions in court and even if the accused claims romance, voluntary […]

Judges Cannot Blame Staff for Court Record Delays

A judge may be held liable when appealed records are not elevated on time, even if staff caused the delay, because court supervision remains the judge’s duty. Court delays caused by missing transcripts, misplaced records, or staff inaction can still result in liability for the judge who supervises the branch. The doctrine is simple but […]

When a Tax Refund Judgment Cannot Be Collected While an Appeal Is Pending

A refund winner cannot collect during appeal without exceptional reasons. A bond and trial court confidence in its ruling are not enough. A taxpayer who wins a refund case at the trial court does not automatically get to collect while the losing party appeals. Even when a tax-related exaction has been declared unconstitutional, execution pending […]

Arson, Alibi, and Positive Identification: When Property Disputes Become Criminal Liability

Eyewitness identification defeated alibi in an arson case tied to a property dispute, while the Court reduced the penalty under post-1987 rules. A person accused of burning another’s house cannot escape conviction by claiming to be elsewhere when eyewitnesses positively identify him at the scene and the surrounding facts show motive, opportunity, and participation. For […]

Missed Appeal Deadlines Can Kill a Tax Case: When Extensions Are Allowed and When They Are Not

Lacsamana explains when appeal extensions are allowed, warning taxpayers that the wrong appellate remedy or late filing can defeat even strong tax defenses. Taxpayers who lose before a court or quasi-judicial body cannot assume that asking for more time will preserve their appeal. Lacsamana clarified a hard procedural dividing line: some appeals allow extensions, but […]

When an Accomplice’s Story Is Enough to Convict: The Co-Conspirator Testimony Rule in Robbery with Homicide

A co-conspirator’s testimony may support conviction when sincere, detailed, and consistent with the evidence, as shown in a robbery with homicide ruling. A conviction may rest on an accomplice’s testimony when the account is sincere, direct, and detailed enough to show that it was not a calculated afterthought. For accused persons, complainants, and families involved […]