When One Gunman Starts a Deadly Attack, All Conspirators May Answer for Murder

Group attackers may all face murder liability when conspiracy is proven through coordinated acts, even if each personโ€™s exact role is not separately shown. A person who joins an armed group attack may be convicted not only for the shot he personally fired, but for the killing carried out by the group when the evidence […]

Tenants Cannot Stop Ejectment Execution by Calling It Mandamus After Missing the Appeal Route

A tenant who loses an ejectment case cannot use mandamus to revive a missed appeal or stop execution without appeal, bond, and rental deposits. A tenant who loses an unlawful detainer case cannot freeze execution simply by recasting the dispute as mandamus after failing to pursue the proper appellate remedy. The controlling lesson of Patalinghug […]

A Perfected Appeal Should Not Be Lost Because the Court Transmitted the Record Late

A timely perfected appeal should not be dismissed solely because the court transmitted the record late, especially after the appellate court already received it. A litigant who perfects an appeal on time should not automatically lose the right to appellate review merely because the lower court or its clerk transmitted the record late. The ruling […]

Equitable Appeal Perfection: When One Day Should Not Defeat Justice

Technical appeal dismissals may be relaxed when substantial compliance, proof of mailing, and serious expropriation issues require review. Equitable appeal perfection means that a court should not automatically throw out an appeal for a minor procedural delay when the record shows substantial compliance, government counsel was not negligent, and the case involves a serious public […]

When an Appeal Becomes Pointless: Mootness Lessons for Tax Litigation

A final main judgment can render related petitions moot, warning taxpayers that ancillary motions cannot replace timely appeals in tax disputes. A pending appeal can die not because the partyโ€™s argument is weak, but because the main case has already become final and executory. For taxpayers, corporations, and litigants challenging government action, the practical lesson […]

A Criminal Information Limits What the Court May Convict You Of

A rape charge alleging force did not support conviction for simple seduction because deceit was not alleged. Courts may convict only on the charge as written. A person charged with one crime cannot be convicted of another offense unless the lesser offense is necessarily included in the charge as written. In Barba, the Court applied […]

When a Lawyer Misses the Appeal Brief Deadline, the Client Is Not Automatically to Blame

A lawyer cannot let an appeal deadline lapse by blaming unpaid printing costs. Counsel must seek relief, inform the court, or protect the clientโ€™s case. A lawyer handling an appeal cannot excuse a missed brief deadline simply by saying the client failed to advance printing costs. If the lawyer remains counsel of record, the duty […]