Stopped Bank Drafts Do Not Defeat a Holder in Due Course

A holder in due course may collect on stopped bank drafts; the bank-drawer remains liable despite a separate indemnity deal with its customer. A party who receives a negotiable bank draft in good faith and for value is not left empty-handed merely because payment is later stopped. When a bank draft is dishonored after a […]

Unregistered Land Buyer Peril Rule: Banks Lose Bad Mortgages

Buyers of unregistered land act at their peril; banks may lose mortgages if the borrower had no ownership and prior possession proves another claim. The Unregistered Land Buyer Peril Rule means that a bank, buyer, or creditor who accepts unregistered land as security cannot rely on good faith if the supposed owner had no real […]

Notarized Surety Agreements Are Hard to Escape: Why a Forgery Defense Needs More Than a Handwriting Report

A notarized surety agreement cannot be defeated by denial alone; forgery must be proven by clear, convincing evidence, not weak handwriting comparison. Business owners, corporate officers, and loan sureties cannot lightly escape a notarized surety agreement by merely denying their signature or presenting an inconclusive handwriting report. When a person signs as surety for a […]

Strict DST Rule: When Interbank Call Loans Are Not Taxable

Interbank call loans are not subject to DST unless clearly taxed by law; later tax code amendments cannot retroactively burden taxpayers. Banks cannot be made to pay documentary stamp tax on interbank call loans unless the tax law clearly, expressly, and unambiguously includes those transactions among taxable instruments. The Strict DST Rule matters because it […]

Tax Amnesty for Documentary Stamp Tax: What Banks Can Claim

Documentary stamp tax may be covered by tax amnesty when it is a direct liability, and BIR circulars cannot add exclusions beyond the law. Taxpayers facing old documentary stamp tax assessments may still invoke tax amnesty when the liability is their own direct tax obligation, not money they merely withheld or collected in trust for […]

Signed and Notarized Loan Documents Are Hard to Undo: When Courts Will Enforce Bank Mortgages Despite Claims of Fraud

Business borrowers challenging signed bank loan and mortgage documents must overcome presumptions of regularity with clear and convincing evidence. Borrowers, corporate officers, and property owners who sign notarized loan, mortgage, pledge, or surety documents cannot later defeat foreclosure by relying on bare allegations that the papers were simulated, coerced, or unsupported by consideration. The Supreme […]

When a Bank Forecloses Beyond the Mortgage: Why Trustees Must Prove the Debt Is Covered

A valid mortgage trustee appointment did not save Metrobankโ€™s foreclosure because it failed to prove San Carlosโ€™ later loans were secured by Centroโ€™s mortgage. A bank acting as mortgage trustee cannot foreclose corporate property for every unpaid loan it later extends unless the loan is actually covered by the mortgage documents. Even where a mortgage […]

Foreign Bank Branches Cannot Be Charged PDIC Premiums on Their Own Head Office Funds

Foreign bank branches need not pay PDIC premiums on head office funds when the placements are internal, payable abroad, and not true public deposits. Foreign bank branches in the Philippines are not required to pay PDIC insurance assessments on funds placed with them by their own head offices or foreign branches when those funds are […]

When Corporate Rehabilitation Cannot Freeze a Guarantorโ€™s Personal Property

Corporate rehabilitation protects corporate assets, not personal properties of guarantors; mortgage fraud and rescission require proof, not mere suspicion. Personal property owned by a corporate guarantor does not automatically become frozen just because the corporation enters suspension of payments or rehabilitation. For creditors, borrowers, banks, and business owners, the practical rule is sharp: a corporate […]