A holder in due course may collect on stopped bank drafts; the bank-drawer remains liable despite a separate indemnity deal with its customer.
A party who receives a negotiable bank draft in good faith and for value is not left empty-handed merely because payment is later stopped. When a bank draft is dishonored after a stop-payment order, the holder in due course may enforce the instrument against the parties liable on it, and a bank-drawer cannot escape liability by pointing to a separate reimbursement or indemnity arrangement with its own customer.
The Doctrine: Stop-Payment Does Not Erase Negotiable Instrument Liability
The central doctrine in Star City v. Llorente may be called the Stop-Payment Recourse Rule. A drawer’s liability on a negotiable instrument is generally secondary, but once payment is stopped and the instrument is effectively dishonored, the holder’s right of recourse arises. The drawer cannot defeat that right by saying that it has already settled separately with another party, particularly where the holder was not bound by that separate arrangement.
For business owners, banks, payment processors, casinos, exporters, contractors, and anyone accepting bank drafts or similar instruments, the ruling is a reminder that negotiable instruments carry legal consequences independent of the private disputes behind them. A customer’s later complaint about the underlying transaction does not automatically cancel the rights of a holder in due course.
Background: A Casino Debt, Two Bank Drafts, and a Stop-Payment Order
Star City Pty Limited, an Australian corporation operating Star City Casino in Sydney, accepted two Equitable PCI Bank drafts from Quintin Llorente, each worth US$150,000.00, for a total of US$300,000.00. Llorente used the drafts to participate in the casino’s Premium Programme. Before allowing him to buy in, Star City verified with the bank that the drafts were issued on clear funds and were not subject to any stop-payment order.
After the drafts were deposited, payment was stopped. Star City demanded payment from Llorente and from Equitable PCI Bank, later BDO Unibank, Inc., and eventually filed a collection case in Makati. Llorente argued that Philippine courts had no jurisdiction, that Star City lacked capacity to sue as a foreign corporation, and that the underlying events occurred in Australia. The case reached the Supreme Court in consolidated petitions (G.R. No. 212050 and 212216, January 15, 2020).
A Foreign Corporation May Sue on an Isolated Transaction
The Court sustained Star City’s capacity to sue in Philippine courts under the isolated transaction rule. A foreign corporation doing business in the Philippines without a license generally cannot maintain an action here. But a foreign corporation not doing business in the Philippines may sue on a singular or isolated transaction, provided that this qualifying fact is affirmatively pleaded.
Star City alleged that it was an Australian corporation, that it was not doing business in the Philippines, and that it was suing on an isolated transaction. Those allegations were enough to establish capacity to sue at the pleading stage. The Court also rejected the argument that the appointment of a Philippine law office as attorney-in-fact destroyed that capacity.
Why Philippine Courts Had Jurisdiction
The dispute was a civil action for collection of a sum of money. The amount demanded, US$300,000.00 plus interest, was far above the jurisdictional threshold for the Regional Trial Court in Metro Manila. The fact that many events occurred in Australia did not deprive the Makati court of jurisdiction over the collection case, especially because the bank drafts were drawn by a Philippine bank.
The Court also observed that, in cases involving checks, relevant places may include where the instrument was drawn, issued, delivered, or dishonored. The Philippine connection was not incidental: the instruments themselves were drawn by Equitable PCI Bank, a Philippine bank.
Star City Was a Holder in Due Course
The Court treated Star City as a holder in due course. It received the drafts before dishonor, for value, in good faith, and without notice of infirmity. The value was not imaginary: Llorente used the drafts to gain access to the casino’s Premium Programme, which provided gaming privileges and rebates. Star City also verified the drafts before accepting them.
As a holder in due course, Star City held the instruments free from personal defenses available among prior parties. That status mattered because Llorente’s allegations of fraud and unfair gaming practices were not proven in a manner that defeated Star City’s rights on the instruments.
The Bank Could Not Hide Behind Unjust Enrichment
The Court rejected Equitable PCI Bank’s reliance on unjust enrichment. The bank argued that it had already reimbursed Llorente and that making it pay Star City would be unfair. But any benefit from the reimbursement went to Llorente, not Star City. Payment to Star City under the bank drafts would not be a mistaken or undue payment; it would be payment based on negotiable instrument liability.
The Court also held that an indemnity agreement between Llorente and the bank did not bind Star City. Under the principle of relativity of contracts, contracts generally take effect only between the parties, their assigns, and heirs. Star City was not a party to the indemnity arrangement, and its rights as holder in due course could not be defeated by it.
Individual and Primary Liability, But Not Solidary Liability
The Court reinstated liability against both Llorente and Equitable PCI Bank, but clarified the nature of that liability. They were individually and primarily liable: Llorente as indorser and the bank as drawer whose liability became enforceable after the stop-payment order and dishonor. However, they were not solidarily liable because solidarity exists only when expressly stated, required by law, or demanded by the nature of the obligation.
Star City could collect the awarded amount from both simultaneously or from either one, but it could not recover more than the total judgment. If the bank paid Star City, the bank could seek recourse against Llorente under their indemnity arrangement.
The Monetary Award
The Court ordered payment of US$300,000.00, with interest at 12% per annum from August 30, 2002 to June 30, 2013, and 6% per annum from July 1, 2013 until full payment. It also awarded attorney’s fees of US$15,000.00, equivalent to 5% of the demand, with 6% interest per annum from finality of the decision until full payment, plus costs of suit.
What This Means for Businesses and Creditors
For creditors, suppliers, and businesses accepting bank drafts, this ruling strengthens confidence in negotiable instruments. If the recipient qualifies as a holder in due course, later disputes between the drawer, payee, and bank will not easily defeat collection. Verification, documentation, and good-faith acceptance remain crucial.
For banks and issuers, the ruling is a warning that stop-payment instructions do not automatically extinguish liability to third-party holders. A separate reimbursement to the customer may create recourse against that customer, but it does not necessarily erase the holder’s rights.
For litigants in cross-border commercial disputes, the decision also shows that Philippine courts may hear collection suits involving foreign corporations when the claim arises from an isolated transaction and the complaint properly pleads the corporation’s capacity to sue.
Need Help Enforcing or Defending a Collection Claim?
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses, creditors, banks, property owners, and individuals in civil litigation, collection suits, negotiable instrument disputes, and cross-border commercial controversies. If you are enforcing a dishonored instrument, responding to a demand letter, or assessing whether a foreign entity may sue in the Philippines, our litigation team can help evaluate your remedies and risks. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our Makati-based litigation lawyers.