When a Private Club Sells Your Membership Share for Unpaid Dues, Property Rights Still Matter

Private clubs may enforce by-laws, but selling a valuable membership share for unpaid dues requires good faith, fair notice, and substantial justice. A non-stock corporation may rely on its by-laws to discipline or terminate a member, but it cannot use vague internal rules to strip a member or an estate of valuable property without substantial […]

When Election Disputes Move From COMELEC to the House Electoral Tribunal

After party-list nominees take office, challenges belong in the HRETβ€”not COMELEC or certiorari. The Court also upheld holdover authority and internal nominations. Once a party-list nominee has been proclaimed, has taken the oath, and has assumed office in Congress, challenges to that nominee’s right to sit no longer belong in COMELEC or in a direct […]

Foreign Government Contractors Cannot Simply Claim Immunity to Defeat Philippine Labor Claims

Foreign government-linked entities must prove sovereign immunity; failure to appeal a labor ruling through the NLRC can make dismissal liability final. Foreign-owned development agencies and government contractors cannot automatically escape Philippine labor jurisdiction by saying they work for a foreign State. If they have a separate corporate personality, enter local employment contracts, and fail to […]

Immediate Payment Rule in Expropriation: When Possession Is Mandatory

In infrastructure expropriation, courts must issue possession once provisional payment is made; final just compensation remains judicial. The Immediate Payment Writ of Possession Rule gives government infrastructure agencies a powerful remedy in expropriation cases: once the required provisional payment is made, the trial court must issue a writ of possession. For property owners, this means […]

Corporate Officers Cannot Convert Removal Disputes Into Labor Cases

A corporate officer named in the by-laws must challenge removal in the proper commercial court, not before the Labor Arbiter or NLRC. A vice president named in a corporation’s by-laws cannot treat removal from office as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the Labor Arbiter. When the position is a corporate office, the dispute belongs […]

Tax Classification Freeze Rule: When Sin Taxes Survive Challenge

Tax classifications survive equal protection attacks when rationally tied to revenue, administration, and uniform tax enforcement goals. The Tax Classification Freeze Rule gives Congress broad room to design excise tax brackets for regulated products, even when the result places old and new brands in different tax positions, so long as the classification rests on a […]

Ample Opportunity Rule: Due Process in Philippine Dismissals

Employee dismissal for loss of confidence requires substantial evidence, two notices, and a meaningful chance to answer charges. The Ample Opportunity Rule gives employers flexibility in disciplinary proceedings, but it does not excuse weak evidence, missing notices, or arbitrary dismissals. For Philippine labor law, the lesson is practical: an employee need not always receive a […]

Airport Properties Used for Public Service Are Exempt from Local Real Property Tax

Airport lands and buildings used for public service are exempt from LGU real property tax, except portions leased to private taxable persons. Local governments cannot impose real property tax on airport lands and buildings that are owned by the Republic, held by a national government instrumentality, and devoted to public use. For taxpayers, local treasurers, […]

Prior Restraint by Permit Denial: LGU Closure of Media Businesses

LGUs may require permits, but cannot use zoning or licensing as a pretext to silence protected speech; mandamus and damages may follow. Prior restraint by permit denial is unconstitutional when a local government uses licensing, zoning, or business-permit requirements as a pretext to silence protected speech. For Philippine businesses, media operators, and politically exposed enterprises, […]