Corporate Books, GIS Filings, and Family Business Disputes: When Denying Inspection Can Become Criminal

A pending accounting case does not defeat stockholder inspection rights, and false GIS shareholding entries may support falsification and perjury charges. A corporation cannot defeat a stockholder’s right to inspect corporate records merely by pointing to a pending accounting dispute. For family corporations, closely held companies, and businesses with contested control, the ruling draws a […]

Homeowners’ Association Disputes Belong Before the Housing Regulator, Not the Regular Courts

Homeowners’ association disputes over construction rules and penalties belong before the housing regulator when they involve member by-laws, not the RTC. Homeowners who challenge subdivision association penalties, construction rules, or board enforcement actions cannot avoid the housing regulator simply by styling their lawsuit as one for declaration of nullity or damages. When the real dispute […]

Labor Awards Cannot Reach Sister-Company Property Without Proof of Alter Ego Abuse

Unpaid employees could not levy on affiliated corporations’ property without proof of debtor ownership, alter ego abuse, fraud, or real-party standing. Employees who win final labor awards do not automatically gain access to the assets of a parent company, sister company, subsidiary, creditor, or later buyer. Even where unpaid workers face a large judgment and […]

Free Patent Reconveyance Deadline: When Land Claims Come Too Late

Free patent titles become indefeasible, and reconveyance claims may prescribe if land claimants delay despite tax declarations. The free patent reconveyance deadline doctrine warns land claimants that a Torrens title issued from a free patent cannot be attacked indefinitely. Once the title becomes indefeasible, a private claimant who wants reconveyance must act within the proper […]

Judicial Just Compensation Rule: Fair Value in Agrarian Takings

Agrarian landowners must receive real just compensation; missing claim folders cannot defeat payment after land is taken and patents issued. Landowners whose property has already been taken for agrarian reform cannot be defeated by missing agency paperwork or a nominal valuation that does not reflect the real value of the land. The Judicial Just Compensation […]

When a Judge Loses Temper in Court: The Courtroom Decorum Rule Every Litigant Should Know

Judges may control proceedings, but not through threats, vulgar language, or intimidation. The Court fined a Cebu RTC judge for bringing a gun into open court. Litigants and lawyers have a right to insist that courtroom authority be exercised through lawful orders, contempt powers, and judicial restraint—not anger, intimidation, vulgar language, or the display of […]

Donation Acceptance Rule: Invalid Waivers in Property Disputes

Donations of land are void without valid acceptance and notice; defective waivers, tax declarations, and CLOA titles may fail in court. The Donation Acceptance Rule protects heirs and landowners from losing real property through informal waivers, quitclaims, or affidavits that do not comply with the Civil Code’s strict requirements for donations of immovable property. In […]

Tax Exemption Finality Rule: Real Property Tax Liability in PH

Tax exemptions are strictly construed; unappealed real property tax assessments become final and collectible despite later exemption arguments. The Tax Exemption Finality Rule gives local governments a powerful collection tool: a taxpayer cannot avoid real property tax by relying on an unclear exemption or by attacking an assessment only after the administrative appeal period has […]

Imprescriptibility of Actions for Null Contracts: Supreme Court Upholds Heirs’ Land Claims

The Supreme Court ruled that actions to annul forged or nullified property contracts are imprescriptible, enabling heirs to reclaim land despite elapsed time. In the Philippines, heirs can now assert claims to nullified or forged property transactions without fear of prescription or laches blocking their case. The Supreme Court clarified that actions to declare a […]