OFW OEC Restraint Rule: SSS Coverage Stays, Travel Bar Falls

Land-based OFWs cannot be denied OECs for unpaid SSS contributions; compulsory SSS coverage stays valid, but travel restraints need clear statutory authority. The OFW OEC Restraint Rule means that mandatory SSS coverage for land-based overseas Filipino workers may be valid, but the government cannot make payment of SSS contributions a condition for releasing an Overseas […]

Boundary Dispute First Rule: When Cities Must Go to Sanggunian

LGU boundary disputes must first go to the Sanggunians; courts will dismiss premature constitutional suits when LGC remedies apply. Local governments cannot rush a territorial conflict straight to court by framing it as a constitutional challenge when the real issue is who controls the disputed land. Under the Boundary Dispute First Rule, competing claims between […]

Hierarchy of Courts Rule: Why Direct SC Petitions Can Fail

Direct SC petitions against government contracts need special reasons; fact-heavy PPP challenges belong in the proper lower forum. The hierarchy of courts rule remains a serious litigation barrier even in constitutional cases: parties challenging government infrastructure contracts must show special and important reasons before going directly to the Supreme Court, especially when the dispute requires […]

Renewable Energy Police Power: Why FIT Charges Were Upheld

FIT charges for renewable energy are valid police-power measures when tied to public welfare, lawful delegation, and sufficient due process safeguards in 2024. The Renewable Energy Police Power Doctrine confirms that electricity consumers may be required to share in renewable energy transition costs when the charge is regulatory, authorized by law, and supported by due […]

Zero-Rated Sales Proof: Why VAT Refunds Fail in PH

VAT refunds require proof of actual zero-rated sales; renewable energy registration alone cannot justify input VAT recovery without evidence. Input VAT refunds for renewable energy developers still depend on proof of actual zero-rated sales, even when the taxpayer is properly registered and legally eligible for VAT zero-rating. The Zero-Rated Sales Proof Rule means that a […]

Party-List Groups Can Lose Registration for Defying Seat Allocations

COMELEC may cancel party-list registration for defying final seat allocations; HRET jurisdiction over nominees does not bar registration review. Party-list registration is not a permanent political franchise: a party-list organization may be cancelled by the COMELEC when it knowingly disregards election-law limits on the seats it may occupy, even if one of its nominees is […]

Paid Expropriation Rule: When Old State Payment Defeats Land Title

Paid expropriation transfers ownership to the State; later reconstituted titles may fall unless a buyer proves innocent purchaser status. The paid expropriation rule protects the State’s ownership of land once just compensation has been paid, even if decades later a private party relies on a reconstituted Torrens title. For property buyers, developers, and landowners, the […]

Corporate Officers Are Not Personally Liable for Business Losses Without Clear Proof of Bad Faith or Gross Negligence

Corporate officers are not personally liable for business losses absent clear proof of bad faith, gross negligence, fraud, or action beyond authority. Corporate officers do not become personal guarantors of every failed business decision, cost overrun, or operational loss. A company that sues its former officer for damages must prove more than poor results, excessive […]

GOCC Employees Cannot Keep Unauthorized Allowances Just Because They Became Company Practice

GOCC employees may file benefit claims before Labor Arbiters, but unauthorized allowances cannot become protected benefits through company practice. Employees of government-owned or controlled corporations without original charters may bring wage and benefit claims before the Labor Arbiter, but they cannot invoke the Labor Code’s non-diminution rule to preserve allowances that violate government compensation, audit, […]

GOCC Employees Cannot Keep Benefits Granted Contrary to Audit Rules

GOCC employees may file money claims before the Labor Arbiter, but benefits granted contrary to COA rules do not become vested rights. Employees of a government-owned or controlled corporation without an original charter may bring unpaid benefit claims before the Labor Arbiter, but they cannot use the Labor Code’s non-diminution rule to preserve a benefit […]