Government Pocket Rule: Why LGUs Cannot Tax NFA Property

LGUs cannot impose real property tax on NFA property because NFA is a government instrumentality exempt under the Local Government Code. The Government Pocket Rule protects national government instrumentalities from local real property tax when the property is owned by the Republic and used for public functions. For local governments, government agencies, and property owners […]

Carry-Over Irrevocability Rule: Why Tax Refund Choices Matter

Carry-over of excess CWT bars later refund claims once elected, even if unused, making consistent corporate tax filings essential. Corporate taxpayers that carry over excess creditable withholding tax can lose the right to a refund even if the carry-over was later described as a mistake and even if the tax credit was never actually used. […]

Seafarer Death Benefits Rule: Who Gets Paid After Bigamy

POEA seafarer death benefits go to the legal spouse and children, not a void bigamous spouse, with shares fixed by succession law in the Philippines. Seafarer death benefits are not automatically estate property, and a named or practical spouse in a void bigamous marriage may still lose the money to the legal spouse and children. […]

Void Local Tax Assessment: When LGUs Must Refund Paid Taxes

Void LGU tax assessments lacking factual and legal basis cannot bar refund claims; taxpayers may recover erroneously collected local taxes. Void local tax assessment doctrine protects taxpayers from paying deficiency taxes based on unexplained demands, vague inspection findings, or figures that the local government unit cannot legally and factually justify. For businesses, this means a […]

Inverse Condemnation Deposit Rule: Why Zonal Value Controls

Landowners in inverse condemnation may demand provisional pay based on current BIR zonal value for national infrastructure takings in the Philippines. Landowners whose property was already taken for a national infrastructure project may still demand provisional compensation based on current BIR zonal value when they file inverse condemnation after the Right-of-Way Act took effect. The […]

Short Period Return Rule: Tax Refunds After Dissolution

Dissolving taxpayers need not file a short period return unless dissolution shortened the taxable year; excess CWT refunds may still proceed. Dissolving companies and partnerships do not automatically lose their tax refund claims merely because they did not file a short period return after ceasing business. The Short Period Return Rule clarified in Mindanao II […]

RA 11573 Remand Rule: Land Title Proof After the New Titling Law

Land title applicants need 20-year possession and proper DENR proof under RA 11573; weak evidence can lead to remand instead of a confirmed property title. The RA 11573 Remand Rule gives land registration applicants a second chance when the law changes while their case is still pendingβ€”but it also warns property claimants that tax declarations […]

When Court Evidence Disappears, Gross Neglect Can End a Judiciary Career

Court personnel may be dismissed for gross neglect when cash evidence is stored improperly and disappears, reinforcing strict evidence-custody duties. Litigants who turn over money, documents, or other exhibits to a court are entitled to expect that the evidence will be safeguarded with the same seriousness as the case itself. When a court employee ignores […]

Registered Owner Notice Rule: Void Tax Sales in the Philippines

Real property tax sales are void when levy notices are not served on the registered owner named in the Torrens title. The Registered Owner Notice Rule protects landowners from losing titled property in a real property tax sale without actual notice to the owner appearing on the transfer certificate of title. A city treasurer cannot […]

Tax Assessment Prescription: When BIR’s 10-Year Window Fails

VAT assessments generally prescribe in three years; without proven falsity, fraud, or a valid 30% underdeclaration, BIR’s 10-year period will not apply. Tax assessment prescription protects taxpayers from stale BIR assessments: the government cannot automatically use the extraordinary 10-year period merely because a return contains an error. Under the Tax Assessment Prescription Rule clarified in […]