Representative Office Tax Rule: When Foreign Offices Avoid VAT

Representative offices that earn no Philippine income are not subject to income tax or VAT; subsidies from a foreign head office are not taxable gain. The Representative Office Tax Rule protects a foreign company’s Philippine liaison office from income tax and VAT when it merely promotes, coordinates, or provides information for its head office without […]

Written-Stipulation Sale Expenses Rule: SC on Property Taxes

Sellers bear sale execution and registration costs unless the deed clearly shifts them; good-faith officials may avoid refund liability. The Written-Stipulation Sale Expenses Rule protects buyers, sellers, and government entities from after-the-fact claims that a property buyer agreed to pay taxes and transfer costs. If the deed of sale does not expressly shift those expenses […]

When Government Buyers Pay the Seller’s Taxes, COA Can Disallow the Deal

COA may disallow LGU payment of a seller’s taxes and legal fees when the deed is silent, but officials may avoid refund liability absent bad faith. Government buyers cannot casually agree to shoulder a seller’s transfer taxes, registration expenses, or private legal fees unless the obligation is clearly written into the sale contract and allowed […]

Administrative Franchise Tax Rule: CATV Permits Are Taxable

Administrative franchises, including CATV permits, may trigger local franchise tax if they grant public-use operating privileges. The Administrative Franchise Tax Rule means that a business may be liable for local franchise tax even without a congressional franchise, if its authority to operate is an administrative franchise charged with public use. For cable television operators and […]

When a Bank Accepts Late Loan Payments, It May Lose the Right to Foreclose Immediately

Late payment acceptance can bar immediate foreclosure by estoppel, while preserving the lender’s debt remedies and respecting separate corporate personality. A creditor that continues to accept delayed amortization payments, sends updated installment reminders, and allows the borrower to believe the loan has been regularized may be barred from immediately foreclosing the mortgage—even if the right […]

When a Lawyer Takes Client Money and Claims Court Connections, Disbarment Can Follow

A lawyer was disbarred for failing to account for client funds, claiming influence in cases, conflict of interest, and soliciting a client’s customers. Clients who entrust money, confidential information, and pending cases to a lawyer are entitled to more than legal skill; they are entitled to loyalty, accounting, and honesty. The ruling establishes a clear […]

When a Corporation Can Reduce Capital Stock Without Unanimous Stockholder Consent

The Supreme Court upheld Sinophil’s capital reduction, ruling that Section 38 compliance, not unanimous stockholder consent, controls SEC approval. Minority stockholders cannot block a corporation’s reduction of authorized capital stock merely because they disagree with the business decision, so long as the corporation complies with the statutory requirements, secures the required two-thirds stockholder vote, protects […]

When Corporate Control Is Disputed, Courts Cannot Use Injunctions to Decide the Boardroom War Early

A disputed corporate election cannot justify injunction without a clear legal right, especially where estate shares, voting authority, and quorum remain unresolved. A faction claiming control of a corporation cannot obtain a preliminary injunction merely by presenting a disputed election as presumptively valid. When the right to manage the company depends on contested voting rights, […]

Manning Agency Officers Can Be Personally Liable for Seafarer Disability Claims

Seafarers may recover permanent disability benefits from a manning agency and responsible officers when overseas employment laws impose solidary liability. Seafarers who become permanently unable to return to vessel work may recover full disability benefits not only from the local recruitment or manning entity, but also from responsible corporate officers when the claim arises from […]

Freeport Lands, Reversion Suits, and Who May Recover Public Property

AFAB could not sue alone to recover alleged Freeport public land; reversion must be filed by the Republic through the OSG. Government agencies that administer public lands cannot always sue in their own name to recover those lands from private title holders. When the case is really about returning land of the public domain to […]