COA may disallow LGU payment of a seller’s taxes and legal fees when the deed is silent, but officials may avoid refund liability absent bad faith.

Government buyers cannot casually agree to shoulder a seller’s transfer taxes, registration expenses, or private legal fees unless the obligation is clearly written into the sale contract and allowed by law. For taxpayers, contractors, landowners, and local officials dealing with government property transactions, the ruling is a warning: a favorable commercial bargain may still fail audit scrutiny if the final contract and tax rules do not support the payment.

The Practical Rule: Put the Tax Burden in the Contract, or the Seller Pays

The central doctrine of Domato-Togonon is straightforward but important: under Article 1487 of the Civil Code, the expenses for the execution and registration of a sale are borne by the seller unless the parties stipulate otherwise. A prior offer, negotiation letter, or local council resolution may explain the commercial background, but it will not override the final deed of sale when that deed is clear and complete.

This matters in real estate sales to government agencies and local government units. Sellers often negotiate a net price, meaning that the buyer is expected to absorb capital gains tax, documentary stamp tax, transfer tax, registration fees, and other transaction costs. Private parties may structure a deal that way, subject to tax law. But when the buyer is a local government unit, the transaction is also governed by public audit rules, statutory limits on taxation, and constitutional accountability for public funds.

Background: The City Hall Site Purchase

The dispute arose from Koronadal City’s purchase of land intended for public use, including a new city hall site and other government facilities. The landowners initially offered the property for P30 million, inclusive of costs. They later reduced the price to P22 million net, on the condition that the city would shoulder transfer-related expenses such as documentation costs, capital gains tax, estate tax, transfer tax, and documentary stamp tax.

The Sangguniang Panlungsod passed a resolution authorizing the mayor to enter into a deed of sale and stating that the city would bear the transfer expenses. However, the Deed of Absolute Sale itself stated only the P22 million consideration and did not stipulate that Koronadal City would shoulder the seller’s taxes and transfer costs. The city nevertheless paid P2,398,403.02 in taxes, fees, registration costs, and notarial fees. COA later disallowed the amount, and the matter reached the Supreme Court in Domato-Togonon v. Commission on Audit (G.R. No. 224516).

Why the Supreme Court Upheld the Disallowance

The Supreme Court sustained COA’s finding that the expenses were properly disallowed. The Court emphasized that the final deed of sale controlled. Since the deed did not contain any stipulation shifting execution and registration expenses to the buyer, the default Civil Code rule applied: the seller bears those expenses.

The Court also rejected the argument that earlier documents could be used to change the terms of the deed. Under the parol evidence rule, when an agreement has been reduced to writing, the writing is treated as the repository of the parties’ agreement. The Court found no ambiguity, mistake, or obscurity in the deed that would justify resort to prior letters or surrounding circumstances. The earlier offer and the local council resolution could not supply a missing contractual term.

The tax aspect made the ruling more consequential. The Court agreed that a local legislative body cannot effectively impose taxes, fees, or charges on the local government unit itself, nor can it legislate the shifting of national tax burdens for the benefit of particular private individuals. The Court noted that capital gains tax is the seller’s liability, while estate tax is primarily chargeable to the estate through the executor or administrator and subsidiarily to heirs or beneficiaries. Transfer taxes on real property are likewise for the seller or transferor’s account under the Local Government Code.

Documentary Stamp Tax, Capital Gains Tax, and Estate Tax in Government Sales

For tax practitioners, the ruling is useful because it distinguishes the legal incidence of several taxes commonly encountered in real estate transfers. Capital gains tax on the sale of real property is a tax on the presumed gain of the seller. It is not the buyer’s tax merely because the buyer benefits from registration of the deed. Estate tax, where applicable, is connected to the settlement and transfer of a decedent’s estate, not to the purchasing local government unit. Transfer tax is likewise statutorily assigned to the seller, donor, transferor, executor, or administrator.

Documentary stamp tax has a more flexible character because, as between non-exempt parties, the parties may agree on who will bear its economic cost. But that agreement still has to be properly reflected in the operative contract and must not conflict with special rules applicable to government entities. In public transactions, a tax allocation clause is not merely a pricing detail; it can determine whether the payment survives COA audit.

Private Lawyer and Notarial Fees Are Also Audit-Sensitive

The Supreme Court also addressed the payment of P419,000.00 in notarial fees to a private lawyer. COA relied on its circulars restricting the use of public funds for private legal services when government legal officers are available, except under recognized exceptional circumstances. The Court found that the prohibition covers legal services broadly and is not limited to courtroom representation. Since the record did not show compliance with the requirements for engaging the private lawyer, the disallowance also stood as to the notarial fees.

Why the Public Official Was Excused from Returning the Money

Although the disallowance was upheld, the Supreme Court partly granted the petition by excusing Marites Domato-Togonon from personally returning the P2,398,403.02. Applying the public officer liability framework developed in COA disallowance cases, the Court held that approving or authorizing officers are not automatically civilly liable for every disallowed expenditure. Bad faith, malice, or gross negligence must be clearly shown.

The Court found no such showing against the petitioner. Her position was that the city received a benefit because the sellers reduced the price from P30 million to P22 million, and the property had been assessed as advantageous to the city. The Court also considered that the disallowed amount consisted largely of taxes paid to the government and fees paid for services rendered. Requiring her to return the entire amount would have effectively allowed the government to benefit twice from the transaction.

What This Means for Landowners, Contractors, and LGUs

The ruling gives three practical lessons. First, when a government buyer is expected to absorb taxes or transfer costs, that obligation must be expressly stated in the final contract. Reliance on offer letters, negotiation history, or resolutions is risky if the deed itself is silent. Second, even a clearly drafted tax-shifting clause may still face audit issues if the payment contradicts statutes assigning tax liability or public finance rules. Third, public officials involved in disallowed transactions are not automatically required to refund the amount, but they must be prepared to show good faith, diligence, and absence of bad faith or gross negligence.

For sellers dealing with government buyers, the safer approach is to price the transaction transparently and ensure that all tax assumptions are reflected in the deed and reviewed before execution. For LGUs and public agencies, the ruling underscores the need for legal, tax, and audit review before signing property acquisition documents. For private parties, it is a reminder that a net-of-tax commercial offer may not translate cleanly into a government procurement or acquisition structure.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients in tax-sensitive real estate transactions, government contracts, COA disallowance disputes, and litigation involving public funds and property acquisitions. If you are selling property to a government entity, responding to a COA notice of disallowance, or structuring a transaction where taxes and transfer costs are being shifted between parties, our litigation and tax team can review the documents, identify audit risks, and prepare a legally defensible strategy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our lawyers in Makati City.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *