Tax Compromise Finality: When BIR Settlement Ends a Tax Case

BIR compromise settlements, once validly approved and paid, can close tax cases despite missed CTA deadlines and later government objections. Tax compromise finality protects taxpayers who settle disputed assessments in good faith: once the Commissioner of Internal Revenue validly approves a compromise and the taxpayer pays the required amount, the tax case may be closed […]

Club Dues Tax Rule: When Membership Fees Are Not Income or VAT

Membership dues and assessments used for club upkeep are capital, not taxable income or VATable receipts, under Philippine tax law. Recreational clubs, golf clubs, and similar nonprofit membership organizations do not automatically owe income tax or VAT on membership dues, assessment fees, and similar collections used for upkeep. The Club Dues Tax Rule protects the […]

RPT Accrual Ownership Rule: When Tax Sales Become Unlawful

Real property tax follows the owner or beneficial user when tax accrues; later buyers cannot be charged old delinquencies or unlawful tax sales. The RPT Accrual Ownership Rule protects buyers from being forced to pay real property taxes that accrued before they owned, possessed, or beneficially used the property. For purchasers of foreclosed assets, ecozone […]

VAT Refund Reckoning Rule: When CTA Appeals Are Timely

VAT refund appeals are timely when filed within 30 days after the BIR’s 120-day period from complete document submission expires. Taxpayers claiming VAT refunds cannot be defeated by a rigid filing-date theory when the BIR itself continued asking for, receiving, and processing additional documents before the current completeness rule took effect. The VAT Refund Reckoning […]

Corporate Officers Can Face Criminal Trial for Blocking Stockholder Access to Company Records

Corporate officers may face trial for refusing stockholder access to records when the information sufficiently alleges unjustified refusal to inspect books. Corporate officers who refuse a stockholder’s lawful request to inspect company books cannot defeat a criminal case merely by arguing that the information did not recite every evidentiary detail. When an indictment alleges that […]

Project Office Tax Situs: When LGUs Can Share Business Taxes

LGUs may share local business tax only if the office is operational, not merely administrative, under Philippine tax situs rules. Local governments cannot claim a share of a company’s local business tax merely because the company maintains an office in their city. Under the project office tax situs doctrine, an office must be directly involved […]

When a Distributor Uses a New Corporation to Escape Contract Obligations, Its President May Be Personally Liable

Corporate officers may be personally liable when they misuse corporations in bad faith to evade distributorship obligations and unpaid contract debts. A corporate officer who uses one corporation to mislead a contracting party, shift obligations to another entity, and avoid payment may lose the protection of separate corporate personality. For businesses, the ruling is a […]

Timely Just Compensation: SC Protects Owners in Expropriation

Government taking of private land requires timely just compensation; courts must determine area, taking date, value, and interest owed to owners. Timely just compensation is not optional: when the government takes private land for a public project, the owner must be paid the fair value of the property within a reasonable time, and delay can […]