Substantial Justice in Tax Appeals: Technical Defects Should Not End Cases

Tax appeals should not be dismissed for curable defects when substantial justice requires a merits ruling in a major BIR assessment case. Substantial justice in tax appeals means that a multimillion-peso tax case should not be thrown out merely because a petition contains curable formal defects, especially where both sides have attempted to correct the […]

Boundary Tax Escrow Doctrine: Paying RPT During LGU Disputes

Property owners in LGU boundary disputes must keep paying RPT, but taxes may be placed in escrow until territorial jurisdiction is finally resolved. The Boundary Tax Escrow Doctrine protects property owners caught between rival local governments: real property taxes must still be paid, but when territorial jurisdiction is genuinely disputed, the taxpayer should not be […]

Gross Philippine Billings Rule: Shipping Tax Exposure in PH

Demurrage and detention fees of international sea carriers fall outside Gross Philippine Billings and may face regular income tax. The Gross Philippine Billings Exclusion Rule means that international sea carriers cannot automatically treat every charge connected with shipping as part of the 2.5% preferential tax base. Demurrage and detention fees, even when imposed in the […]

Condo Dues Are Not Taxable Income: What the First E-Bank Ruling Means for Condominium Corporations

Condominium association dues used for maintenance are not taxable income, VATable receipts, or withholding-taxable payments under the First E-Bank ruling. Condominium corporations cannot be taxed as if every peso of association dues, membership fees, and maintenance assessments were income from business. The Supreme Court confirmed a practical rule with major consequences for unit owners and […]

Stopped Bank Drafts Do Not Defeat a Holder in Due Course

A holder in due course may collect on stopped bank drafts; the bank-drawer remains liable despite a separate indemnity deal with its customer. A party who receives a negotiable bank draft in good faith and for value is not left empty-handed merely because payment is later stopped. When a bank draft is dishonored after a […]

When a Corporate Election Dispute Must Be Filed Within 15 Days

Corporate election challenges involving proxies, quorum, or board authority must be filed within 15 days, or courts may bar evidence on election validity. Corporate members who want to challenge the authority of elected directors cannot wait until a later disciplinary or governance dispute arises before attacking the election. If the complaint questions the validation of […]

Tax Refund Two-Year Rule: When Invalid BIR Taxes Can Still Prescribe

Tax refunds for invalid BIR collections must still be filed within two years, or prescribed amounts and unsupported claims may be denied. The Tax Refund Two-Year Rule means that even when the BIR collected tax under an invalid regulation, a taxpayer can still lose part of the refund by filing too late or failing to […]

Majority Stockholders Cannot Use Derivative Suits to Bypass the Board

Majority stockholders cannot use derivative suits to bypass board authority when a corporation can sue in its own name over corporate property. Majority stockholders who control a corporation cannot sue in a derivative capacity merely because a corporate asset was allegedly misused. If the corporation can act through its board, the proper plaintiff is the […]

Operative Fact Tax Reliance: When Invalid Tax Laws Still Matter

Invalid tax laws may still affect past conduct: good-faith taxpayers can avoid double payment, while agencies may retain prior tax effects. Operative fact tax reliance means that even an unconstitutional tax-related law may still produce consequences for transactions completed before it was struck down. For taxpayers, local governments, and businesses caught between competing authorities, the […]

Gun Licenses Are a Privilege, But Your Home Still Needs a Warrant

Gun ownership is only a statutory privilege, but firearm licensing cannot justify warrantless PNP inspections of private homes. Firearm owners in the Philippines cannot claim a constitutional right to own or carry guns, but the government also cannot turn gun licensing into an open-ended license to enter and inspect a private home. The controlling doctrine […]