MWSS Tax Exemption Rule: When LGUs Cannot Levy Property Taxes

Government instrumentalities with corporate powers are exempt from local real property tax unless private beneficial use is shown. The MWSS Tax Exemption Rule protects government instrumentalities with corporate powers from local real property tax, unless the local government can show that beneficial use of the property was granted to a taxable private person. For property […]

When Utilities Cut Water Without Notice, Homeowners Can Recover Damages

Utilities and contractors may be liable for damages when they cut or transfer water lines without notice, even during authorized rehabilitation works. Homeowners and associations are not helpless when a utility provider or contractor interrupts essential services without warning. Even when a company has authority to improve, rehabilitate, or maintain a water system, that authority […]

Local Tax Ordinance Appeals: When City Tax Hikes Exceed LGC Limits

Cities cannot impose accumulated local tax hikes beyond LGC limits; taxpayers must challenge illegal ordinances through the proper appeal route. Local governments cannot wait years, accumulate unused taxing power, and then impose a one-time business tax increase beyond the Local Government Code’s 10 percent adjustment ceiling. For retailers and other businesses facing new city revenue […]

When a Stock Trading Dispute Belongs in Regular Court, Not a Special Commercial Court

The Supreme Court held that an investor’s unauthorized-trading claim against a broker is an ordinary civil action, not automatically an intra-corporate case. Investors who sue a securities broker for unauthorized trades, missing funds, or the return of shares are not automatically dragged into special commercial court procedure simply because the dispute involves stocks. If the […]

A Bad Investment Is Not Automatically Estafa: When Share Payments Stay Civil, Not Criminal

A failed share investment is not automatically estafa; prosecutors must prove fiduciary receipt and actual conversion before corporate officers may be convicted. Business losses, failed investments, and unpaid demands do not automatically become criminal estafa. When money is paid for shares of stock, prosecutors must still prove a fiduciary receipt of the money and a […]

Tax Due Process Rule: When BIR Assessments Become Void

BIR tax assessments are void when the agency ignores taxpayer evidence and fails to state the factual and legal basis for its demand. Taxpayers facing deficiency assessments are not merely entitled to receive notices; they are entitled to a real explanation of why the Bureau of Internal Revenue rejected their defenses. Under the Tax Due […]

Quieting Title Best Evidence Rule: Why Original Deeds Matter

Quieting title requires proof of ownership and original evidence; photocopies cannot defeat a proven deed and better property claim. The Quieting Title Best Evidence Rule is a practical warning for property owners: a Torrens title, photocopied documents, and late-discovered papers will not automatically defeat a buyer who can prove a valid sale, possession of original […]

RPT Owner Liability Rule: When Property Owners Must Pay Local Taxes

Registered taxable property owners remain liable for RPT, and RTC local tax rulings must be appealed to the CTA before Supreme Court review. The RPT Owner Liability Rule makes one point clear for property owners: a registered owner that is not tax-exempt cannot avoid real property tax merely by saying that someone else possessed the […]

Free Patent Right-of-Way: When Road Projects Still Require Payment

Free patent land may carry a government road easement, but owners may recover just compensation if the remaining property is materially impaired. The Free Patent Right-of-Way Rule means that land originally acquired through a free patent may carry a built-in government easement for roads and public works, even after the land is later sold to […]

Input VAT Cost Exclusion: SC Limits Construction Cost Claims

Input VAT credited against output VAT cannot inflate construction cost or reduce a joint venture partner’s share in reserved real estate units. The Input VAT Cost Exclusion doctrine matters to developers, landowners, joint venture partners, and businesses in construction disputes because a VAT-registered party cannot inflate a shared project cost by charging input VAT that […]