Tolerance by Positive Acts: When Ejectment Claims Fail

Unlawful detainer based on tolerance fails unless the owner proves positive acts of permission; silence or delay is not enough. Tolerance by positive acts is now a critical rule for property owners filing unlawful detainer cases in the Philippines: a plaintiff cannot rely on silence, delay, or inaction to prove that another person’s possession was […]

Real Action by Ultimate Relief: Property Jurisdiction in the Philippines

Property suits framed as specific performance may still be real actions; without assessed value and proper docket fees, RTC proceedings are void. The real action by ultimate relief doctrine warns property claimants that a complaint cannot avoid jurisdictional rules merely by calling itself specific performance. If the practical objective is to recover land, obtain title, […]

Withholding Tax Prescription Rule: Tax Assessments Can Expire

Withholding tax assessments are internal revenue taxes subject to the three-year prescription period; invalid waivers cannot extend BIR assessment time. The Withholding Tax Prescription Rule protects businesses from stale tax assessments: expanded withholding tax and withholding tax on compensation assessments are internal revenue tax assessments covered by the three-year prescriptive period under Philippine tax law. […]

When a Corporate President’s Signature Can Bind the Company: Apparent Authority, Bank Loans, and Compromise Judgments

A corporation may be bound by its president’s settlement when its conduct created apparent authority and it delayed objecting for years. A company may still be bound by a president’s loan-related settlement even without a produced board resolution if the corporation previously held that officer out as authorized, accepted the benefits of the transaction, and […]

No-Interest Levy Rule: Why Prior Buyers Beat Execution Sales

A prior buyer who received delivery before levy has the better right to possess property; execution buyers acquire only the debtor’s remaining interest. The No-Interest Levy Rule protects a prior buyer who already acquired ownership and possession of land before a creditor levied on the seller’s title. In practical terms, a judgment creditor who buys […]

PEZA Incentive Scope Rule: When Ecozone Income Becomes Taxable

PEZA tax holidays cover only registered activities; income from unregistered facility leasing remains taxable and not refundable. The PEZA Incentive Scope Rule means that a tax holiday does not automatically shield every peso earned by a PEZA-registered enterprise. Only income arising from the enterprise’s registered activity, or from an activity clearly embraced within that registration, […]

Private Land Free Patent Rule: When Torrens Titles Can Be Cancelled

A void free patent over private land cannot defeat decades of possession; reconveyance may cancel Torrens titles issued in bad faith. The Private Land Free Patent Rule protects long-time possessors from losing land merely because another person later obtained a free patent and Torrens title over property that had already become private by operation of […]

Bel-Air Lot Owners Cannot Escape Title-Annotated Village Restrictions by Resigning from the Association

Annotated subdivision restrictions bind buyers and may be extended by valid association vote; resignation does not defeat title-based HOA obligations. Property buyers who acquire land with annotated subdivision restrictions on the title take the property with those burdens, including automatic homeowners’ association membership, assessment obligations, and community rules validly extended under the governing deed. For […]

Stock Transfer Disposition Rule: Tax on Share Loans in PH

Share transfers outside the stock exchange may trigger capital gains tax and DST even when labeled as stock loans or trust arrangements. The stock transfer disposition rule means that a taxpayer cannot avoid capital gains tax and documentary stamp tax merely by calling a transfer of shares a loan, trust arrangement, or informal accommodation. When […]

MWSS Tax Exemption Rule: When LGUs Cannot Levy Property Taxes

Government instrumentalities with corporate powers are exempt from local real property tax unless private beneficial use is shown. The MWSS Tax Exemption Rule protects government instrumentalities with corporate powers from local real property tax, unless the local government can show that beneficial use of the property was granted to a taxable private person. For property […]