A Missed Hearing Can Cost You the Case: When Courts May Treat Silence as Waiver

A missed hearing may waive cross-examination and evidence rights. Dy Teban clarifies due process, postponements, certiorari, and commercial court jurisdiction. A party who repeatedly delays trial cannot later claim denial of due process when the court proceeds without him. The decisive lesson of Dy Teban is practical and unforgiving: the right to cross-examine witnesses and […]

LOA Scope Rule: Void Tax Assessments Beyond Audit Authority

Tax assessments beyond the LOA period are void, and crop-method taxpayers may deduct production costs when crop income is realized under tax rules. The LOA Scope Rule protects taxpayers from tax assessments issued beyond the authority actually granted to BIR examiners. For businesses facing a deficiency tax assessment in the Philippines, the case teaches a […]

When “Sans Recourse” Investments Become Securities Fraud: What Investors Can Recover When Paper Promises Collapse

Investors may recover failed placements when “sans recourse” labels hide fraud, unregistered securities, bad-faith assignments, or negligent board action. Investors may recover not only from the investment house that sold them a supposedly “sans recourse” placement, but also from responsible officers, directors, and controlling personalities when the transaction was structured to hide risk, evade securities […]

Title Location Rule: Who Collects Local Taxes in Boundary Disputes

Torrens title location controls local tax situs until amended, letting taxpayers rely on title entries despite unresolved boundary disputes. The Title Location Rule protects taxpayers from being trapped between competing local governments: for local tax purposes, the location stated in a certificate of title controls until it is amended through the proper court proceeding. For […]

Corporate Officers Can Face Criminal Liability for Blocking a Member’s Right to Inspect Records

Corporate officers may face liability for refusing a member’s written demand to inspect records, even if the corporation’s registration was revoked. Corporate transparency is not optional: a member who makes a written demand to inspect association records may trigger personal criminal exposure for officers who refuse access without a lawful basis. For officers of corporations, […]

Initial Local Tax Implementation Rule: Limits on City Tax Hikes

Cities may correct old local tax codes, but retailer tax hikes must follow Local Government Code limits and cannot be oppressive. The Initial Local Tax Implementation Rule protects both sides of a local tax dispute: cities may correct outdated business tax ordinances to comply with the Local Government Code, but they cannot use that correction […]

Land Recovery Proof Rule: Why Tax Declarations Are Not Enough

Land claimants must prove the exact property and their own title; tax declarations alone cannot defeat a free patent or recover disputed land. The Land Recovery Proof Rule protects titled property owners and defendants in reconveyance cases from claims built on uncertain boundaries, inconsistent lot areas, and tax declarations standing alone. A claimant who asks […]

Stockholder Property Cannot Be Frozen for Corporate Rehabilitation Debts

Stockholder-owned land cannot be frozen as a corporate rehabilitation asset merely because officers own shares in the debtor corporation. Personal property owned by corporate stockholders cannot be treated as a corporate asset merely because the corporation is under rehabilitation, even where the stockholders are officers of the company and even where the corporation is alleged […]

Tax Abatement Termination Letter: When BIR Relief Becomes Final

BIR tax abatement is final only with a termination letter; payment forms alone do not close deficiency tax assessments. Taxpayers who apply for BIR tax abatement cannot treat an assessment as closed simply because they paid the basic tax or submitted abatement forms. Under the tax abatement termination letter doctrine, the assessment remains enforceable until […]

A Merger Does Not Erase Labor Liabilities: Surviving Corporations Can Inherit Employee Claims

A surviving corporation in a merger may inherit labor liabilities, including constructive dismissal awards, when the absorbed company was solidarily liable. Companies that absorb another corporation through merger inherit more than assets, contracts, and business opportunities; they may also inherit unresolved labor liabilities, including monetary awards for constructive dismissal. For employers planning acquisitions or corporate […]