LOA Due Process Rule: When BIR VAT Assessments Become Void

BIR tax exams need a valid Letter of Authority; without it, VAT assessments are void, and HMO medical-use funds may be excluded. The LOA Due Process Rule gives taxpayers a powerful defense against unauthorized BIR assessments: if a revenue officer examines a taxpayer without a valid Letter of Authority, the resulting assessment is void. In […]

Notarized Surety Agreements Are Hard to Escape: Why a Forgery Defense Needs More Than a Handwriting Report

A notarized surety agreement cannot be defeated by denial alone; forgery must be proven by clear, convincing evidence, not weak handwriting comparison. Business owners, corporate officers, and loan sureties cannot lightly escape a notarized surety agreement by merely denying their signature or presenting an inconclusive handwriting report. When a person signs as surety for a […]

Strict Waiver Rule: Defective BIR Waivers Void Tax Assessments

BIR assessments beyond three years are void when waivers are defective and RELIEF discrepancies fail to prove fraud or intentional falsity. Tax assessments issued after the ordinary three-year period can be void when the BIR relies on defective waivers, and alleged discrepancies from computerized matching do not automatically prove fraud. The Strict Waiver Rule protects […]

Fraudulent Free Patent Reversion: When Land Titles Can Still Fall

Fraudulent free patents can still be cancelled by the State; buyers lose good-faith protection when title defects require inquiry. The fraudulent free patent reversion doctrine warns land buyers that a Torrens title is not always the end of the story. When land originally came from a free patent obtained through fraud, the government may still […]

VAT Refund Proof Rule: When Zero-Rated Claims Fail in Court

VAT refund claims require strict proof of zero-rated sales and VAT invoices; early CTA filing survived only under the San Roque exception. The VAT Refund Proof Rule requires taxpayers to win on two fronts: timely access to the Court of Tax Appeals and strict documentary proof that every peso claimed qualifies for refund. For businesses […]

When a Buyer Blocks Closing, the Law May Treat the Condition as Fulfilled

Business advances and share-sale payments can become enforceable when a buyer blocks conditions; novation still needs creditor consent, with Nacar interest rules applied. A party that takes control of a business cannot avoid payment by delaying the very closing document that would trigger its obligation. The Supreme Court treated the prevented condition as fulfilled, made […]

Void Execution Sales Cannot Defeat the True Owner’s Right to Get the Property Back

The Supreme Court ruled that property sold through a void execution sale must be restored when actual restitution remains legally and physically possible. Property taken through a void execution sale must be returned to its true owner when actual restitution is still physically and legally possible. A judgment creditor who later sells the property to […]

Buyer at Peril Doctrine: Buying Unregistered Land in the Philippines

Buyers of unregistered land in the Philippines buy at their peril; a deed of sale cannot defeat proven possession and acquisitive prescription. The Buyer at Peril Doctrine warns every purchaser of unregistered land in the Philippines that a deed of sale is not enough. When the seller cannot prove ownership, and another family has long […]