Share Redemption Tax Rule: When Preferred Shares Are Not Dividends

Share redemption payments are not taxable dividends without earnings or profits; taxpayers may file CTA refund suits before BIR action to beat prescription. Share redemptions are not automatically taxable dividends merely because the shareholder receives more than par value. For corporations dealing with foreign parent companies, affiliates, or investors, the key tax lesson is clear: […]

When Corporate Names Are Too Similar: The SEC Can Force a Company to Rename Itself

The Supreme Court upheld the SEC’s power to force a company to change a confusingly similar corporate name, protecting prior registrants and the public. A business that registers a corporate name first can stop a later company from using a name that is identical, deceptively similar, or likely to confuse the publicβ€”even if the later […]

Sheriff Ministerial Duty Rule: Execution Sales Must Follow Court Orders

Sheriffs enforcing writs must strictly follow Rule 39; grave procedural lapses in an execution sale can warrant dismissal. The Sheriff Ministerial Duty Rule protects judgment debtors from execution sales carried out beyond the exact terms of a court order. For property owners, litigants, and judgment creditors, the lesson is direct: a sheriff enforcing a writ […]

Connections Fraud Rule: Fake BIR Contacts Can Mean Estafa

Estafa applies when fake BIR contacts induce tax payment; forged receipts may prove falsification through circumstantial evidence. Public officials and intermediaries who claim they can use government β€œconnections” to lower taxes or speed up title transfers may face serious criminal liability when money is taken and a fake receipt is issued. The Connections Fraud Rule […]

Shareholder Lawsuits Over Unfinished Corporate Projects Must Go to the Right Commercial Court

Shareholder derivative suits over corporate projects must be filed in special commercial courts and must strictly plead exhaustion and other requisites. A shareholder who sues on behalf of a corporation cannot avoid the special rules for derivative suits by labeling the case as one for specific performance. When the complaint seeks to enforce a corporate […]

Corporate Officers Cannot Split Company Control by Private Deal Without Board Authority

Private agreements cannot divide corporate control without board authority. Tom v. Rodriguez protects lawful governance and tax-sensitive corporate documentation. Corporate control cannot be transferred, divided, or informally reassigned by private agreement when the corporation itself has not acted through its board of directors or duly authorized agents. For business owners, investors, tax managers, and corporate […]

Strict DST Rule: When Interbank Call Loans Are Not Taxable

Interbank call loans are not subject to DST unless clearly taxed by law; later tax code amendments cannot retroactively burden taxpayers. Banks cannot be made to pay documentary stamp tax on interbank call loans unless the tax law clearly, expressly, and unambiguously includes those transactions among taxable instruments. The Strict DST Rule matters because it […]

Personal Action Damages Rule: Venue in Property Disputes

A damages claim over a house is a personal action when compensation, not possession or title, is the real remedy sought. Property owners and occupants may sue for damages where they reside when the real objective of the case is compensation for injury to property rights, not recovery of title or possession. The Personal Action […]

1945 Possession Rule: Why Land Title Claims Fail in Court

Land title applicants must prove possession since June 12, 1945; tax declarations and hearsay testimony cannot confirm imperfect title. The 1945 Possession Rule makes land registration harder than many property claimants expect: tax declarations, deeds of sale, and unopposed possession are not enough unless the applicant proves open, continuous, exclusive, and notorious possession of alienable […]