When Final Judgment Can Still Yield to Substantial Justice in Family Corporation Share Disputes

A withdrawn appeal over family corporation shares may be reinstated when failed reconciliation and serious ownership claims make strict finality unjust. A party who withdrew an appeal because he was led to expect family reconciliation may still be allowed to revive that appeal when the expected settlement never materializes and strict finality would produce a […]

Cooperative Property Tax Exemption: When LGUs Can Still Tax Machinery

Cooperative-owned land stays real property tax-exempt when leased, but business machinery used directly in operations remains taxable. The cooperative property tax exemption can protect land and permanent improvements even when the property is leased to a private business, but it does not automatically shield business machinery that is mobile, self-propelled, and indispensable to operations. For […]

Stockholders Can Inspect Corporate Records—Confidentiality Alone Is Not Enough to Stop Them

Corporations generally cannot stop stockholder inspection through pre-emptive injunction; confidentiality objections must be proven as defenses. Corporations cannot use a pre-emptive injunction to put stockholders on the defensive when they ask to inspect corporate records. The default rule is access: a stockholder who makes a written demand to examine corporate books, records of business transactions, […]

Corporate Mergers Do Not Automatically Trigger Separation Pay for Employees

A merger does not automatically dismiss employees or trigger separation pay when operations continue and contracts do not expressly provide merger benefits. Employees do not become automatically dismissed, and therefore do not automatically earn separation pay, merely because a corporate merger changes the legal structure above their employer. The controlling doctrine is simple but important […]

Mangrove Conversion Rule: When Fishpond Work Becomes a Crime

Mangrove work that alters protected forest can be criminal conversion; tax declarations, inherited use, and good faith do not bar conviction. The Mangrove Conversion Rule means that a person may face imprisonment and fines not only for creating a new fishpond, but also for continuing to alter, improve, excavate, or use a mangrove forest in […]

Election Residency Rule: Temporary Absence Does Not Void Candidacy

Election residency means domicile, so temporary absence does not void candidacy absent false material representation and intent to deceive voters. Election residency in the Philippines means domicile, not imprisonment in one place. Under the unbroken presence not required rule, a candidate who has established a true home in the locality does not automatically lose that […]

Invalid Levy Rule: Why Creditors Cannot Seize Another Person’s Land

Money judgments bind only the debtor’s property; invalid levies on third-party land can be cancelled despite sheriff’s sale documents. The invalid levy rule protects property owners from losing land to satisfy another person’s debt: a money judgment may be enforced only against property that unquestionably belongs to the judgment debtor. For landowners, judgment creditors, and […]

Nunc Pro Tunc Partition: Fixing Omitted Property in Final Judgments

Final partition judgments may be corrected nunc pro tunc when omitted property was actually adjudged, but repeat suits remain barred by res judicata. Nunc pro tunc partition matters because a family property dispute may survive even after a case is technically barred by res judicata, if the earlier court actually decided that property should be […]

PAGCOR Licensee Tax Exemption: Casino Gaming Income Needs Only 5%

PAGCOR licensees owe only 5% franchise tax on casino gaming income; BIR cannot impose corporate income tax by circular. PAGCOR contractees and licensees operating authorized casinos are not automatically liable for corporate income tax on gaming income merely because the BIR issued a circular saying so. Under the PAGCOR Licensee Tax Exemption doctrine, income derived […]

Bare Tolerance Rule: Why Ejectment Requires Proof of Permission

Unlawful detainer requires proof of actual tolerance; long possession and tax declarations can defeat summary ejectment in Philippine courts. The Bare Tolerance Rule protects occupants from being summarily ejected on nothing more than a landholder’s unsupported claim that they were merely allowed to stay. In Philippine unlawful detainer cases, a property claimant must prove not […]