When a Lawyerโ€™s Negligence Becomes Dishonesty: Client Desistance Will Not End Accountability

A lawyerโ€™s negligence and dishonest estate settlement representations justified a three-year suspension despite the clientโ€™s affidavit of desistance. Clients who withdraw a disbarment complaint or accept an apology do not automatically erase a lawyerโ€™s professional liability, especially when the record shows neglect, misrepresentation, or falsified documents. The Supreme Court made clear that a lawyerโ€™s duty […]

Judges Who Borrow Court Funds Can Be Dismissed Even After Paying Everything Back

A judge who borrowed from court collections was dismissed despite repayment, confirming that misuse of court funds is gross misconduct. Court funds are not a personal credit line, even for the judge who supervises the court. When a magistrate borrows from judiciary collections, later repayment does not erase the misconduct, because the offense lies not […]

Local Fiscal Autonomy Rule: When Congress Cannot Divert LGU Taxes

LGU tax proceeds must accrue to the LGU; Congress cannot divert locally imposed amusement taxes to FDCP or private film producers. Local taxes collected under the Local Government Code must accrue to the local government that levies them, and Congress cannot make an LGU impose a tax only to divert the proceeds to a national […]

Unobjected Income Testimony Can Support a Multimillion-Peso Damages Award After Wrongful Death

Unobjected salary testimony may support loss of earning capacity in a criminal case, allowing heirs to recover civil damages despite missing payroll records. A family seeking civil damages after a killing is not automatically defeated by the absence of payroll records, income tax returns, or receipts. Where testimony on the deceased personโ€™s salary is admitted […]

Procurement Funding Rule: Why Budget Must Come Before Bidding

Government projects need lawful funding before procurement starts; later appropriations may cure mootness but cannot erase irregular public bidding defects. Government procurement cannot be treated as a promise to find money later. Under the Procurement Funding Rule, agencies must have sufficient appropriation, and where required a Multi-Year Obligational Authority, before starting procurement for public projects. […]