When an Injunction Comes Too Late: Why Courts Cannot Undo a Completed Corporate Expulsion Through a Temporary Writ

A completed corporate expulsion cannot be undone by preliminary injunction, but threatened sanctions may still be restrained to preserve the status quo. Parties seeking emergency court protection must act before the threatened act is completed: a preliminary injunction preserves the last peaceable status quo, but it cannot undo a corporate expulsion, suspension, or other completed […]

Procurement Funding Rule: Why Budget Must Come Before Bidding

Government projects need lawful funding before procurement starts; later appropriations may cure mootness but cannot erase irregular public bidding defects. Government procurement cannot be treated as a promise to find money later. Under the Procurement Funding Rule, agencies must have sufficient appropriation, and where required a Multi-Year Obligational Authority, before starting procurement for public projects. […]

Pacto de Retro Sales: When Redemption Rights Expire in Property Disputes

Heirs cannot revive an expired pacto de retro redemption right without proof that the sale was really an equitable mortgage under Philippine law. Pacto de retro sellers and their heirs cannot revive an expired right to repurchase merely by calling the transaction an equitable mortgage years later. For families, land buyers, and businesses involved in […]

Oil Exploration in Protected Seascapes Needs More Than a Government Contract

Protected seascape oil exploration was void for lack of constitutional safeguards, prior environmental compliance, and specific legal authority for resource use. Businesses cannot rely on a government-issued service contract to explore or exploit energy resources inside a protected seascape when constitutional safeguards, environmental impact requirements, and protected-area laws have not been strictly followed. For communities, […]

Paying Back Public Money Later Does Not Cure Misuse: The No-Restitution Rule for Court Funds

A clerk of court was dismissed for delayed remittance and misuse of judiciary collections; repayment did not cure gross neglect, grave misconduct, or dishonesty. Public officers entrusted with government collections cannot avoid dismissal simply by returning the money later. When court funds are not deposited on time, and the delay shows misappropriation or personal use, […]

When a Lawyer Fails to Finish the Job and Keeps Client Funds, Discipline May Follow

A lawyer who neglects property work and fails to return client funds may be suspended and ordered to refund money received for the engagement. Clients who pay a lawyer for a specific legal task are entitled to more than silence, delay, and excuses. A lawyer who accepts money for titling, reconstitution, estate documents, taxes, or […]

Land Registration Proof Rule: Why Tax Declarations Are Not Enough

Applicants must prove DENR alienability and possession since 1945; tax declarations and CENRO certifications alone cannot secure title. The Land Registration Proof Rule places a heavy evidentiary burden on anyone seeking original title over land that may still belong to the public domain. A claimant cannot rely on family occupation, old tax declarations, or a […]

Stockholders Can Enforce Corporate Inspection Rights in the RTC Even When Sequestered Companies Are Involved

Stockholders may enforce inspection rights in the RTC when the dispute is intra-corporate, even if the company has sequestration history. Stockholders and corporate representatives do not lose the ordinary remedy of enforcing inspection rights merely because a corporation has a sequestration history or a factional board dispute. When the controversy is about corporate books, board […]

Lawyers Can Be Suspended for Bouncing Checks, Even in Private Transactions

A lawyer may be suspended for issuing worthless checks, even in a private transaction, because the act constitutes serious misconduct under legal ethics rules. A lawyer who issues worthless checks may be disciplined as a lawyer even when the transaction is private, unrelated to court work, and still the subject of separate criminal proceedings. For […]