Corporate Secretaries Can Be Suspended for Filing False SEC General Information Sheets

A lawyer-corporate secretary was suspended for certifying a false SEC GIS listing a non-stockholder as chairman and president of a corporation. Lawyers who serve as corporate secretaries cannot treat SEC filings as provisional paperwork or internal business favors. When a lawyer certifies a General Information Sheet as true, the lawyer personally assumes professional responsibility for […]

Tax Refund Evidence Rule: How Companies Prove Excess CWT Claims

Companies may recover excess CWT if timely filed and proven; BIR cannot defeat a refund claim without rebutting the taxpayer’s evidence. Corporate taxpayers claiming a refund of excess creditable withholding tax must prove three things clearly: timely filing, declaration of the related income, and actual withholding by the payor. The Tax Refund Evidence Rule matters […]

PAGCOR Franchise Tax Rule: When Gaming Income Avoids Double Tax

Gaming income under PAGCOR’s charter is subject only to 5% franchise tax; BIR cannot impose extra income tax by circular. The PAGCOR Franchise Tax Rule protects gaming income covered by a special legislative franchise from being taxed twice when the basic charter says that a five percent franchise tax is paid in lieu of all […]

False Return Tax Assessment Rule: When BIR Gets 10 Years to Assess

False withholding tax returns can give the BIR 10 years to assess, even without proving fraud, if substantial underdeclaration is shown. The false return tax assessment rule means a taxpayer may lose the ordinary three-year protection against BIR assessments when its return substantially understates taxes due, even if the taxpayer argues there was no intent […]

When a Status Quo Order Goes Too Far: Why Courts Cannot Use It to Undo Corporate Acts Without Bond and Verification

A status quo order cannot reinstate a removed corporate officer without proper injunctive safeguards, including verification, hearing, and bond. A status quo order in an intra-corporate dispute cannot be used as a shortcut to reinstate a removed officer, trustee, or administrator. If the order effectively commands the undoing of an already completed corporate act, it […]

Tax Waiver Prescription Rule: When BIR Collection Comes Too Late

A defective BIR waiver does not extend tax collection; stale deficiency tax claims prescribe when legal requirements are not strictly met. The Tax Waiver Prescription Rule protects taxpayers from stale deficiency tax collections when the Bureau of Internal Revenue relies on a defective waiver or waits too long to act. A taxpayer’s waiver of prescription […]

When Notarization Is a Sham: Why Lawyers Are Personally Responsible for Their Notarial Seal

A lawyer-notary was suspended after his secretary notarized 18 documents while he was abroad, reinforcing strict responsibility for notarial seals. A notarized deed is not automatically safe just because it bears a lawyer’s name, seal, and notarial details; if the notarization was performed by an unauthorized person, the act may be treated as a sham, […]

Bouncing Checks Can Cost Court Employees Their Jobs, Even Over Private Debts

A court employee’s final BP 22 conviction justified dismissal, while unpaid debt alone would have merited only a reprimand for a first offense. Public employees, especially court personnel, can lose their government careers when a private debt becomes a final criminal conviction for bouncing checks. In Vitor v. Zafra, the Supreme Court drew a sharp […]

Winning a Case Is Not Enough: Sheriffs Can Be Disciplined for Letting Judgments Go Unenforced

Sheriffs must promptly enforce writs of execution. Unexplained delay can lead to liability, but bribery claims still require substantial evidence. A court victory becomes meaningless when the winning party cannot actually recover the property, enforce the judgment, or obtain the relief already awarded. In Miranda v. Raymundo, Jr., the Supreme Court emphasized a practical rule […]