A Lawyer’s Criminal Conviction Can End the Right to Practice Law

A lawyer convicted of homicide may be disbarred when the facts show moral turpitude; commutation does not restore the privilege to practice law. A final conviction for a crime involving moral turpitude can cost a lawyer the privilege to practice law, even when the underlying offense is homicide and even when the lawyer later receives […]

Foreign Ownership Can Be Traced Through Corporate Layers When Beneficial Control Is in Doubt

The Supreme Court allowed tracing through corporate layers when foreign control is in doubt, disqualifying mining firms despite apparent 60-40 ownership. Corporations operating in partly nationalized industries cannot rely on paper compliance alone: when the apparent 60-40 Filipino ownership structure is clouded by foreign funding, control, or beneficial ownership, regulators and courts may look through […]

CWT Refund Proof Rule: Annual ITR Can Win a Tax Refund

Annual ITR evidence may prove no CWT carry-over, allowing taxpayers to recover valid refunds despite missing quarterly returns. The CWT Refund Proof Rule protects taxpayers from losing valid refund claims merely because they did not present every quarterly return, so long as they can prove by competent evidence that excess creditable withholding taxes were not […]

Bad-Faith Closure Dismissal: When Business Losses Cannot Hide Illegal Termination

Business closure cannot justify dismissal without bona fide losses; belated abandonment and loss-of-confidence charges may prove illegal termination. Bad-faith closure dismissal is illegal when an employer uses an alleged shutdown, abandonment charge, or loss-of-confidence accusation as a device to remove an employee without proving a genuine authorized or just cause. For Philippine employers, the ruling […]

When Court Cash Bonds Go Missing: Why Restitution Does Not Erase Liability for Public Funds

Court employees handling cash bonds and fiduciary funds remain liable for delayed deposits and shortages even after restitution, risking forfeiture of benefits. Court personnel who receive cash bonds, filing fees, and fiduciary funds cannot cure years of non-remittance simply by paying the money back after an audit. The doctrine is straightforward but severe: public funds […]

When Your Lawyer Gets Suspended, Your Case Cannot Be Left Behind

A lawyer’s suspension does not end client duties. The Court imposed a five-year suspension for gross negligence, noncommunication, and ignored court orders. A lawyer who becomes unable to continue representing a client cannot simply disappear from the case. Even suspension from the practice of law does not erase the lawyer’s duty to protect the client […]

Unauthorized Notarization Can Cost a Lawyer Both the Notarial Commission and the Right to Practice

Unauthorized notarization can lead to lawyer suspension and permanent loss of notarial authority when done without a valid commission or outside jurisdiction. A notarized document is not automatically safe merely because it bears a lawyer’s signature and notarial seal. When a lawyer notarizes without a valid commission, outside the authorized territorial jurisdiction, or after the […]

When a Lawyer Acts for a Dead Client, Court Filings Can Become Professional Misconduct

A lawyer was suspended for filing execution papers for a client he knew had died, reinforcing counsel’s duty to disclose death and prove authority. A lawyer who continues to act in court for a client known to be dead risks more than a defective filing. The act may become professional misconduct when the lawyer fails […]

Tax Treaty Refund Rule: BIR Prior Filing Cannot Defeat Relief

Treaty-rate tax refunds cannot be denied solely for missed prior BIR filing when entitlement is proven and refund claims are timely filed. Taxpayers who overpaid withholding tax because they failed to apply a treaty rate in time may still recover the excess tax if they are genuinely entitled to treaty relief. The Tax Treaty Refund […]