Just Compensation Proof Rule: Who Gets Paid in Expropriation Cases

Just compensation covers proven land value and improvements, not excavated soil; disputed owners must prove title before payment is released. The Just Compensation Proof Rule means that landowners in Philippine expropriation cases may recover the fair market value of the land and proven improvements, but not speculative add-ons such as separately priced excavated soil, and […]

When a Contractor Is Just a Labor Supplier, the Principal Employer Pays

Labor-only contracting can make the principal employer solidarily liable for unpaid wages and illegal dismissal when the contractor lacks real capital or independence. Workers assigned through a contractor are not always limited to suing the contractor that signed their papers. When the contractor lacks substantial capital, tools, equipment, or an independent workplace, and the workers […]

A General Manager Is Not a Corporate Officer Unless the By-Laws Say So

A general manager not listed in corporate by-laws remains an employee; closure was valid, but lack of notice required separation pay and damages. Companies cannot move an executive’s dismissal out of the labor system simply by calling that person a corporate officer. If the position is not expressly listed in the by-laws as a corporate […]

Revenue Target Due Process: BOC Attrition Upheld

Revenue target attrition is valid for BIR and BOC employees if standards, relevant factors, due process, and appeal rights are preserved. Revenue Target Due Process is the rule that government revenue officers may be subjected to performance-based removal laws, but only when Congress supplies clear standards, the agency considers relevant factors, and the employee retains […]

Alienable Land Proof Rule: Why Long Possession Is Not Enough

Long possession cannot register public land unless alienable status and possession since June 12, 1945 are clearly proven. Land possession alone does not create ownership when the property remains part of the public domain. Under the Alienable Land Proof Rule, a claimant seeking judicial confirmation of title must first prove, through clear and official government […]

When a Tax Sale Buyer Still Cannot Register the Land

A tax sale buyer’s rights do not guarantee registered title unless the land is clearly identified and proven alienable, disposable, and registrable. A failed redemption of tax-delinquent real property does not automatically settle ownership, and even a successful bidder at a real property tax auction cannot obtain registered title unless the land is proven registrable, […]

When Land Sale Proceeds Replace Land: Tax and Corporate Lessons from Hacienda Luisita

Hacienda Luisita clarifies when land sale proceeds replace agrarian land, what deductions apply, and why corporate form cannot defeat beneficiary rights. Corporate landowners cannot use corporate-law formalities to keep sale proceeds from property that should have gone to agrarian reform beneficiaries. When land covered by agrarian reform is validly sold or expropriated before actual distribution, […]

Court Delays Caused by Missing Transcripts Can Be Judicial Misconduct

Court stenographer suspended for transcript delays and improper fee handling, while extortion claims failed for lack of substantial evidence. Court personnel who delay transcripts of stenographic notes can face serious administrative discipline even when more sensational accusations, such as extortion or arrogant behavior, are not proven. For litigants, lawyers, and parties waiting for rulings, this […]

When a Judge Delays a Case, Retirement Will Not Erase Accountability

A judge who failed to decide a submitted case for years was fined despite retirement, confirming that judicial delay violates speedy disposition rights. A judge who lets a case sit unresolved beyond the constitutional deadline may still be disciplined even after retirement, and the penalty may be taken directly from retirement benefits. For litigants, the […]