A general manager not listed in corporate by-laws remains an employee; closure was valid, but lack of notice required separation pay and damages.
Companies cannot move an executive’s dismissal out of the labor system simply by calling that person a corporate officer. If the position is not expressly listed in the by-laws as a corporate office, the person holding it may still be treated as an employee, with the right to bring a termination dispute before the Labor Arbiter and to recover separation pay and statutory damages when the employer closes without proper notice.
Why This Ruling Matters to Employers and Executives
The doctrine may be called the By-Laws Control Rule for Corporate Officers. For Philippine corporations, it means that titles, board resolutions, and high-level responsibilities are not enough. A general manager, managing director, or senior executive becomes a corporate officer for jurisdictional purposes only when the Corporation Code or the corporation’s own by-laws give that position the character of a corporate office.
The practical consequence is significant. If the person is truly a corporate officer, disputes over removal are treated as intra-corporate controversies cognizable by the Regional Trial Court. If the person is merely an employee, even a high-ranking one, the dismissal dispute belongs to the Labor Arbiter. That difference affects forum, procedure, remedies, litigation strategy, and potential personal exposure of corporate officers who carried out the dismissal.
Background: A Family Corporation, a General Manager, and a Business Closure
Marc II Marketing, Inc. was organized to engage in the buying, marketing, selling, and distribution of household appliances and other products. Alfredo Joson served as its General Manager, and he was also an incorporator, director, and stockholder. Before the corporation was incorporated, he had entered into a Management Contract under the letterhead of Marc Marketing, Inc., providing that he would receive 30% of net income or net profit for his work as General Manager.
After Marc II Marketing was incorporated, Alfredo continued working as General Manager. The corporation’s by-laws expressly listed its corporate officers as Chairman, President, one or more Vice-Presidents, Treasurer, and Secretary. The by-laws also contained an enabling clause allowing the Board to appoint such other officers as it deemed necessary or proper. Petitioners relied on an undated Secretary’s Certificate stating that the Board had appointed Alfredo as a corporate officer with the title of General Manager. The dispute reached the Supreme Court in Marc II Marketing, Inc. v. Joson (G.R. No. 171993), decided on December 12, 2011.
The Supreme Court’s Core Ruling
The Court held that Alfredo was not a corporate officer of Marc II Marketing because the position of General Manager was not expressly included in the corporation’s by-laws. The Board’s alleged resolution appointing him as General Manager could not, by itself, convert that position into a corporate office. Under the Court’s reading of the Corporation Code, corporate officers are those named by law or by the by-laws; the Board may create appointive positions, but the occupants of those positions are not automatically corporate officers.
The Court emphasized that allowing a board to create corporate offices through a general enabling clause would create a dangerous loophole. A corporation could evade labor protections by reclassifying employees as corporate officers without formally amending its by-laws. That would undermine the constitutional guarantee of security of tenure.
Because Alfredo was not a corporate officer, his dismissal as General Manager was not an intra-corporate controversy. The case properly belonged to the Labor Arbiter, not the Regional Trial Court sitting as a special commercial court.
Being a Stockholder or Director Did Not Automatically Make the Dispute Intra-Corporate
The Court also rejected the argument that Alfredo’s status as stockholder and director automatically made the controversy intra-corporate. Not every dispute between a stockholder and a corporation is an intra-corporate case. Courts must look at both the relationship of the parties and the nature of the controversy.
Here, the dispute concerned Alfredo’s dismissal from his position as General Manager. There was no showing that his termination as General Manager also removed him as director or stockholder. There was also no adequate basis to conclude that his profit-sharing claim arose from ownership rather than from his management work. The Court therefore treated the controversy as a labor dispute arising from employment, not a corporate governance dispute arising from shareholding or board membership.
Closure of Business Was Valid, But the Dismissal Still Violated Statutory Due Process
The Court then turned to the legality of the dismissal. Marc II Marketing had ceased business operations on June 30, 1997, citing poor sales collection and inefficient management. The Court recognized that an employer may close or cease business operations as an authorized cause under the Labor Code, even if the closure is not due to serious business losses, so long as the closure is bona fide and not intended to defeat employees’ tenure rights.
However, closure has mandatory consequences. For a valid cessation of business operations not due to serious business losses, the employer must give written notice to the affected employees and the Department of Labor and Employment at least one month before the intended closure; the closure must be bona fide; and the employer must pay separation pay equivalent to one month pay or at least one-half month pay for every year of service, whichever is higher.
Marc II Marketing failed on two critical points. Alfredo and the DOLE were not given the required one-month written notice, and Alfredo was not paid separation pay. The Court therefore held that the dismissal was based on an authorized cause but was carried out without proper observance of statutory due process. As a result, Alfredo was entitled to separation pay and P50,000.00 in nominal damages.
Why the Pre-Incorporation Management Contract Did Not Control the Computation
The Court also ruled that the Management Contract executed before Marc II Marketing’s incorporation could not bind the corporation. A private corporation obtains juridical personality only from the issuance of its certificate of incorporation. A contract entered into before incorporation does not automatically bind the later corporation unless it is adopted, ratified, or confirmed.
Because there was no proof that Marc II Marketing adopted or ratified the Management Contract, the 30% net profit arrangement could not be used as the basis for computing Alfredo’s separation pay. The Court remanded the case to the Labor Arbiter solely to determine the compensation Alfredo actually received as General Manager, which would then be used to compute the proper separation pay.
Personal Liability of the Corporate President
The Court affirmed the solidary liability of Lucila Joson, the corporation’s President. Ordinarily, corporate officers are not personally liable for official acts because the corporation has a personality separate from its officers and stockholders. But the Court found bad faith and malice in the manner the dismissal was carried out: Alfredo was dismissed outright on the same day the corporation decided to cease operations, without the required prior notice and without separation pay.
This aspect of the ruling is important for business owners and corporate officers. The corporate veil does not always protect decision-makers who personally implement dismissals in bad faith or in violation of statutory labor protections. A closure may be lawful as a business decision, but the manner of termination can still expose the corporation and responsible officers to liability.
Practical Lessons for Philippine Corporations
First, corporations should review their by-laws before treating senior personnel as corporate officers. A title such as General Manager or Managing Director is not decisive. If the position is not in the by-laws, the safer assumption is that the person may be considered an employee for labor-law purposes.
Second, board resolutions should not be used as shortcuts for by-law amendments. If the corporation wants a position to be a true corporate office, the by-laws must be properly amended in accordance with law. Otherwise, the company may find itself litigating in the labor forum despite believing it had an intra-corporate controversy.
Third, business closure requires advance planning. Even when the closure is genuine, employers must serve written notice on both the affected employees and the DOLE at least one month before the intended date, and must pay the required separation pay unless serious business losses or financial reverses are sufficiently proven.
Finally, pre-incorporation contracts should be handled carefully. Promoters, founders, and incoming executives often sign agreements before the company legally exists. Those agreements should be expressly adopted or superseded after incorporation if the parties intend the corporation to be bound.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises corporations, executives, founders, and shareholders on the overlap between labor law and corporate governance. We assist clients in drafting by-laws, structuring executive appointments, documenting board action, handling business closures, and defending or prosecuting employment and intra-corporate disputes.
For companies facing executive termination issues, business closure concerns, or disputes over whether a case belongs before the Labor Arbiter or the commercial courts, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com for focused, litigation-ready legal guidance.