Equitable Mortgage Rule: When a Sale Is Really a Loan Security

A pacto de retro sale may be treated as an equitable mortgage when possession, taxes, and conduct show it secured a loan. Property owners who sign a deed of sale with right to repurchase may still prove that the transaction was only an equitable mortgage if the surrounding facts show that the document was meant […]

When a Lawyer Refiles a Lost Case, Final Judgment Means Final Judgment

A lawyer was suspended for refiling an illegal dismissal case already finally decided, reinforcing res judicata, forum shopping rules, and final judgment protection. A lawyer cannot restart a finished case simply because the client still believes the earlier ruling was wrong. Once a judgment becomes final, filing a new complaint involving the same parties, facts, […]

Tax Carry-Over Irrevocability: Why Refund Claims Can Be Lost

Corporate taxpayers that choose carry-over for excess income tax credits cannot later claim a refund for the same amount under Section 76. The Tax Carry-Over Irrevocability Doctrine means that a corporation that chooses to carry over excess income tax credits cannot later convert that same carried-over amount into a cash refund or tax credit certificate […]

Assessed Value Jurisdiction: Where to File Possession Cases

Accion publiciana jurisdiction depends on assessed value: Metro Manila property cases at P50,000 or below belong in first-level courts, not RTCs. Property owners filing an accion publiciana must first check the assessed value in the tax declaration, not merely the nature of the possession dispute. Under the assessed value jurisdiction doctrine, even a plenary action […]

DST Refund Proof Rule: Why Tax Refund Claims Need Clear Evidence

Taxpayers claiming DST refunds must prove the tax base, rate, payment, and overpayment clearly; unsupported BIR certifications are not enough. The DST Refund Proof Rule makes one point unmistakable for taxpayers: a refund claim is not won by showing that a payment looks excessive, but by proving with clear records why the tax was legally […]

Punitive Damages in Corporate Disputes Cannot Be Collected While the Appeal Is Still Pending

The Court ruled that exemplary damages and attorneyโ€™s fees in intra-corporate cases cannot be immediately executed while appeal remains pending. Parties who win an intra-corporate case cannot immediately collect exemplary damages or attorneyโ€™s fees while the losing sideโ€™s appeal remains pending. Even when corporate dispute decisions are generally immediately executory, punitive and discretionary monetary awards […]

Church Corporations Can Change Their Structure Without Dissolving First

Religious corporations may convert from corporation sole to aggregate by amended articles, preserving continuity without dissolution when approvals are met. A religious corporation organized as a corporation sole does not necessarily have to die before it can become a corporation aggregate. When the required corporate approvals are obtained and the amendment serves a legitimate purpose, […]

Beneficial Trust Tax Refund Rule: When Title Is Not Tax Ownership

Tax ownership may follow beneficial trust rights, not title alone; employeesโ€™ trust funds can recover tax wrongly withheld on property sale income. Beneficial owners can claim tax relief even when the Torrens title stands in another partyโ€™s name, if the evidence shows that the titled owner merely held the property in trust. The Beneficial Trust […]