Retirement Trusts Can Recover Withheld Tax When Property Is Held in Another Name

A tax-exempt employees’ trust may recover withholding tax when it proves beneficial ownership of property titled in another company’s name. A tax-exempt employees’ retirement trust does not lose its exemption, or its right to a refund, merely because the real property it beneficially owns is registered and sold in another company’s name. When co-owners agree […]

Alluvial Accretion Ownership: When Creekside Land Becomes Private

Creekside accreted land may be private property, not public land, when ownership arises through accretion, possession, and prescription. Alluvial accretion ownership can protect a landholder from eviction when land gradually forms beside a creek and the possessor has exercised long, open, and exclusive control over it. For property owners, the practical lesson is direct: registration […]

When Suspicion Is Not Enough: How Corporations Must Prove Fraud in Share Transfers

Suspicion alone cannot void a share transfer. Fraud must be proven clearly, and stock ownership may exist before the certificate is issued. A corporation that suspects insider dealing in the sale and resale of its shares cannot recover damages or undo the transaction on suspicion alone. Fraud must be pleaded and proven by clear and […]

Real Party in Interest Rule: Why Property Appeals Can Fail

Only a real party in interest may appeal a property ruling; heirs without present title or legal interest cannot revive land claims. The real party in interest rule can defeat even a long-running property claim: a litigant who no longer has a present, substantial legal interest in the land cannot continue appealing simply because he […]

Corporate Lawsuits Can Be Dismissed When the Signatory Has No Board Authority

A corporation’s complaint may be dismissed if the person signing for it lacks proven board authority, even in urgent injunction and business disputes. A corporation that sues in court must show that the person signing and filing the case was authorized by its board; otherwise, even a potentially serious business dispute can be dismissed before […]

Tax Refund Proof Rule: Why Refund Claims Fail Without Evidence

Tax refund claimants must prove declared income and withholding; BIR inaction alone does not entitle taxpayers to a refund in the Philippines. The Tax Refund Proof Rule makes one point unmistakable: a taxpayer does not win a refund simply because the Bureau of Internal Revenue failed to disprove the claim. In Philippine tax litigation, the […]

Court Employees Cannot Broker Property Titling Deals: The Simple Misconduct Rule for Private Transactions

Court personnel may be suspended for private property-titling dealings involving solicitation and misrepresentation, though money recovery needs a separate case. People dealing with court employees should not assume that a judiciary employee may safely facilitate land titling, survey work, or other private transactions simply because the employee works inside the court system. The controlling lesson […]

Minimum Corporate Income Tax Rule: Why MCIT and Real Estate CWT Stand

MCIT and real estate CWT are valid tax measures; corporations must prove actual confiscation to defeat Philippine tax laws on due process grounds. The Minimum Corporate Income Tax Rule means that a corporation cannot defeat income taxation merely by repeatedly reporting zero or negative taxable income when its gross income shows continuing business activity. For […]