When a Pending Certiorari Petition Does Not Stop a Case: Why Courts Must Still Act Unless Restrained

Certiorari does not automatically stop proceedings. Courts must act unless restrained, and undue delay in resolving motions may be sanctioned. A pending petition for certiorari does not automatically freeze proceedings in the lower court or appellate court. Unless the higher court issues a temporary restraining order or writ of preliminary injunction, judges and justices must […]

When Sheriffs Ask for Cash: Why Court Execution Expenses Must Go Through the Clerk of Court

Sheriffs cannot demand or receive direct cash for writ execution. Expenses must be court-approved, deposited with the Clerk of Court, receipted, and liquidated. Parties who win a case do not have to hand cash directly to a sheriff just to enforce a judgment. When execution, demolition, levy, or service of court processes requires expenses, the […]

Legal Interest Rule: Who May Protest Real Property Tax Assessments

Only owners or persons with legal interest may protest real property tax; contractual tax liability alone gives no appeal right. The legal interest rule in Philippine real property tax litigation means that a party cannot challenge a local tax assessment merely because it agreed by contract to shoulder the tax. To protest an assessment, the […]

Cooperative Deposit Tax Exemption: SC Shields Member Interest Income

Cooperative member deposit interest is exempt from 20% final withholding tax; SC cancelled the BIR deficiency tax assessment. Cooperative deposit tax exemption means a duly registered credit cooperative need not withhold 20% final tax on interest earned from its membersโ€™ savings and time deposits. For cooperatives and their members, the ruling confirms that member transactions […]

Pawn Ticket DST Rule: When Pawnshops Owe Tax and Penalties Fall

Pawnshops owe documentary stamp tax on pawn tickets, but 1999 VAT and good-faith tax penalties may be cancelled under Philippine tax law. Pawnshops may defeat a VAT assessment for years when Congress deferred VAT collection, but they cannot treat pawn tickets as tax-free paper. The Pawn Ticket DST Rule means that a pawn ticket, even […]

When BIR Paperwork Saves a Taxpayer: Voluntary Assessment Protection Requires Strict Registry Compliance

The Supreme Court cancelled BIR deficiency assessments because the taxpayer was not disqualified from VAP without proper registry recording. A taxpayer who comes forward under a voluntary assessment program may still be protected from deficiency assessments and related civil or criminal consequences if the BIR failed to complete the exact disqualification steps required by its […]

When a Corporation in Liquidation Must Pay the Liquidatorโ€™s Fee

The Supreme Court held that the SEC may fix a reasonable liquidatorโ€™s fee and a corporation cannot avoid payment by refusing to agree on compensation. Corporations placed under liquidation cannot avoid paying a court- or agency-appointed liquidator simply by refusing to negotiate the amount of compensation. When the liquidator has actually performed the work, and […]

Court Investigations Are Built Before the Case Begins: Why Training Orders Matter to Litigants

Supreme Court authorization of investigative training shows how official court fact-finding supports litigation, tax disputes, and administrative accountability. Investigations inside the judiciary are not treated as casual administrative errands: when the Supreme Court directs selected court lawyers and personnel to undergo investigative training as official business, it signals that court discipline, case management, and fact-finding […]

Beneficial Use Tax Rule: Who Pays Real Property Tax in PH

Tax-exempt government property may still trigger real property tax when a taxable private lessee has beneficial use, but levy on GSIS property is barred. The Beneficial Use Tax Rule protects government instrumentalities from local real property tax liability, but shifts the tax burden to the private party that actually uses government property. For cities, taxpayers, […]

Constructive Trust in Land Titles: When Torrens Title Must Yield

Torrens title cannot protect a buyer who ignores occupants and warning signs; proven possession may justify reconveyance under constructive trust. Constructive trust in land titles means that a Torrens title does not automatically defeat a true owner who can prove prior possession, inheritance, fraud, or mistake. For property owners, buyers, and families dealing with inherited […]