The Supreme Court cancelled BIR deficiency assessments because the taxpayer was not disqualified from VAP without proper registry recording.
A taxpayer who comes forward under a voluntary assessment program may still be protected from deficiency assessments and related civil or criminal consequences if the BIR failed to complete the exact disqualification steps required by its own rules. In Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Ariete, the Supreme Court held that even a taxpayer already under investigation could avail of the Voluntary Assessment Program because the verified information against her was not duly recorded in the BIRโs Official Registry Book before she filed under the program.
The Registry Requirement Doctrine
The core doctrine of Ariete is simple but powerful: when a BIR issuance says that a taxpayer is excluded from a tax relief program only if several conditions are present, the government must prove every condition. The Court treated the word