Prior Public Hearing Rule: When LGU Charges Become Void

LGU fees and market stall charges are void if imposed without a valid prior public hearing required by the Local Government Code. Local governments cannot impose market stall rentals, goodwill fees, or similar business charges by ordinance unless affected parties first receive the public hearing required by law. The Prior Public Hearing Rule means that […]

Third-Party Mortgage Priority: When Labor Execution Cannot Reach Assets

Prior registered mortgage rights can defeat later labor execution when assets belong to a third-party claimant, not the judgment debtor. The third-party mortgage priority doctrine protects a non-party mortgagee from having its mortgaged or foreclosed assets seized to satisfy another company’s labor judgment, even where the labor award itself is valid and final. For businesses, […]

Agrarian Foreclosure Bar: Why Banks Cannot Seize Farmer Lands

Agrarian reform lands under PD 27 cannot be privately foreclosed; banks may recover loans but cannot seize farmer-beneficiary titles. Agrarian reform lands awarded under Presidential Decree No. 27 cannot be foreclosed by ordinary creditor-banks, even when the farmer-beneficiary used the land documents as loan collateral. The Agrarian Foreclosure Bar protects farmer-beneficiaries from losing land reform […]

Privatization Does Not Erase Pending Government Employee Disciplinary Appeals

Privatization does not erase pending CSC appeals involving acts committed while a corporation was still government-owned; jurisdiction once acquired continues. When a government-owned corporation is privatized, its employees may fall under private-sector labor rules going forward, but pending civil service disciplinary appeals do not disappear. A government employee who appealed to the Civil Service Commission […]

Corporate Officers Can Be Personally Liable for Bad Faith Management Without Piercing the Corporate Veil

Corporate officers may be personally liable for bad faith or gross negligence under Section 31, even without piercing the corporate veil. Corporate officers cannot hide behind the corporation when they personally manage corporate affairs in bad faith or with gross negligence. A creditor, government agency, stockholder, member, or other injured party may recover damages directly […]

OSG Appellate Counsel Rule: Criminal Appeals Need State Due Process

Criminal appeals require notice to the OSG; an acquittal issued without State due process may be void and remanded. The OSG Appellate Counsel Rule means that an accused cannot secure an appellate acquittal in a criminal case without giving the People of the Philippines, through the Office of the Solicitor General, a fair opportunity to […]

Transitional Input Tax Credit Rule: VAT Refunds for Real Estate Dealers

Real estate dealers may claim transitional input tax credits on land inventory when the tax law allows it; BIR rules cannot narrow the statute. Real estate developers and other newly VAT-registered businesses may claim transitional input tax credits based on their beginning inventory when the tax law allows it, and the Bureau of Internal Revenue […]

When a Former Company Lawyer May Still Represent the Other Side

A former company lawyer was not disciplined because no confidential corporate secret or prohibited conflict was proven in the later adverse representation. A former corporate lawyer does not automatically commit a conflict of interest merely because he later appears for someone sued by his former client. The decisive question is narrower: did the lawyer use […]

Unregistered Land Sale Rule: Why Recording Protects Property Rights

Unregistered land sales bind only the parties unless recorded; an unrecorded deed cannot defeat third-party property claims. The Unregistered Land Sale Rule means that a buyer of unregistered land cannot rely on a private, unrecorded deed to defeat the rights of third persons. For property owners, heirs, and buyers in Philippine real estate disputes, the […]

Land Registration Proof Rule: Tax Receipts Do Not Prove Ownership

Tax receipts and vague witness memories do not prove land ownership; applicants must show qualifying possession since June 12, 1945. Property buyers cannot secure a Philippine land title merely by presenting a deed of sale, recent tax declarations, or witnesses who vaguely remember that an ancestor possessed the land decades ago. The Land Registration Proof […]