Church Property Disputes: Why Possession Cases Can Move Forward Even While Ownership Is Being Challenged

A church could pursue ejectment despite ownership and corporate-status disputes because unlawful detainer resolves physical possession, not final title. A person allowed to occupy property only because of an office, assignment, or position may be ejected once that authority ends, even if he later raises a separate ownership or corporate-control dispute. For property owners, religious […]

HMO DST Exemption Rule: When Health Plans Are Not Insurance

HMOs providing prepaid health services are not insurers for DST purposes when service, not indemnity, is the agreement’s principal object. Health maintenance organizations are not automatically insurance companies for tax purposes, and their prepaid health care agreements cannot be subjected to documentary stamp tax unless the law clearly treats them as insurance policies. The HMO […]

Possession by Tolerance Rule: File Ejectment in the Proper Court

Possession by tolerance after demand is unlawful detainer, not RTC recovery; filing in the wrong court makes proceedings void. The Possession by Tolerance Rule can defeat a property owner’s case before the merits are even reached: when occupants originally stayed with the owner’s permission and are later asked to leave, the case may be unlawful […]

When Employees Accept CBA Payments, Do They Waive the Right to Claim More?

Employees who accept CBA payments do not automatically waive further claims, but signing bonuses remain discretionary absent a successfully negotiated CBA. Employees who accept wage increases or benefits during a labor dispute do not automatically waive their right to pursue additional lawful benefits, especially where the payment is received under economic pressure and the union […]

When Public Levy Funds Become Corporate Shares: The Supreme Court’s Rule on Preserving Sequestered Assets

The Court allowed PCGG to convert sequestered SMC shares into preferred shares, treating coconut levy assets as public funds under court control. Sequestered corporate assets purchased with public levy funds may be converted into a safer financial instrument when the conversion clearly preserves value, improves expected returns, and remains under court supervision. For coconut levy […]

Actual Occupation Rule: Why Possession Alone Cannot Register Land

Land title applicants must prove actual occupation, not mere possession, since June 12, 1945 to confirm imperfect title over public land. The Actual Occupation Rule makes land registration harder for applicants who rely only on inherited claims, old documents, or general statements of possession. To confirm imperfect title over public land, a claimant must prove […]

Property Prescription Rule: When Delay Defeats Heirs’ Land Claims

Heirs may lose land claims when buyers possess openly, pay taxes, and act as owners long enough to acquire property by prescription. Long, open, and owner-like possession can defeat even an heir’s belated property claim when the possessor held the land in good faith, under a deed, paid real property taxes, and acted as owner […]

Forged Deed No Title Rule: Recovering Fraudulent Land Titles

A forged deed conveys no land title; fraudulent Torrens registration may be cancelled through reconveyance in Philippine property disputes. The Forged Deed No Title Rule protects landowners from losing property merely because a forged document was registered first. In Philippine property disputes, a Torrens title is powerful, but it is not a license to profit […]

Indigent Legal Aid Clients Can File Cases Without Paying Court Fees

Indigent IBP legal aid clients may file court cases without paying legal fees upfront, subject to means and merit tests and safeguards against abuse. Qualified indigent clients of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines legal aid system may now pursue court cases without first paying filing, docket, appeal, mediation, sheriff’s, stenographer’s, and other legal fees. […]

Free Patent Fraud Rule: When a Torrens Title Cannot Be Cancelled

A free patent title stands unless actual extrinsic fraud is proven; tax declarations alone cannot defeat a registered Torrens title. The Free Patent Fraud Rule protects registered land titles from cancellation unless the challenger proves actual and extrinsic fraud—not merely older tax declarations, private deeds of sale, or competing claims of possession. For property owners, […]